Social media in the lives of adolescents

Article Type
Changed
Tue, 07/12/2022 - 14:05

Adolescence is a time of growing autonomy fueled by puberty, intellectual development, and identity formation. Social media engages adolescents by giving them easy access to (semi) private communication with peers, the ability to safely explore their sexuality, and easily investigate issues of intellectual curiosity, as they move from childhood to older adolescence. Social media facilitates the creation of a teenager’s own world, separate and distinct from adult concern or scrutiny. It is clearly compelling for adolescents, but we are in the early days of understanding the effect of various types of digital activities on the health and well-being of youth. There is evidence that for some, the addictive potential of these applications is potent, exacerbating or triggering mood, anxiety, and eating disorder symptoms. Their drive to explore their identity and relationships and their immature capacity to regulate emotions and behaviors make the risks of overuse substantial. But it would be impossible (and probably socially very costly) to simply avoid social media. So how to discuss its healthy use with your patients and their parents?

The data

Social media are digital communication platforms that allow users to build a public profile and then accumulate a network of followers, and follow other users, based on shared interests. They include FaceBook, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube, and Twitter. Surveys demonstrated that 90% of U.S. adolescents use social media, with 75% having at least one social media profile and over half visiting social media sites at least once daily. Adolescents spend over 7 hours daily on their phones, not including time devoted to online schoolwork, and 8- to 12-year-olds are not far behind at almost 5 hours of daily phone use. On average, 39% of adolescent screen time is spent on passive consumption, 26% on social media, 25% on interactive activities (browsing the web, interactive video gaming) and 3% on content creation (coding, etc). There was considerable variability in survey results, and differences between genders, with boys engaged in video games almost eight times as often as girls, and girls in social media nearly twice as often as boys.1

The research

There is a growing body of research devoted to understanding the effects of all of this digital activity on youth health and well-being.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

A large, longitudinal study of Canadian 13- to 17-year-olds found that time spent on social media or watching television was strongly associated with depressive and anxiety symptoms, with a robust dose-response relationship.2 However, causality is not clear, as anxious, shy, and depressed adolescents may use more social media as a consequence of their mood. Interestingly, there was no such relationship with mood and anxiety symptoms and time spent on video games.3 For youth with depression and anxiety, time spent on social media has been strongly associated with increased levels of self-reported distress, self-injury and suicidality, but again, causality is hard to prove.

 

 

One very large study from the United Kingdom (including more than 10,000 participants), demonstrated a strong relationship between time spent on social media and severity of depressive symptoms, with a more pronounced effect in girls than in boys.4 Many more nuanced studies have demonstrated that excessive time spent on social media, the presence of an addictive pattern of use, and the degree to which an adolescent’s sense of well-being is connected to social media are the variables that strongly predict an association with worsening depressive or anxiety symptoms.5

Several studies have demonstrated that low to moderate use of social media, and use to gather information and make plans were associated with better scores of emotional self-regulation and lower rates of depressive symptoms in teens.6 It seems safe to say that social media can be useful and fun, but that too much can be bad for you. So help your adolescent patients to expand their perspective on its use by discussing it with them.
 

Make them curious about quantity

Most teens feel they do not have enough time for all of the things they need to do, so invite them to play detective by using their phone’s applications that can track their time spent online and in different apps.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Remind them that these apps were designed to be so engaging that for some addiction is a real problem. As with tobacco, addiction is the business model by which these companies earn advertising dollars. Indeed, adolescents are the target demographic, as they are most sensitive to social rewards and are the most valuable audience for advertisers. Engage their natural suspicion of authority by pointing out that with every hour on Insta, someone else is making a lot of money. They get to choose how they want to relax, connect with friends, and explore the world, so help them to be aware of how these apps are designed to keep them from choosing.

Raise awareness of vulnerability

Adolescents who have attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder already have difficulty with impulse control and with shifting their attention to less engaging activities. Adolescents with anxiety are prone to avoid stressful situations, but still hunger for knowledge and connections. Adolescents with depression are managing low motivation and self-esteem, and the rewards of social media may keep them from exercise and actual social engagement that are critical to their treatment. Youth with eating disorders are especially prone to critical comparison of themselves to others, feeding their distorted body images. Help your patients with these common illnesses to be aware of how social media may make their treatment harder, rather than being the source of relief it may feel like.

Protect their health

For all young people, too much time spent in virtual activities and passive media consumption may not leave enough time to explore potential interests, talents, or relationships. These are important activities throughout life, but they are the central developmental tasks of adolescence. They also need 8-10 hours of sleep nightly and regular exercise. And of course, they have homework! Help them to think about how to use their time wisely to support satisfying relationships and activities, with time for relaxation and good health.

Keep parents in the room for these discussions

State that most of us have difficulty putting down our phones. Children and teens need adults who model striving for balance in all areas of choice. Just as we try to teach them to make good choices about food, getting excellent nutrition while still valuing taste and pleasure, we can talk about how to balance virtual activities with actual activities, work with play, and effort with relaxation. You can help expand your young patients’ self-awareness, acknowledge the fun and utility of their digital time, and enhance their sense of how we must all learn how to put screens down sometimes. In so doing, you can help families to ensure that they are engaging with the digital tools and toys available to all of us in ways that can support their health and well-being.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.
 

References

1. Geena Davis Institute on Gender and Media. The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Teens and Tweens, 2015.

2. Abi-Jaoude E et al. CMAJ 2020;192(6):E136-41.

3. Boers E et al. Can J Psychiatry. 2020 Mar;65(3):206-8.

4. Kelly Y et al. EClinicalMedicine. 2019 Jan 4;6:59-68.

5. Vidal C et al. Int Rev Psychiatry. 2020 May;32(3):235-53.

6. Coyne SM et al. J Res Adolescence. 2019;29(4):897-907.

Publications
Topics
Sections

Adolescence is a time of growing autonomy fueled by puberty, intellectual development, and identity formation. Social media engages adolescents by giving them easy access to (semi) private communication with peers, the ability to safely explore their sexuality, and easily investigate issues of intellectual curiosity, as they move from childhood to older adolescence. Social media facilitates the creation of a teenager’s own world, separate and distinct from adult concern or scrutiny. It is clearly compelling for adolescents, but we are in the early days of understanding the effect of various types of digital activities on the health and well-being of youth. There is evidence that for some, the addictive potential of these applications is potent, exacerbating or triggering mood, anxiety, and eating disorder symptoms. Their drive to explore their identity and relationships and their immature capacity to regulate emotions and behaviors make the risks of overuse substantial. But it would be impossible (and probably socially very costly) to simply avoid social media. So how to discuss its healthy use with your patients and their parents?

The data

Social media are digital communication platforms that allow users to build a public profile and then accumulate a network of followers, and follow other users, based on shared interests. They include FaceBook, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube, and Twitter. Surveys demonstrated that 90% of U.S. adolescents use social media, with 75% having at least one social media profile and over half visiting social media sites at least once daily. Adolescents spend over 7 hours daily on their phones, not including time devoted to online schoolwork, and 8- to 12-year-olds are not far behind at almost 5 hours of daily phone use. On average, 39% of adolescent screen time is spent on passive consumption, 26% on social media, 25% on interactive activities (browsing the web, interactive video gaming) and 3% on content creation (coding, etc). There was considerable variability in survey results, and differences between genders, with boys engaged in video games almost eight times as often as girls, and girls in social media nearly twice as often as boys.1

The research

There is a growing body of research devoted to understanding the effects of all of this digital activity on youth health and well-being.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

A large, longitudinal study of Canadian 13- to 17-year-olds found that time spent on social media or watching television was strongly associated with depressive and anxiety symptoms, with a robust dose-response relationship.2 However, causality is not clear, as anxious, shy, and depressed adolescents may use more social media as a consequence of their mood. Interestingly, there was no such relationship with mood and anxiety symptoms and time spent on video games.3 For youth with depression and anxiety, time spent on social media has been strongly associated with increased levels of self-reported distress, self-injury and suicidality, but again, causality is hard to prove.

 

 

One very large study from the United Kingdom (including more than 10,000 participants), demonstrated a strong relationship between time spent on social media and severity of depressive symptoms, with a more pronounced effect in girls than in boys.4 Many more nuanced studies have demonstrated that excessive time spent on social media, the presence of an addictive pattern of use, and the degree to which an adolescent’s sense of well-being is connected to social media are the variables that strongly predict an association with worsening depressive or anxiety symptoms.5

Several studies have demonstrated that low to moderate use of social media, and use to gather information and make plans were associated with better scores of emotional self-regulation and lower rates of depressive symptoms in teens.6 It seems safe to say that social media can be useful and fun, but that too much can be bad for you. So help your adolescent patients to expand their perspective on its use by discussing it with them.
 

Make them curious about quantity

Most teens feel they do not have enough time for all of the things they need to do, so invite them to play detective by using their phone’s applications that can track their time spent online and in different apps.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Remind them that these apps were designed to be so engaging that for some addiction is a real problem. As with tobacco, addiction is the business model by which these companies earn advertising dollars. Indeed, adolescents are the target demographic, as they are most sensitive to social rewards and are the most valuable audience for advertisers. Engage their natural suspicion of authority by pointing out that with every hour on Insta, someone else is making a lot of money. They get to choose how they want to relax, connect with friends, and explore the world, so help them to be aware of how these apps are designed to keep them from choosing.

Raise awareness of vulnerability

Adolescents who have attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder already have difficulty with impulse control and with shifting their attention to less engaging activities. Adolescents with anxiety are prone to avoid stressful situations, but still hunger for knowledge and connections. Adolescents with depression are managing low motivation and self-esteem, and the rewards of social media may keep them from exercise and actual social engagement that are critical to their treatment. Youth with eating disorders are especially prone to critical comparison of themselves to others, feeding their distorted body images. Help your patients with these common illnesses to be aware of how social media may make their treatment harder, rather than being the source of relief it may feel like.

Protect their health

For all young people, too much time spent in virtual activities and passive media consumption may not leave enough time to explore potential interests, talents, or relationships. These are important activities throughout life, but they are the central developmental tasks of adolescence. They also need 8-10 hours of sleep nightly and regular exercise. And of course, they have homework! Help them to think about how to use their time wisely to support satisfying relationships and activities, with time for relaxation and good health.

Keep parents in the room for these discussions

State that most of us have difficulty putting down our phones. Children and teens need adults who model striving for balance in all areas of choice. Just as we try to teach them to make good choices about food, getting excellent nutrition while still valuing taste and pleasure, we can talk about how to balance virtual activities with actual activities, work with play, and effort with relaxation. You can help expand your young patients’ self-awareness, acknowledge the fun and utility of their digital time, and enhance their sense of how we must all learn how to put screens down sometimes. In so doing, you can help families to ensure that they are engaging with the digital tools and toys available to all of us in ways that can support their health and well-being.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.
 

References

1. Geena Davis Institute on Gender and Media. The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Teens and Tweens, 2015.

2. Abi-Jaoude E et al. CMAJ 2020;192(6):E136-41.

3. Boers E et al. Can J Psychiatry. 2020 Mar;65(3):206-8.

4. Kelly Y et al. EClinicalMedicine. 2019 Jan 4;6:59-68.

5. Vidal C et al. Int Rev Psychiatry. 2020 May;32(3):235-53.

6. Coyne SM et al. J Res Adolescence. 2019;29(4):897-907.

Adolescence is a time of growing autonomy fueled by puberty, intellectual development, and identity formation. Social media engages adolescents by giving them easy access to (semi) private communication with peers, the ability to safely explore their sexuality, and easily investigate issues of intellectual curiosity, as they move from childhood to older adolescence. Social media facilitates the creation of a teenager’s own world, separate and distinct from adult concern or scrutiny. It is clearly compelling for adolescents, but we are in the early days of understanding the effect of various types of digital activities on the health and well-being of youth. There is evidence that for some, the addictive potential of these applications is potent, exacerbating or triggering mood, anxiety, and eating disorder symptoms. Their drive to explore their identity and relationships and their immature capacity to regulate emotions and behaviors make the risks of overuse substantial. But it would be impossible (and probably socially very costly) to simply avoid social media. So how to discuss its healthy use with your patients and their parents?

The data

Social media are digital communication platforms that allow users to build a public profile and then accumulate a network of followers, and follow other users, based on shared interests. They include FaceBook, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube, and Twitter. Surveys demonstrated that 90% of U.S. adolescents use social media, with 75% having at least one social media profile and over half visiting social media sites at least once daily. Adolescents spend over 7 hours daily on their phones, not including time devoted to online schoolwork, and 8- to 12-year-olds are not far behind at almost 5 hours of daily phone use. On average, 39% of adolescent screen time is spent on passive consumption, 26% on social media, 25% on interactive activities (browsing the web, interactive video gaming) and 3% on content creation (coding, etc). There was considerable variability in survey results, and differences between genders, with boys engaged in video games almost eight times as often as girls, and girls in social media nearly twice as often as boys.1

The research

There is a growing body of research devoted to understanding the effects of all of this digital activity on youth health and well-being.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

A large, longitudinal study of Canadian 13- to 17-year-olds found that time spent on social media or watching television was strongly associated with depressive and anxiety symptoms, with a robust dose-response relationship.2 However, causality is not clear, as anxious, shy, and depressed adolescents may use more social media as a consequence of their mood. Interestingly, there was no such relationship with mood and anxiety symptoms and time spent on video games.3 For youth with depression and anxiety, time spent on social media has been strongly associated with increased levels of self-reported distress, self-injury and suicidality, but again, causality is hard to prove.

 

 

One very large study from the United Kingdom (including more than 10,000 participants), demonstrated a strong relationship between time spent on social media and severity of depressive symptoms, with a more pronounced effect in girls than in boys.4 Many more nuanced studies have demonstrated that excessive time spent on social media, the presence of an addictive pattern of use, and the degree to which an adolescent’s sense of well-being is connected to social media are the variables that strongly predict an association with worsening depressive or anxiety symptoms.5

Several studies have demonstrated that low to moderate use of social media, and use to gather information and make plans were associated with better scores of emotional self-regulation and lower rates of depressive symptoms in teens.6 It seems safe to say that social media can be useful and fun, but that too much can be bad for you. So help your adolescent patients to expand their perspective on its use by discussing it with them.
 

Make them curious about quantity

Most teens feel they do not have enough time for all of the things they need to do, so invite them to play detective by using their phone’s applications that can track their time spent online and in different apps.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Remind them that these apps were designed to be so engaging that for some addiction is a real problem. As with tobacco, addiction is the business model by which these companies earn advertising dollars. Indeed, adolescents are the target demographic, as they are most sensitive to social rewards and are the most valuable audience for advertisers. Engage their natural suspicion of authority by pointing out that with every hour on Insta, someone else is making a lot of money. They get to choose how they want to relax, connect with friends, and explore the world, so help them to be aware of how these apps are designed to keep them from choosing.

Raise awareness of vulnerability

Adolescents who have attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder already have difficulty with impulse control and with shifting their attention to less engaging activities. Adolescents with anxiety are prone to avoid stressful situations, but still hunger for knowledge and connections. Adolescents with depression are managing low motivation and self-esteem, and the rewards of social media may keep them from exercise and actual social engagement that are critical to their treatment. Youth with eating disorders are especially prone to critical comparison of themselves to others, feeding their distorted body images. Help your patients with these common illnesses to be aware of how social media may make their treatment harder, rather than being the source of relief it may feel like.

Protect their health

For all young people, too much time spent in virtual activities and passive media consumption may not leave enough time to explore potential interests, talents, or relationships. These are important activities throughout life, but they are the central developmental tasks of adolescence. They also need 8-10 hours of sleep nightly and regular exercise. And of course, they have homework! Help them to think about how to use their time wisely to support satisfying relationships and activities, with time for relaxation and good health.

Keep parents in the room for these discussions

State that most of us have difficulty putting down our phones. Children and teens need adults who model striving for balance in all areas of choice. Just as we try to teach them to make good choices about food, getting excellent nutrition while still valuing taste and pleasure, we can talk about how to balance virtual activities with actual activities, work with play, and effort with relaxation. You can help expand your young patients’ self-awareness, acknowledge the fun and utility of their digital time, and enhance their sense of how we must all learn how to put screens down sometimes. In so doing, you can help families to ensure that they are engaging with the digital tools and toys available to all of us in ways that can support their health and well-being.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.
 

References

1. Geena Davis Institute on Gender and Media. The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Teens and Tweens, 2015.

2. Abi-Jaoude E et al. CMAJ 2020;192(6):E136-41.

3. Boers E et al. Can J Psychiatry. 2020 Mar;65(3):206-8.

4. Kelly Y et al. EClinicalMedicine. 2019 Jan 4;6:59-68.

5. Vidal C et al. Int Rev Psychiatry. 2020 May;32(3):235-53.

6. Coyne SM et al. J Res Adolescence. 2019;29(4):897-907.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Teambase XML
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!--$RCSfile: InCopy_agile.xsl,v $ $Revision: 1.35 $-->
<!--$RCSfile: drupal.xsl,v $ $Revision: 1.7 $-->
<root generator="drupal.xsl" gversion="1.7"> <header> <fileName>158949</fileName> <TBEID>0C043C98.SIG</TBEID> <TBUniqueIdentifier>MD_0C043C98</TBUniqueIdentifier> <newsOrJournal>News</newsOrJournal> <publisherName>Frontline Medical Communications</publisherName> <storyname/> <articleType>353</articleType> <TBLocation>QC Done-All Pubs</TBLocation> <QCDate>20220712T092041</QCDate> <firstPublished>20220712T140122</firstPublished> <LastPublished>20220712T140123</LastPublished> <pubStatus qcode="stat:"/> <embargoDate/> <killDate/> <CMSDate>20220712T140122</CMSDate> <articleSource/> <facebookInfo/> <meetingNumber/> <byline>Swick and Jellinek</byline> <bylineText>SUSAN D. SWICK, MD, AND MICHAEL S. JELLINEK, MD</bylineText> <bylineFull>SUSAN D. SWICK, MD, AND MICHAEL S. JELLINEK, MD</bylineFull> <bylineTitleText/> <USOrGlobal/> <wireDocType/> <newsDocType/> <journalDocType/> <linkLabel/> <pageRange/> <citation/> <quizID/> <indexIssueDate/> <itemClass qcode="ninat:text"/> <provider qcode="provider:imng"> <name>IMNG Medical Media</name> <rightsInfo> <copyrightHolder> <name>Frontline Medical News</name> </copyrightHolder> <copyrightNotice>Copyright (c) 2015 Frontline Medical News, a Frontline Medical Communications Inc. company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, copied, or otherwise reproduced or distributed without the prior written permission of Frontline Medical Communications Inc.</copyrightNotice> </rightsInfo> </provider> <abstract/> <metaDescription>Adolescence is a time of growing autonomy fueled by puberty, intellectual development, and identity formation. Social media engages adolescents by giving them e</metaDescription> <articlePDF/> <teaserImage>236038</teaserImage> <teaser>Help your patients with common mental and emotional issues to be aware of how social media may make their treatment harder, rather than being the source of relief it may feel like. </teaser> <title>Social media in the lives of adolescents</title> <deck/> <disclaimer/> <AuthorList/> <articleURL/> <doi/> <pubMedID/> <publishXMLStatus/> <publishXMLVersion>1</publishXMLVersion> <useEISSN>0</useEISSN> <urgency/> <pubPubdateYear/> <pubPubdateMonth/> <pubPubdateDay/> <pubVolume/> <pubNumber/> <wireChannels/> <primaryCMSID/> <CMSIDs/> <keywords/> <seeAlsos/> <publications_g> <publicationData> <publicationCode>FP</publicationCode> <pubIssueName/> <pubArticleType/> <pubTopics/> <pubCategories/> <pubSections/> <journalTitle/> <journalFullTitle/> <copyrightStatement>Copyright 2017 Frontline Medical News</copyrightStatement> </publicationData> <publicationData> <publicationCode>PN</publicationCode> <pubIssueName/> <pubArticleType/> <pubTopics/> <pubCategories/> <pubSections/> <journalTitle/> <journalFullTitle/> <copyrightStatement/> </publicationData> </publications_g> <publications> <term>15</term> <term canonical="true">25</term> </publications> <sections> <term>52</term> <term>41022</term> <term canonical="true">27728</term> </sections> <topics> <term canonical="true">248</term> <term>271</term> </topics> <links> <link> <itemClass qcode="ninat:picture"/> <altRep contenttype="image/jpeg">images/2400b0fe.jpg</altRep> <description role="drol:caption">Dr. Susan D. Swick</description> <description role="drol:credit"/> </link> <link> <itemClass qcode="ninat:picture"/> <altRep contenttype="image/jpeg">images/2400cbf9.jpg</altRep> <description role="drol:caption">Dr. Michael S. Jellinek</description> <description role="drol:credit"/> </link> </links> </header> <itemSet> <newsItem> <itemMeta> <itemRole>Main</itemRole> <itemClass>text</itemClass> <title>Social media in the lives of adolescents</title> <deck/> </itemMeta> <itemContent> <p>Adolescence is a time of growing autonomy fueled by puberty, intellectual development, and identity formation. Social media engages adolescents by giving them easy access to (semi) private communication with peers, the ability to safely explore their sexuality, and easily investigate issues of intellectual curiosity, as they move from childhood to older adolescence. Social media facilitates the creation of a teenager’s own world, separate and distinct from adult concern or scrutiny. It is clearly compelling for adolescents, but we are in the early days of understanding the effect of various types of digital activities on the health and well-being of youth. There is evidence that for some, the addictive potential of these applications is potent, exacerbating or triggering mood, anxiety, and eating disorder symptoms. Their drive to explore their identity and relationships and their immature capacity to regulate emotions and behaviors make the risks of overuse substantial. But it would be impossible (and probably socially very costly) to simply avoid social media. So how to discuss its healthy use with your patients and their parents?</p> <h2>The data</h2> <p>Social media are digital communication platforms that allow users to build a public profile and then accumulate a network of followers, and follow other users, based on shared interests. They include FaceBook, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube, and Twitter. Surveys demonstrated that 90% of U.S. adolescents use social media, with 75% having at least one social media profile and over half visiting social media sites at least once daily. Adolescents spend over 7 hours daily on their phones, not including time devoted to online schoolwork, and 8- to 12-year-olds are not far behind at almost 5 hours of daily phone use. On average, 39% of adolescent screen time is spent on passive consumption, 26% on social media, 25% on interactive activities (browsing the web, interactive video gaming) and 3% on content creation (coding, etc). There was considerable variability in survey results, and differences between genders, with boys engaged in video games almost eight times as often as girls, and girls in social media nearly twice as often as boys.<sup>1</sup></p> <h2>The research</h2> <p>There is a growing body of research devoted to understanding the effects of all of this digital activity on youth health and well-being. [[{"fid":"236038","view_mode":"medstat_image_flush_left","fields":{"format":"medstat_image_flush_left","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":"Dr. Susan D. Swick, physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula.","field_file_image_credit[und][0][value]":"","field_file_image_caption[und][0][value]":"Dr. Susan D. Swick"},"type":"media","attributes":{"class":"media-element file-medstat_image_flush_left"}}]]A large, longitudinal <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://www.cmaj.ca/content/192/6/E136">study </a></span>of Canadian 13- to 17-year-olds found that time spent on social media or watching television was strongly associated with depressive and anxiety symptoms, with a robust dose-response relationship.<sup>2</sup> However, causality is not clear, as anxious, shy, and depressed adolescents may use more social media as a consequence of their mood. Interestingly, there was no such relationship with mood and anxiety symptoms and time spent on <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0706743719885486">video games</a></span>.<sup>3</sup> For youth with depression and anxiety, time spent on social media has been strongly associated with increased levels of self-reported distress, self-injury and suicidality, but again, causality is hard to prove. </p> <p>One very large study from the <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5370(18)30060-9/fulltext">United Kingdom</a></span> (including more than 10,000 participants), demonstrated a strong relationship between time spent on social media and severity of depressive symptoms, with a more pronounced effect in girls than in boys.<sup>4</sup> Many more nuanced <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09540261.2020.1720623?journalCode=iirp20">studies</a></span> have demonstrated that excessive time spent on social media, the presence of an addictive pattern of use, and the degree to which an adolescent’s sense of well-being is connected to social media are the variables that strongly predict an association with worsening depressive or anxiety symptoms.<sup>5</sup><br/><br/>Several studies have demonstrated that low to moderate use of social media, and use to gather information and make plans were associated with <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jora.12424">better scores</a></span> of emotional self-regulation and lower rates of depressive symptoms in teens.<sup>6</sup> It seems safe to say that social media can be useful and fun, but that too much can be bad for you. So help your adolescent patients to expand their perspective on its use by discussing it with them.<br/><br/> </p> <h2>Make them curious about quantity</h2> <p>Most teens feel they do not have enough time for all of the things they need to do, so invite them to play detective by using their phone’s applications that can track their time spent online and in different apps. [[{"fid":"251601","view_mode":"medstat_image_flush_left","fields":{"format":"medstat_image_flush_left","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":"Dr. Michael S. Jellinek, professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston","field_file_image_credit[und][0][value]":"","field_file_image_caption[und][0][value]":"Dr. Michael S. Jellinek"},"type":"media","attributes":{"class":"media-element file-medstat_image_flush_left"}}]]Remind them that these apps were designed to be so engaging that for some addiction is a real problem. As with tobacco, addiction is the business model by which these companies earn advertising dollars. Indeed, adolescents are the target demographic, as they are most sensitive to social rewards and are the most valuable audience for advertisers. Engage their natural suspicion of authority by pointing out that with every hour on Insta, someone else is making a lot of money. They get to choose how they want to relax, connect with friends, and explore the world, so help them to be aware of how these apps are designed to keep them from choosing.</p> <h2>Raise awareness of vulnerability</h2> <p>Adolescents who have attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder already have difficulty with impulse control and with shifting their attention to less engaging activities. Adolescents with anxiety are prone to avoid stressful situations, but still hunger for knowledge and connections. Adolescents with depression are managing low motivation and self-esteem, and the rewards of social media may keep them from exercise and actual social engagement that are critical to their treatment. Youth with eating disorders are especially prone to critical comparison of themselves to others, feeding their distorted body images. Help your patients with these common illnesses to be aware of how social media may make their treatment harder, rather than being the source of relief it may feel like.</p> <h2>Protect their health</h2> <p>For all young people, too much time spent in virtual activities and passive media consumption may not leave enough time to explore potential interests, talents, or relationships. These are important activities throughout life, but they are the central developmental tasks of adolescence. They also need 8-10 hours of sleep nightly and regular exercise. And of course, they have homework! Help them to think about how to use their time wisely to support satisfying relationships and activities, with time for relaxation and good health.</p> <h2>Keep parents in the room for these discussions </h2> <p>State that most of us have difficulty putting down our phones. Children and teens need adults who model striving for balance in all areas of choice. Just as we try to teach them to make good choices about food, getting excellent nutrition while still valuing taste and pleasure, we can talk about how to balance virtual activities with actual activities, work with play, and effort with relaxation. You can help expand your young patients’ self-awareness, acknowledge the fun and utility of their digital time, and enhance their sense of how we must all learn how to put screens down sometimes. In so doing, you can help families to ensure that they are engaging with the digital tools and toys available to all of us in ways that can support their health and well-being.</p> <p> <em>Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="mailto:pdnews%40mdedge.com?subject=">pdnews@mdedge.com</a></span>.<br/><br/></em> </p> <h2>References</h2> <p>1. Geena Davis Institute on Gender and Media. The Common Sense Census: <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://seejane.org/gender-in-media-news/the-common-sense-census-media-use-by-tweens-and-teens/#:~:text=A%20new%20landmark%20report%20released,media%20for%20school%20or%20homework.">Media Use by Teens and Tweens</a></span>, 2015.<br/><br/>2. Abi-Jaoude E et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32041697/">CMAJ 2020;192(6):E136-41</a></span>.<br/><br/>3. Boers E et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31684757/">Can J Psychiatry. 2020 Mar;65(3):206-8</a></span>.<br/><br/>4. Kelly Y et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31193561/">EClinicalMedicine. 2019 Jan 4;6:59-68</a></span>.<br/><br/>5. Vidal C et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32065542/">Int Rev Psychiatry. 2020 May;32(3):235-53</a></span>.<br/><br/>6. Coyne SM et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29953692/">J Res Adolescence. 2019;29(4):897-907</a></span>.</p> </itemContent> </newsItem> <newsItem> <itemMeta> <itemRole>teaser</itemRole> <itemClass>text</itemClass> <title/> <deck/> </itemMeta> <itemContent> </itemContent> </newsItem> </itemSet></root>
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

Anorexia nervosa in adolescent patients: What pediatricians need to know

Article Type
Changed
Tue, 05/10/2022 - 15:32

Eating disorders are among the most prevalent, disabling, and potentially fatal psychiatric illnesses, and the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated their burden, with a 15.3% increase in incidence in 2020 compared with previous years.1 This increase was almost solely among adolescent girls with anorexia nervosa (AN), which is often insidious in onset and more difficult to treat as it advances. Adolescents with AN are most likely to present to their pediatricians, so awareness and early recognition of the symptoms is critical. Pediatricians are also an integral part of the treatment team in AN and can offer monitoring for serious complications, alongside valuable guidance to parents, who are central to treatment and the reestablishment of healthy eating habits in their children. Here we will review the epidemiology, diagnosis, and treatment of anorexia, with an emphasis on what pediatricians need to know to screen and to facilitate treatment.

Epidemiology

AN is marked by a fear of gaining weight or behaviors that interfere with weight gain and a self-evaluation unduly influenced by weight and body shape. Youth with AN often deny the seriousness of their malnutrition, although that is not required for diagnosis. AN can be of a restrictive or binge-purge subtype, and amenorrhea is no longer a requirement for diagnosis. There is not a specific weight or body mass index cutoff for the diagnosis, but the severity of AN is determined by the BMI percentile normed to age and sex. The average age of onset is 18, and the prepandemic prevalence of AN was about 1% of the population. It affects about 10 times as many females as males. It is quite rare prior to puberty, affecting about 0.01% of that age group. There is a heritable component, with a fivefold relative risk in youth with a parent with AN, and twin studies suggest heritability rates as high as 75%. Youth with rigid cognitive styles appear more vulnerable, as do those who participate in activities such as ballet, gymnastics, modeling, and wrestling because of the role of appearance and weight in performance. More than half of patients with AN will have another psychiatric illness, most commonly anxiety disorders, depression, or obsessive-compulsive disorder. AN becomes chronic in up to 15% of sufferers and the mortality rate is close to 10%, with approximately half dying from medical complications and half dying by suicide.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Screening

Parents and pediatricians are usually the first to notice that a child has started to lose weight or is falling off the growth curve. But weight changes usually emerge after feelings of preoccupation with weight, body shape, and body satisfaction. If parents report escalating pickiness around food, increased or compulsive exercise, persistent self-consciousness and self-criticism around weight and body shape, it is worth starting with screening questions.

If you notice preoccupation or anxiety around being weighed, even if the weight or growth curve are still normal, it is worthwhile to screen. Screening questions, such as the SCOFF questionnaire with five simple questions, can be very sensitive for both AN and bulimia nervosa.2 There are also many validated screening instruments, such as the Eating Disorder Inventory or Eating Attitudes Test (for adolescents) and the Kids Eating Disorder Survey and the Child Eating Attitudes Test (for younger children), that are short self-reports that you can have your patients fill out when you have a higher index of suspicion. Weight loss or growth failure without a preoccupation around weight or appearance needs a thorough a medical workup, and could be a function of other psychiatric problems, such as depression.

If a child screens positive for an eating disorder, your full physical examination, growth curves, and longitudinal growth charts are critical for diagnosis. Percentile BMIs must be used, given the inaccuracy of standard BMI calculations in this age group. (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention age and sex growth charts include methods for this calculation). Laboratory assessment, including metabolic, kidney, pancreatic, and thyroid function, and an EKG can illuminate if there are consequences of restricting or purging. Of course, you want to evaluate for significant medical symptoms, including bradycardia, orthostasis, and hypokalemia. These medical symptoms are not limited to the severely underweight and merit referral to an emergency department and possible medical admission.

Then, a referral to a clinician who is expert in the assessment and treatment of eating disorders is needed. This may be a child psychiatrist, psychologist, or a colleague pediatrician with this specialization. It is also very important to begin the conversation with the family to introduce your concerns, describe what you have noticed, and discuss the need for further assessment and possibly treatment.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek


Be mindful that discussing this in front of your patient may heighten the patient’s anxiety or distress. Be prepared to offer support and understanding for your patient’s anxiety, while steadfastly providing absolute clarity for the parents about the necessity of further evaluation and treatment. Many parents will be concerned and ready to do whatever is needed to get their child’s eating and growth back on track. But some parents may have more difficulty. They may have their own history with an eating disorder. They may be avoiding a sense of shame or alarm. They may be eager to avoid adding to their child’s stress. They may be tired of engaging in power struggles with the child. They may be proud of their ambitious, accomplished young athlete. Their trust in you makes you uniquely positioned to complicate their thinking. And treatment will hinge on them, so this is a critical bridge to care.

Beyond telling parents that they will need to bring more structure and supervision to mealtimes to begin addressing their child’s nutrition, you might offer guidance on other strategies. Empower parents to limit their child’s use of social media sites such as Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok, where they may be immersed in comparing themselves to idealized (and airbrushed) influencers. Empower them to make their child’s participation in beloved sports contingent on eating meals together and completely or on a stabilized weight (as will be common in treatment). Remind them that there are no bad foods, that the goal is health, and that they are not in a power struggle with their child, but instead allied with their child to treat AN. Remind them to also look for chances to have fun with their child, to help everyone remember what matters.
 

 

 

Treatment

Family-based therapy (FBT) is the first-line treatment of shorter-duration AN in children and adolescents. It focuses on the parents, helping them to calmly and effectively manage their child’s eating behaviors until their weight and behaviors have normalized. As a patient’s nutritional status improves, so does cognitive function, emotional flexibility, and mood. Individual therapy and psychopharmacologic treatment can be very effective for comorbid anxiety, mood, attentional, and thought disorders. Family-based work does include the child and is often done in group-based settings with clinicians from multiple disciplines. Dietitians provide education and guidance about healthy nutrition to the child and parents. Therapists may work with the child, parents, or full family to focus on behavior modification and managing distress. Most academic medical centers provide access to FBT, but there are many regions with no providers of this evidence-based treatment. One of the silver linings of the COVID-19 pandemic is that several online services have emerged offering FBT, working with families to manage mealtimes and treatment entirely at home.3 Pediatricians provide regular medical checks to measure progress and help with decisions about when it is safe to permit exercise or advance privileges and independence around eating. Some pediatricians have discovered a deep interest in this area of pediatrics and built their practices on it. Given the surge in prevalence of AN and the needs for adolescent mental health services, we hope more will do so.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Taquet M et al. Br J Psychiatry. 2022;220:262-4.

2. Morgan JF et al. West J Med. 2000 Mar;172(3):164-5.

3. Matheson BE et al. Int J Eat Disord. 2020 Jul;53(7):1142-54.

Publications
Topics
Sections

Eating disorders are among the most prevalent, disabling, and potentially fatal psychiatric illnesses, and the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated their burden, with a 15.3% increase in incidence in 2020 compared with previous years.1 This increase was almost solely among adolescent girls with anorexia nervosa (AN), which is often insidious in onset and more difficult to treat as it advances. Adolescents with AN are most likely to present to their pediatricians, so awareness and early recognition of the symptoms is critical. Pediatricians are also an integral part of the treatment team in AN and can offer monitoring for serious complications, alongside valuable guidance to parents, who are central to treatment and the reestablishment of healthy eating habits in their children. Here we will review the epidemiology, diagnosis, and treatment of anorexia, with an emphasis on what pediatricians need to know to screen and to facilitate treatment.

Epidemiology

AN is marked by a fear of gaining weight or behaviors that interfere with weight gain and a self-evaluation unduly influenced by weight and body shape. Youth with AN often deny the seriousness of their malnutrition, although that is not required for diagnosis. AN can be of a restrictive or binge-purge subtype, and amenorrhea is no longer a requirement for diagnosis. There is not a specific weight or body mass index cutoff for the diagnosis, but the severity of AN is determined by the BMI percentile normed to age and sex. The average age of onset is 18, and the prepandemic prevalence of AN was about 1% of the population. It affects about 10 times as many females as males. It is quite rare prior to puberty, affecting about 0.01% of that age group. There is a heritable component, with a fivefold relative risk in youth with a parent with AN, and twin studies suggest heritability rates as high as 75%. Youth with rigid cognitive styles appear more vulnerable, as do those who participate in activities such as ballet, gymnastics, modeling, and wrestling because of the role of appearance and weight in performance. More than half of patients with AN will have another psychiatric illness, most commonly anxiety disorders, depression, or obsessive-compulsive disorder. AN becomes chronic in up to 15% of sufferers and the mortality rate is close to 10%, with approximately half dying from medical complications and half dying by suicide.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Screening

Parents and pediatricians are usually the first to notice that a child has started to lose weight or is falling off the growth curve. But weight changes usually emerge after feelings of preoccupation with weight, body shape, and body satisfaction. If parents report escalating pickiness around food, increased or compulsive exercise, persistent self-consciousness and self-criticism around weight and body shape, it is worth starting with screening questions.

If you notice preoccupation or anxiety around being weighed, even if the weight or growth curve are still normal, it is worthwhile to screen. Screening questions, such as the SCOFF questionnaire with five simple questions, can be very sensitive for both AN and bulimia nervosa.2 There are also many validated screening instruments, such as the Eating Disorder Inventory or Eating Attitudes Test (for adolescents) and the Kids Eating Disorder Survey and the Child Eating Attitudes Test (for younger children), that are short self-reports that you can have your patients fill out when you have a higher index of suspicion. Weight loss or growth failure without a preoccupation around weight or appearance needs a thorough a medical workup, and could be a function of other psychiatric problems, such as depression.

If a child screens positive for an eating disorder, your full physical examination, growth curves, and longitudinal growth charts are critical for diagnosis. Percentile BMIs must be used, given the inaccuracy of standard BMI calculations in this age group. (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention age and sex growth charts include methods for this calculation). Laboratory assessment, including metabolic, kidney, pancreatic, and thyroid function, and an EKG can illuminate if there are consequences of restricting or purging. Of course, you want to evaluate for significant medical symptoms, including bradycardia, orthostasis, and hypokalemia. These medical symptoms are not limited to the severely underweight and merit referral to an emergency department and possible medical admission.

Then, a referral to a clinician who is expert in the assessment and treatment of eating disorders is needed. This may be a child psychiatrist, psychologist, or a colleague pediatrician with this specialization. It is also very important to begin the conversation with the family to introduce your concerns, describe what you have noticed, and discuss the need for further assessment and possibly treatment.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek


Be mindful that discussing this in front of your patient may heighten the patient’s anxiety or distress. Be prepared to offer support and understanding for your patient’s anxiety, while steadfastly providing absolute clarity for the parents about the necessity of further evaluation and treatment. Many parents will be concerned and ready to do whatever is needed to get their child’s eating and growth back on track. But some parents may have more difficulty. They may have their own history with an eating disorder. They may be avoiding a sense of shame or alarm. They may be eager to avoid adding to their child’s stress. They may be tired of engaging in power struggles with the child. They may be proud of their ambitious, accomplished young athlete. Their trust in you makes you uniquely positioned to complicate their thinking. And treatment will hinge on them, so this is a critical bridge to care.

Beyond telling parents that they will need to bring more structure and supervision to mealtimes to begin addressing their child’s nutrition, you might offer guidance on other strategies. Empower parents to limit their child’s use of social media sites such as Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok, where they may be immersed in comparing themselves to idealized (and airbrushed) influencers. Empower them to make their child’s participation in beloved sports contingent on eating meals together and completely or on a stabilized weight (as will be common in treatment). Remind them that there are no bad foods, that the goal is health, and that they are not in a power struggle with their child, but instead allied with their child to treat AN. Remind them to also look for chances to have fun with their child, to help everyone remember what matters.
 

 

 

Treatment

Family-based therapy (FBT) is the first-line treatment of shorter-duration AN in children and adolescents. It focuses on the parents, helping them to calmly and effectively manage their child’s eating behaviors until their weight and behaviors have normalized. As a patient’s nutritional status improves, so does cognitive function, emotional flexibility, and mood. Individual therapy and psychopharmacologic treatment can be very effective for comorbid anxiety, mood, attentional, and thought disorders. Family-based work does include the child and is often done in group-based settings with clinicians from multiple disciplines. Dietitians provide education and guidance about healthy nutrition to the child and parents. Therapists may work with the child, parents, or full family to focus on behavior modification and managing distress. Most academic medical centers provide access to FBT, but there are many regions with no providers of this evidence-based treatment. One of the silver linings of the COVID-19 pandemic is that several online services have emerged offering FBT, working with families to manage mealtimes and treatment entirely at home.3 Pediatricians provide regular medical checks to measure progress and help with decisions about when it is safe to permit exercise or advance privileges and independence around eating. Some pediatricians have discovered a deep interest in this area of pediatrics and built their practices on it. Given the surge in prevalence of AN and the needs for adolescent mental health services, we hope more will do so.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Taquet M et al. Br J Psychiatry. 2022;220:262-4.

2. Morgan JF et al. West J Med. 2000 Mar;172(3):164-5.

3. Matheson BE et al. Int J Eat Disord. 2020 Jul;53(7):1142-54.

Eating disorders are among the most prevalent, disabling, and potentially fatal psychiatric illnesses, and the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated their burden, with a 15.3% increase in incidence in 2020 compared with previous years.1 This increase was almost solely among adolescent girls with anorexia nervosa (AN), which is often insidious in onset and more difficult to treat as it advances. Adolescents with AN are most likely to present to their pediatricians, so awareness and early recognition of the symptoms is critical. Pediatricians are also an integral part of the treatment team in AN and can offer monitoring for serious complications, alongside valuable guidance to parents, who are central to treatment and the reestablishment of healthy eating habits in their children. Here we will review the epidemiology, diagnosis, and treatment of anorexia, with an emphasis on what pediatricians need to know to screen and to facilitate treatment.

Epidemiology

AN is marked by a fear of gaining weight or behaviors that interfere with weight gain and a self-evaluation unduly influenced by weight and body shape. Youth with AN often deny the seriousness of their malnutrition, although that is not required for diagnosis. AN can be of a restrictive or binge-purge subtype, and amenorrhea is no longer a requirement for diagnosis. There is not a specific weight or body mass index cutoff for the diagnosis, but the severity of AN is determined by the BMI percentile normed to age and sex. The average age of onset is 18, and the prepandemic prevalence of AN was about 1% of the population. It affects about 10 times as many females as males. It is quite rare prior to puberty, affecting about 0.01% of that age group. There is a heritable component, with a fivefold relative risk in youth with a parent with AN, and twin studies suggest heritability rates as high as 75%. Youth with rigid cognitive styles appear more vulnerable, as do those who participate in activities such as ballet, gymnastics, modeling, and wrestling because of the role of appearance and weight in performance. More than half of patients with AN will have another psychiatric illness, most commonly anxiety disorders, depression, or obsessive-compulsive disorder. AN becomes chronic in up to 15% of sufferers and the mortality rate is close to 10%, with approximately half dying from medical complications and half dying by suicide.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Screening

Parents and pediatricians are usually the first to notice that a child has started to lose weight or is falling off the growth curve. But weight changes usually emerge after feelings of preoccupation with weight, body shape, and body satisfaction. If parents report escalating pickiness around food, increased or compulsive exercise, persistent self-consciousness and self-criticism around weight and body shape, it is worth starting with screening questions.

If you notice preoccupation or anxiety around being weighed, even if the weight or growth curve are still normal, it is worthwhile to screen. Screening questions, such as the SCOFF questionnaire with five simple questions, can be very sensitive for both AN and bulimia nervosa.2 There are also many validated screening instruments, such as the Eating Disorder Inventory or Eating Attitudes Test (for adolescents) and the Kids Eating Disorder Survey and the Child Eating Attitudes Test (for younger children), that are short self-reports that you can have your patients fill out when you have a higher index of suspicion. Weight loss or growth failure without a preoccupation around weight or appearance needs a thorough a medical workup, and could be a function of other psychiatric problems, such as depression.

If a child screens positive for an eating disorder, your full physical examination, growth curves, and longitudinal growth charts are critical for diagnosis. Percentile BMIs must be used, given the inaccuracy of standard BMI calculations in this age group. (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention age and sex growth charts include methods for this calculation). Laboratory assessment, including metabolic, kidney, pancreatic, and thyroid function, and an EKG can illuminate if there are consequences of restricting or purging. Of course, you want to evaluate for significant medical symptoms, including bradycardia, orthostasis, and hypokalemia. These medical symptoms are not limited to the severely underweight and merit referral to an emergency department and possible medical admission.

Then, a referral to a clinician who is expert in the assessment and treatment of eating disorders is needed. This may be a child psychiatrist, psychologist, or a colleague pediatrician with this specialization. It is also very important to begin the conversation with the family to introduce your concerns, describe what you have noticed, and discuss the need for further assessment and possibly treatment.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek


Be mindful that discussing this in front of your patient may heighten the patient’s anxiety or distress. Be prepared to offer support and understanding for your patient’s anxiety, while steadfastly providing absolute clarity for the parents about the necessity of further evaluation and treatment. Many parents will be concerned and ready to do whatever is needed to get their child’s eating and growth back on track. But some parents may have more difficulty. They may have their own history with an eating disorder. They may be avoiding a sense of shame or alarm. They may be eager to avoid adding to their child’s stress. They may be tired of engaging in power struggles with the child. They may be proud of their ambitious, accomplished young athlete. Their trust in you makes you uniquely positioned to complicate their thinking. And treatment will hinge on them, so this is a critical bridge to care.

Beyond telling parents that they will need to bring more structure and supervision to mealtimes to begin addressing their child’s nutrition, you might offer guidance on other strategies. Empower parents to limit their child’s use of social media sites such as Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok, where they may be immersed in comparing themselves to idealized (and airbrushed) influencers. Empower them to make their child’s participation in beloved sports contingent on eating meals together and completely or on a stabilized weight (as will be common in treatment). Remind them that there are no bad foods, that the goal is health, and that they are not in a power struggle with their child, but instead allied with their child to treat AN. Remind them to also look for chances to have fun with their child, to help everyone remember what matters.
 

 

 

Treatment

Family-based therapy (FBT) is the first-line treatment of shorter-duration AN in children and adolescents. It focuses on the parents, helping them to calmly and effectively manage their child’s eating behaviors until their weight and behaviors have normalized. As a patient’s nutritional status improves, so does cognitive function, emotional flexibility, and mood. Individual therapy and psychopharmacologic treatment can be very effective for comorbid anxiety, mood, attentional, and thought disorders. Family-based work does include the child and is often done in group-based settings with clinicians from multiple disciplines. Dietitians provide education and guidance about healthy nutrition to the child and parents. Therapists may work with the child, parents, or full family to focus on behavior modification and managing distress. Most academic medical centers provide access to FBT, but there are many regions with no providers of this evidence-based treatment. One of the silver linings of the COVID-19 pandemic is that several online services have emerged offering FBT, working with families to manage mealtimes and treatment entirely at home.3 Pediatricians provide regular medical checks to measure progress and help with decisions about when it is safe to permit exercise or advance privileges and independence around eating. Some pediatricians have discovered a deep interest in this area of pediatrics and built their practices on it. Given the surge in prevalence of AN and the needs for adolescent mental health services, we hope more will do so.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Taquet M et al. Br J Psychiatry. 2022;220:262-4.

2. Morgan JF et al. West J Med. 2000 Mar;172(3):164-5.

3. Matheson BE et al. Int J Eat Disord. 2020 Jul;53(7):1142-54.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Teambase XML
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!--$RCSfile: InCopy_agile.xsl,v $ $Revision: 1.35 $-->
<!--$RCSfile: drupal.xsl,v $ $Revision: 1.7 $-->
<root generator="drupal.xsl" gversion="1.7"> <header> <fileName>157848</fileName> <TBEID>0C04266F.SIG</TBEID> <TBUniqueIdentifier>MD_0C04266F</TBUniqueIdentifier> <newsOrJournal>News</newsOrJournal> <publisherName>Frontline Medical Communications</publisherName> <storyname/> <articleType>353</articleType> <TBLocation>QC Done-All Pubs</TBLocation> <QCDate>20220510T134635</QCDate> <firstPublished>20220510T152722</firstPublished> <LastPublished>20220510T152722</LastPublished> <pubStatus qcode="stat:"/> <embargoDate/> <killDate/> <CMSDate>20220510T152722</CMSDate> <articleSource/> <facebookInfo/> <meetingNumber/> <byline>Swick and Jellinek</byline> <bylineText>SUSAN D. SWICK, MD, AND MICHAEL S. JELLINEK, MD</bylineText> <bylineFull>SUSAN D. SWICK, MD, AND MICHAEL S. JELLINEK, MD</bylineFull> <bylineTitleText/> <USOrGlobal/> <wireDocType/> <newsDocType/> <journalDocType/> <linkLabel/> <pageRange/> <citation/> <quizID/> <indexIssueDate/> <itemClass qcode="ninat:text"/> <provider qcode="provider:imng"> <name>IMNG Medical Media</name> <rightsInfo> <copyrightHolder> <name>Frontline Medical News</name> </copyrightHolder> <copyrightNotice>Copyright (c) 2015 Frontline Medical News, a Frontline Medical Communications Inc. company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, copied, or otherwise reproduced or distributed without the prior written permission of Frontline Medical Communications Inc.</copyrightNotice> </rightsInfo> </provider> <abstract/> <metaDescription>Eating disorders are among the most prevalent, disabling, and potentially fatal psychiatric illnesses, and the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated their burden, w</metaDescription> <articlePDF/> <teaserImage>236038</teaserImage> <teaser>Adolescents with anorexia nervosa are most likely to present to their pediatricians, so awareness and early recognition of the symptoms is critical. </teaser> <title>Anorexia nervosa in adolescent patients: What pediatricians need to know</title> <deck/> <disclaimer/> <AuthorList/> <articleURL/> <doi/> <pubMedID/> <publishXMLStatus/> <publishXMLVersion>1</publishXMLVersion> <useEISSN>0</useEISSN> <urgency/> <pubPubdateYear/> <pubPubdateMonth/> <pubPubdateDay/> <pubVolume/> <pubNumber/> <wireChannels/> <primaryCMSID/> <CMSIDs/> <keywords/> <seeAlsos/> <publications_g> <publicationData> <publicationCode>FP</publicationCode> <pubIssueName/> <pubArticleType/> <pubTopics/> <pubCategories/> <pubSections/> <journalTitle/> <journalFullTitle/> <copyrightStatement>Copyright 2017 Frontline Medical News</copyrightStatement> </publicationData> <publicationData> <publicationCode>PN</publicationCode> <pubIssueName/> <pubArticleType/> <pubTopics/> <pubCategories/> <pubSections/> <journalTitle/> <journalFullTitle/> <copyrightStatement/> </publicationData> </publications_g> <publications> <term>15</term> <term canonical="true">25</term> </publications> <sections> <term>52</term> <term>41022</term> <term canonical="true">27728</term> </sections> <topics> <term canonical="true">248</term> <term>271</term> <term>176</term> </topics> <links> <link> <itemClass qcode="ninat:picture"/> <altRep contenttype="image/jpeg">images/2400b0fe.jpg</altRep> <description role="drol:caption">Dr. Susan D. Swick</description> <description role="drol:credit"/> </link> <link> <itemClass qcode="ninat:picture"/> <altRep contenttype="image/jpeg">images/2400cbf9.jpg</altRep> <description role="drol:caption">Dr. Michael S. Jellinek</description> <description role="drol:credit"/> </link> </links> </header> <itemSet> <newsItem> <itemMeta> <itemRole>Main</itemRole> <itemClass>text</itemClass> <title>Anorexia nervosa in adolescent patients: What pediatricians need to know</title> <deck/> </itemMeta> <itemContent> <p>Eating disorders are among the most prevalent, disabling, and potentially fatal psychiatric illnesses, and the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated their burden, with a 15.3% increase in incidence in 2020 compared with previous years.<sup>1</sup> This increase was almost solely among adolescent girls with anorexia nervosa (AN), which is often insidious in onset and more difficult to treat as it advances. Adolescents with AN are most likely to present to their pediatricians, so awareness and early recognition of the symptoms is critical. Pediatricians are also an integral part of the treatment team in AN and can offer monitoring for serious complications, alongside valuable guidance to parents, who are central to treatment and the reestablishment of healthy eating habits in their children. Here we will review the epidemiology, diagnosis, and treatment of anorexia, with an emphasis on what pediatricians need to know to screen and to facilitate treatment.</p> <h2>Epidemiology</h2> <p>AN is marked by a fear of gaining weight or behaviors that interfere with weight gain and a self-evaluation unduly influenced by weight and body shape. Youth with AN often deny the seriousness of their malnutrition, although that is not required for diagnosis. AN can be of a restrictive or binge-purge subtype, and amenorrhea is no longer a requirement for diagnosis. There is not a specific weight or body mass index cutoff for the diagnosis, but the severity of AN is determined by the BMI percentile normed to age and sex. The average age of onset is 18, and the prepandemic prevalence of AN was about 1% of the population. It affects about 10 times as many females as males. It is quite rare prior to puberty, affecting about 0.01% of that age group. There is a heritable component, with a fivefold relative risk in youth with a parent with AN, and twin studies suggest heritability rates as high as 75%. Youth with rigid cognitive styles appear more vulnerable, as do those who participate in activities such as ballet, gymnastics, modeling, and wrestling because of the role of appearance and weight in performance. More than half of patients with AN will have another psychiatric illness, most commonly anxiety disorders, depression, or obsessive-compulsive disorder. AN becomes chronic in up to 15% of sufferers and the mortality rate is close to 10%, with approximately half dying from medical complications and half dying by suicide.[[{"fid":"236038","view_mode":"medstat_image_flush_left","fields":{"format":"medstat_image_flush_left","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":"Dr. Susan D. Swick, physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula.","field_file_image_credit[und][0][value]":"","field_file_image_caption[und][0][value]":"Dr. Susan D. Swick"},"type":"media","attributes":{"class":"media-element file-medstat_image_flush_left"}}]]</p> <h2>Screening</h2> <p>Parents and pediatricians are usually the first to notice that a child has started to lose weight or is falling off the growth curve. But weight changes usually emerge after feelings of preoccupation with weight, body shape, and body satisfaction. If parents report escalating pickiness around food, increased or compulsive exercise, persistent self-consciousness and self-criticism around weight and body shape, it is worth starting with screening questions. </p> <p>If you notice preoccupation or anxiety around being weighed, even if the weight or growth curve are still normal, it is worthwhile to screen. Screening questions, such as the SCOFF questionnaire with five simple questions, can be very sensitive for both AN and bulimia nervosa.<sup>2</sup> There are also many validated screening instruments, such as the Eating Disorder Inventory or Eating Attitudes Test (for adolescents) and the Kids Eating Disorder Survey and the Child Eating Attitudes Test (for younger children), that are short self-reports that you can have your patients fill out when you have a higher index of suspicion. Weight loss or growth failure without a preoccupation around weight or appearance needs a thorough a medical workup, and could be a function of other psychiatric problems, such as depression.<br/><br/>If a child screens positive for an eating disorder, your full physical examination, growth curves, and longitudinal growth charts are critical for diagnosis. Percentile BMIs must be used, given the inaccuracy of standard BMI calculations in this age group. (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention age and sex growth charts include methods for this calculation). Laboratory assessment, including metabolic, kidney, pancreatic, and thyroid function, and an EKG can illuminate if there are consequences of restricting or purging. Of course, you want to evaluate for significant medical symptoms, including bradycardia, orthostasis, and hypokalemia. These medical symptoms are not limited to the severely underweight and merit referral to an emergency department and possible medical admission.<br/><br/>Then, a referral to a clinician who is expert in the assessment and treatment of eating disorders is needed. This may be a child psychiatrist, psychologist, or a colleague pediatrician with this specialization. It is also very important to begin the conversation with the family to introduce your concerns, describe what you have noticed, and discuss the need for further assessment and possibly treatment. [[{"fid":"251601","view_mode":"medstat_image_flush_left","fields":{"format":"medstat_image_flush_left","field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]":"Dr. Michael S. Jellinek, professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston","field_file_image_credit[und][0][value]":"","field_file_image_caption[und][0][value]":"Dr. Michael S. Jellinek"},"type":"media","attributes":{"class":"media-element file-medstat_image_flush_left"}}]]<br/><br/>Be mindful that discussing this in front of your patient may heighten the patient’s anxiety or distress. Be prepared to offer support and understanding for your patient’s anxiety, while steadfastly providing absolute clarity for the parents about the necessity of further evaluation and treatment. Many parents will be concerned and ready to do whatever is needed to get their child’s eating and growth back on track. But some parents may have more difficulty. They may have their own history with an eating disorder. They may be avoiding a sense of shame or alarm. They may be eager to avoid adding to their child’s stress. They may be tired of engaging in power struggles with the child. They may be proud of their ambitious, accomplished young athlete. Their trust in you makes you uniquely positioned to complicate their thinking. And treatment will hinge on them, so this is a critical bridge to care.<br/><br/>Beyond telling parents that they will need to bring more structure and supervision to mealtimes to begin addressing their child’s nutrition, you might offer guidance on other strategies. Empower parents to limit their child’s use of social media sites such as Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok, where they may be immersed in comparing themselves to idealized (and airbrushed) influencers. Empower them to make their child’s participation in beloved sports contingent on eating meals together and completely or on a stabilized weight (as will be common in treatment). Remind them that there are no bad foods, that the goal is health, and that they are not in a power struggle with their child, but instead allied with their child to treat AN. Remind them to also look for chances to have fun with their child, to help everyone remember what matters.<br/><br/></p> <h2>Treatment</h2> <p>Family-based therapy (FBT) is the first-line treatment of shorter-duration AN in children and adolescents. It focuses on the parents, helping them to calmly and effectively manage their child’s eating behaviors until their weight and behaviors have normalized. As a patient’s nutritional status improves, so does cognitive function, emotional flexibility, and mood. Individual therapy and psychopharmacologic treatment can be very effective for comorbid anxiety, mood, attentional, and thought disorders. Family-based work does include the child and is often done in group-based settings with clinicians from multiple disciplines. Dietitians provide education and guidance about healthy nutrition to the child and parents. Therapists may work with the child, parents, or full family to focus on behavior modification and managing distress. Most academic medical centers provide access to FBT, but there are many regions with no providers of this evidence-based treatment. One of the silver linings of the COVID-19 pandemic is that several online services have emerged offering FBT, working with families to manage mealtimes and treatment entirely at home.<sup>3</sup> Pediatricians provide regular medical checks to measure progress and help with decisions about when it is safe to permit exercise or advance privileges and independence around eating. Some pediatricians have discovered a deep interest in this area of pediatrics and built their practices on it. Given the surge in prevalence of AN and the needs for adolescent mental health services, we hope more will do so.</p> <p> <em>Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="mailto:pdnews%40mdedge.com?subject=">pdnews@mdedge.com</a></span>.</em> </p> <h2>References</h2> <p>1. Taquet M et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry/article/incidence-and-outcomes-of-eating-disorders-during-the-covid19-pandemic/ACFCF65FF7B1D07CCF1DDC628C50C7CA">Br J Psychiatry. 2022;220:262-4</a></span>. <br/><br/>2. Morgan JF et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18751246/">West J Med. 2000 Mar;172(3):164-5</a></span>.<br/><br/>3. Matheson BE et al. <span class="Hyperlink"><a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/eat.23326">Int J Eat Disord. 2020 Jul;53(7):1142-54</a></span>.</p> </itemContent> </newsItem> <newsItem> <itemMeta> <itemRole>teaser</itemRole> <itemClass>text</itemClass> <title/> <deck/> </itemMeta> <itemContent> </itemContent> </newsItem> </itemSet></root>
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

Diagnosing adolescent ADHD

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 03/17/2022 - 11:03

Pediatricians are increasingly expert in the assessment and treatment of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. But what do you do when adolescents present to your office saying they think they have ADHD? While ADHD is a common and treatable disorder of youth, it is important to take special care when assessing an adolescent. Difficulties with attention and concentration are common symptoms for many different challenges of adolescence, and for ADHD to be the underlying cause, those symptoms must have started prior to adolescence (according to DSM-5, prior to the age of 12). When your adolescent patients or their parents come to your office complaining of inattention, it is important to consider the full range of possible explanations.

Sleep

We have written in this column previously about the challenges that adolescents face in getting adequate sleep consistently. Teenagers, on average, need more than 9 hours of sleep nightly and American teenagers get fewer than 6. This mismatch is because of physiologic shifts that move their natural sleep onset time significantly later, while school still starts early. It’s often compounded by other demands on their time, including homework, extracurricular activities, and the gravitational pull of social connections. Independent teenagers make their own decisions about how to manage their time and may feel sleep is optional, or manage their fatigue with naps and caffeine, both of which will further compromise the quality and efficiency of sleep.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Chronic sleep deprivation will present with difficulties with focus, attention, memory, and cognitive performance. Treatment of this problem with stimulants is likely to make the underlying poor sleep habits even worse. When your patient presents complaining of difficulty concentrating and worsening school performance, be sure to start with a thorough sleep history, and always provide guidance about the body’s need for sleep and healthy sleep habits.
 

Anxiety

Anxiety disorders are the most common psychiatric illnesses of youth, with estimates of as many as 30% of children and adolescents experiencing one. The true prevalence of ADHD is estimated to be about 4% of the population. Whether social phobia, generalized anxiety disorder, or even posttraumatic stress disorder, anxiety disorders interfere with attention as ruminative worry tends to distract those experiencing it. It can also affect attention and focus indirectly by interfering with restful sleep. Anxiety disorders can be difficult to identify, as the sufferers typically internalize their symptoms. But inquire about specific worries (such as speaking in front of others, meeting new people, or an illness or accident striking themselves or a loved one) and how much time they take up. Explore if worries fill their thoughts during quiet or downtime, and explore more about their worries. You may use a screening instrument such as the Pediatric Symptom Checklist or the SCARED, both of which will indicate a likely problem with anxiety. While it is possible to have comorbid ADHD with an anxiety disorder, the anxiety disorder will likely worsen with stimulants and should be treated first. These are usually curable illnesses and you may find that remission of anxiety symptoms resolves the attentional problems.

 

 

Depression

Mood disorders are less common than anxiety disorders in youth, but far more prevalent than ADHD. And depression is usually marked by serious difficulty concentrating across settings (including for things that were previously very interesting). A sullen teenager who is deeply self-critical about school performance would benefit from exploration of associated changes in mood, interests, energy, appetite, sleep, and for feelings of worthlessness, guilt, and suicidal thoughts. The PHQ9A is a simple, free screening instrument that is reasonable to use with every sick visit (and well-check) with your adolescent patients, given the risks of undetected and untreated depression. If your patient presents complaining of poor school performance, always screen for depression. As with anxiety disorders, comorbid ADHD is possible, but it is always recommended to treat the mood disorder first and then to assess for residual ADHD symptoms once the mood disorder is in remission.

Substance abuse

Adolescence is a time of exploration, and drug and alcohol use is common. While attentional impairment will happen with intoxication, occasional or rare use should not lead to consistent impairment in school. But when parents are more worried than their children about a significant change in school performance, it is important to screen for substance abuse. A child with a secret substance use disorder will often present with behavioral changes and deteriorating school performance and might deny any drug or alcohol use to parents. Indeed, stimulants have some street value and some patients may be seeking a stimulant prescription to sell or trade for other drugs. Regular marijuana use may present with only deteriorating school performance and no irritability or other noticeable behavioral changes. Marijuana is seen as safe and even healthy by many teenagers (and even many parents), and some youth may be using it recreationally or to manage difficulties with sleep, anxiety, or mood symptoms.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

But there is compelling evidence that marijuana use causes cognitive impairment, including difficulty with sustaining attention, short-term memory, and processing speed, for as long as 24 hours after use. If a teenager is using marijuana daily after school, it is certainly going to interfere, in a dose-dependent manner, with attention and cognitive function. Sustained heavy use can lead to permanent cognitive deficits. It can also trigger or worsen anxiety or mood symptoms (contrary to much popular opinion).

Gathering a thorough substance use history is essential when assessing a teenager for difficulties with focus or attention, especially when these are accompanied by change in behavior and school performance. Remember, it is critical to interview these children without their parents present to invite them to be forthcoming with you.
 

History

While true ADHD should have been present throughout childhood, it is possible that the symptoms have become noticeable only in adolescence. For patients with very high intelligence and lower levels of impulsivity and hyperactivity, they might easily have “flown under the radar” during their elementary and even middle school years. Their difficulties with attention and focus might become apparent only when the volume and difficulty of schoolwork both are great enough that their intelligence is not enough to get good grades. That is, their problems with executive function, prioritizing, shifting sets, and completing tasks in a timely way make it impossible to keep up good grades when the work gets harder.

Your history should reveal a long history of dreaminess or distractibility, a tendency to lose and forget things, and the other symptoms of inattention. Did they often seem to not be listening when they were younger? Forget to hand in homework? Leave chores unfinished? Leave messes behind everywhere they went? These will not be definitive, but they do reassure that symptoms may have been present for a long time, even if school performance was considered fine until the workload got too large. If such problems were not present before puberty, consider whether a subtle learning disability could be impairing them as they face more challenging academic subjects.

If you have ruled out anxiety, mood, and substance use concerns, and helped them to address a sleep deficit, then you can proceed. It is worthwhile to get Vanderbilt Assessments as you would for a younger child. If they meet criteria, discuss the risks and benefits of medication, executive skills coaching, and environmental adjustments (extra time for tests, a less stimulating environment) that can help them explore academic challenges without the discouragement that ADHD can bring.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Topics
Sections

Pediatricians are increasingly expert in the assessment and treatment of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. But what do you do when adolescents present to your office saying they think they have ADHD? While ADHD is a common and treatable disorder of youth, it is important to take special care when assessing an adolescent. Difficulties with attention and concentration are common symptoms for many different challenges of adolescence, and for ADHD to be the underlying cause, those symptoms must have started prior to adolescence (according to DSM-5, prior to the age of 12). When your adolescent patients or their parents come to your office complaining of inattention, it is important to consider the full range of possible explanations.

Sleep

We have written in this column previously about the challenges that adolescents face in getting adequate sleep consistently. Teenagers, on average, need more than 9 hours of sleep nightly and American teenagers get fewer than 6. This mismatch is because of physiologic shifts that move their natural sleep onset time significantly later, while school still starts early. It’s often compounded by other demands on their time, including homework, extracurricular activities, and the gravitational pull of social connections. Independent teenagers make their own decisions about how to manage their time and may feel sleep is optional, or manage their fatigue with naps and caffeine, both of which will further compromise the quality and efficiency of sleep.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Chronic sleep deprivation will present with difficulties with focus, attention, memory, and cognitive performance. Treatment of this problem with stimulants is likely to make the underlying poor sleep habits even worse. When your patient presents complaining of difficulty concentrating and worsening school performance, be sure to start with a thorough sleep history, and always provide guidance about the body’s need for sleep and healthy sleep habits.
 

Anxiety

Anxiety disorders are the most common psychiatric illnesses of youth, with estimates of as many as 30% of children and adolescents experiencing one. The true prevalence of ADHD is estimated to be about 4% of the population. Whether social phobia, generalized anxiety disorder, or even posttraumatic stress disorder, anxiety disorders interfere with attention as ruminative worry tends to distract those experiencing it. It can also affect attention and focus indirectly by interfering with restful sleep. Anxiety disorders can be difficult to identify, as the sufferers typically internalize their symptoms. But inquire about specific worries (such as speaking in front of others, meeting new people, or an illness or accident striking themselves or a loved one) and how much time they take up. Explore if worries fill their thoughts during quiet or downtime, and explore more about their worries. You may use a screening instrument such as the Pediatric Symptom Checklist or the SCARED, both of which will indicate a likely problem with anxiety. While it is possible to have comorbid ADHD with an anxiety disorder, the anxiety disorder will likely worsen with stimulants and should be treated first. These are usually curable illnesses and you may find that remission of anxiety symptoms resolves the attentional problems.

 

 

Depression

Mood disorders are less common than anxiety disorders in youth, but far more prevalent than ADHD. And depression is usually marked by serious difficulty concentrating across settings (including for things that were previously very interesting). A sullen teenager who is deeply self-critical about school performance would benefit from exploration of associated changes in mood, interests, energy, appetite, sleep, and for feelings of worthlessness, guilt, and suicidal thoughts. The PHQ9A is a simple, free screening instrument that is reasonable to use with every sick visit (and well-check) with your adolescent patients, given the risks of undetected and untreated depression. If your patient presents complaining of poor school performance, always screen for depression. As with anxiety disorders, comorbid ADHD is possible, but it is always recommended to treat the mood disorder first and then to assess for residual ADHD symptoms once the mood disorder is in remission.

Substance abuse

Adolescence is a time of exploration, and drug and alcohol use is common. While attentional impairment will happen with intoxication, occasional or rare use should not lead to consistent impairment in school. But when parents are more worried than their children about a significant change in school performance, it is important to screen for substance abuse. A child with a secret substance use disorder will often present with behavioral changes and deteriorating school performance and might deny any drug or alcohol use to parents. Indeed, stimulants have some street value and some patients may be seeking a stimulant prescription to sell or trade for other drugs. Regular marijuana use may present with only deteriorating school performance and no irritability or other noticeable behavioral changes. Marijuana is seen as safe and even healthy by many teenagers (and even many parents), and some youth may be using it recreationally or to manage difficulties with sleep, anxiety, or mood symptoms.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

But there is compelling evidence that marijuana use causes cognitive impairment, including difficulty with sustaining attention, short-term memory, and processing speed, for as long as 24 hours after use. If a teenager is using marijuana daily after school, it is certainly going to interfere, in a dose-dependent manner, with attention and cognitive function. Sustained heavy use can lead to permanent cognitive deficits. It can also trigger or worsen anxiety or mood symptoms (contrary to much popular opinion).

Gathering a thorough substance use history is essential when assessing a teenager for difficulties with focus or attention, especially when these are accompanied by change in behavior and school performance. Remember, it is critical to interview these children without their parents present to invite them to be forthcoming with you.
 

History

While true ADHD should have been present throughout childhood, it is possible that the symptoms have become noticeable only in adolescence. For patients with very high intelligence and lower levels of impulsivity and hyperactivity, they might easily have “flown under the radar” during their elementary and even middle school years. Their difficulties with attention and focus might become apparent only when the volume and difficulty of schoolwork both are great enough that their intelligence is not enough to get good grades. That is, their problems with executive function, prioritizing, shifting sets, and completing tasks in a timely way make it impossible to keep up good grades when the work gets harder.

Your history should reveal a long history of dreaminess or distractibility, a tendency to lose and forget things, and the other symptoms of inattention. Did they often seem to not be listening when they were younger? Forget to hand in homework? Leave chores unfinished? Leave messes behind everywhere they went? These will not be definitive, but they do reassure that symptoms may have been present for a long time, even if school performance was considered fine until the workload got too large. If such problems were not present before puberty, consider whether a subtle learning disability could be impairing them as they face more challenging academic subjects.

If you have ruled out anxiety, mood, and substance use concerns, and helped them to address a sleep deficit, then you can proceed. It is worthwhile to get Vanderbilt Assessments as you would for a younger child. If they meet criteria, discuss the risks and benefits of medication, executive skills coaching, and environmental adjustments (extra time for tests, a less stimulating environment) that can help them explore academic challenges without the discouragement that ADHD can bring.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Pediatricians are increasingly expert in the assessment and treatment of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. But what do you do when adolescents present to your office saying they think they have ADHD? While ADHD is a common and treatable disorder of youth, it is important to take special care when assessing an adolescent. Difficulties with attention and concentration are common symptoms for many different challenges of adolescence, and for ADHD to be the underlying cause, those symptoms must have started prior to adolescence (according to DSM-5, prior to the age of 12). When your adolescent patients or their parents come to your office complaining of inattention, it is important to consider the full range of possible explanations.

Sleep

We have written in this column previously about the challenges that adolescents face in getting adequate sleep consistently. Teenagers, on average, need more than 9 hours of sleep nightly and American teenagers get fewer than 6. This mismatch is because of physiologic shifts that move their natural sleep onset time significantly later, while school still starts early. It’s often compounded by other demands on their time, including homework, extracurricular activities, and the gravitational pull of social connections. Independent teenagers make their own decisions about how to manage their time and may feel sleep is optional, or manage their fatigue with naps and caffeine, both of which will further compromise the quality and efficiency of sleep.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Chronic sleep deprivation will present with difficulties with focus, attention, memory, and cognitive performance. Treatment of this problem with stimulants is likely to make the underlying poor sleep habits even worse. When your patient presents complaining of difficulty concentrating and worsening school performance, be sure to start with a thorough sleep history, and always provide guidance about the body’s need for sleep and healthy sleep habits.
 

Anxiety

Anxiety disorders are the most common psychiatric illnesses of youth, with estimates of as many as 30% of children and adolescents experiencing one. The true prevalence of ADHD is estimated to be about 4% of the population. Whether social phobia, generalized anxiety disorder, or even posttraumatic stress disorder, anxiety disorders interfere with attention as ruminative worry tends to distract those experiencing it. It can also affect attention and focus indirectly by interfering with restful sleep. Anxiety disorders can be difficult to identify, as the sufferers typically internalize their symptoms. But inquire about specific worries (such as speaking in front of others, meeting new people, or an illness or accident striking themselves or a loved one) and how much time they take up. Explore if worries fill their thoughts during quiet or downtime, and explore more about their worries. You may use a screening instrument such as the Pediatric Symptom Checklist or the SCARED, both of which will indicate a likely problem with anxiety. While it is possible to have comorbid ADHD with an anxiety disorder, the anxiety disorder will likely worsen with stimulants and should be treated first. These are usually curable illnesses and you may find that remission of anxiety symptoms resolves the attentional problems.

 

 

Depression

Mood disorders are less common than anxiety disorders in youth, but far more prevalent than ADHD. And depression is usually marked by serious difficulty concentrating across settings (including for things that were previously very interesting). A sullen teenager who is deeply self-critical about school performance would benefit from exploration of associated changes in mood, interests, energy, appetite, sleep, and for feelings of worthlessness, guilt, and suicidal thoughts. The PHQ9A is a simple, free screening instrument that is reasonable to use with every sick visit (and well-check) with your adolescent patients, given the risks of undetected and untreated depression. If your patient presents complaining of poor school performance, always screen for depression. As with anxiety disorders, comorbid ADHD is possible, but it is always recommended to treat the mood disorder first and then to assess for residual ADHD symptoms once the mood disorder is in remission.

Substance abuse

Adolescence is a time of exploration, and drug and alcohol use is common. While attentional impairment will happen with intoxication, occasional or rare use should not lead to consistent impairment in school. But when parents are more worried than their children about a significant change in school performance, it is important to screen for substance abuse. A child with a secret substance use disorder will often present with behavioral changes and deteriorating school performance and might deny any drug or alcohol use to parents. Indeed, stimulants have some street value and some patients may be seeking a stimulant prescription to sell or trade for other drugs. Regular marijuana use may present with only deteriorating school performance and no irritability or other noticeable behavioral changes. Marijuana is seen as safe and even healthy by many teenagers (and even many parents), and some youth may be using it recreationally or to manage difficulties with sleep, anxiety, or mood symptoms.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

But there is compelling evidence that marijuana use causes cognitive impairment, including difficulty with sustaining attention, short-term memory, and processing speed, for as long as 24 hours after use. If a teenager is using marijuana daily after school, it is certainly going to interfere, in a dose-dependent manner, with attention and cognitive function. Sustained heavy use can lead to permanent cognitive deficits. It can also trigger or worsen anxiety or mood symptoms (contrary to much popular opinion).

Gathering a thorough substance use history is essential when assessing a teenager for difficulties with focus or attention, especially when these are accompanied by change in behavior and school performance. Remember, it is critical to interview these children without their parents present to invite them to be forthcoming with you.
 

History

While true ADHD should have been present throughout childhood, it is possible that the symptoms have become noticeable only in adolescence. For patients with very high intelligence and lower levels of impulsivity and hyperactivity, they might easily have “flown under the radar” during their elementary and even middle school years. Their difficulties with attention and focus might become apparent only when the volume and difficulty of schoolwork both are great enough that their intelligence is not enough to get good grades. That is, their problems with executive function, prioritizing, shifting sets, and completing tasks in a timely way make it impossible to keep up good grades when the work gets harder.

Your history should reveal a long history of dreaminess or distractibility, a tendency to lose and forget things, and the other symptoms of inattention. Did they often seem to not be listening when they were younger? Forget to hand in homework? Leave chores unfinished? Leave messes behind everywhere they went? These will not be definitive, but they do reassure that symptoms may have been present for a long time, even if school performance was considered fine until the workload got too large. If such problems were not present before puberty, consider whether a subtle learning disability could be impairing them as they face more challenging academic subjects.

If you have ruled out anxiety, mood, and substance use concerns, and helped them to address a sleep deficit, then you can proceed. It is worthwhile to get Vanderbilt Assessments as you would for a younger child. If they meet criteria, discuss the risks and benefits of medication, executive skills coaching, and environmental adjustments (extra time for tests, a less stimulating environment) that can help them explore academic challenges without the discouragement that ADHD can bring.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

Pediatric depression and parents

Article Type
Changed
Wed, 01/12/2022 - 09:23

In October of 2021, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the Children’s Hospital Association jointly declared a National State of Emergency in Children’s Mental Health and called on policy makers to address a host of challenges that have impeded access to effective mental health care for youth.

In November, we wrote about how pediatricians may increase their use of screening for adolescent depression and initiate treatment when appropriate.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Now we complement that piece with guidance you may offer the parents of your depressed adolescent patients. Adolescent depression is a common pediatric disorder, especially in the COVID-19 era when so many relationships and activities have been limited or cut off. With treatment, most adolescents recover. Accepting that it may be taking longer to find a therapist, you can make treatment recommendations, support the teenager and parents, address safety concerns and, if the depression is of moderate or more serious severity, start medications. Parents are your natural partners as they are concerned about their children’s health and safety and eager for guidance on how to best support their recovery.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Adolescence is a time in which parents transition to more of a consulting than a controlling posture with their children, but illness calls for a shift toward setting rules and routines that will support health and healing. Prepare both the teenager (in a 1:1 discussion) and parents for this temporary shift, and for some teenagers, expect resistance. Depression will make the teenager more unhappy and irritable. It also causes withdrawal, by sapping energy and making one feel unwelcome at activities, believing his or her presence will be a burden to others. Treatment includes something called “behavioral activation,” or continuous nudging, to keep the patient involved in social, intellectual, and physical activities. Parents (and siblings) are the keys to this behavioral activation, whether nudging to participate in a board game or a walk. Reassure parents they should not take it personally when their teen resists, and not be discouraged if they fail sometimes. Their focus is on calmly, warmly, and repeatedly prompting their children with nudges toward these routines and activities. They should be ready to remind them why they are “nagging,” framing these efforts explicitly as supporting recovery from depression. If possible, applying these rules to everyone at home will help. They need to avoid being drawn into conflict, focusing instead on staying connected to their teens. Their task is to keep planning and cajoling, giving their children multiple opportunities to participate, pushing back against depression’s gravitational pull for total withdrawal.
 

Sleep

One of the most important thing parents can do for their depressed adolescents is to support their healthy restful sleep. During adolescence, the timing of sleep naturally shifts later, and the need for restful sleep increases. Working against the demands of homework, extracurricular activities, and social connections, sleep often suffers during adolescence. Further sleep disruptions, including difficulty falling asleep and frequent awakening during sleep or in the early morning, are typical of depression. Restful sleep is instrumental to recovery, and parents need to help their depressed teens set good sleep habits. This includes setting a time for bed that is realistic and consistent and turning off screens 30 minutes before lights out. A soothing, consistent bedtime routine, including a hot shower and reading in bed, is a powerful cue for sleep. Getting daily exercise and avoiding a heavy meal and caffeine in the hours before bed supports both falling and staying asleep. Having light reading near bed (magazines or comics) instead of screens can provide a way to pass 30 minutes if they wake up during the night (ideally reading out of bed), one that will not make it harder for them to go back to sleep. Finally, teens should not be allowed to spend all day in bed or nap in the afternoon. This may be the hardest task for parents, as adolescents naturally treat their beds like their center of operations and depression lowers their energy and initiative. If parents set these rules and routines for all members of the family, it can improve the chances that their depressed adolescents may begin to return to healthy sleep.

 

 

Exercise

Vigorous exercise (for 20 minutes three times weekly) is as effective as SSRIs in treating mild to moderate depression. Even in severe depression, exercise may accelerate recovery and certainly contributes to returning to restful sleep and a feeling of improved energy. Inviting their depressed teens to join them on a trip to the gym may seem like a fool’s errand to parents, but they should prioritize getting their children moving. Don’t offer choices or ask what activity they would like to do. Most invitations will be met with “no, thanks” (or probably something less polite). Instead, initiate simple activities and then cajole the children with “let’s go!” They should use loving persistence to get them out the door. Parents are the experts on their children and will know if there is an activity that they are more likely to enjoy. Make any activities group ones, easy to start and not too long. They could initiate family walks or bike rides in their neighborhood. If it helps, they can blame you, “these are doctor’s orders!” This approach of warm persistence should be applied across the board, helping their depressed teens participate in mealtimes and other activities. Prepare parents that this can feel unnatural, if they have been letting their healthy teenagers have more space and independence and less time in family activities.

Social connections

Behavioral activation includes keeping a depressed teen engaged in social activities. Friendships are a potent motivator in the lives of healthy adolescents. If depressed teens can stay connected to close friends, it is a powerful force for recovery. Find out if their friends know about their depression, whom do they trust to tell about it? Help them find comfortable language to speak about their depression with trusted friends. Parents can use their behavioral activation strategies to prompt their teenagers to participate in social activities. If texting, video chatting, or social media platforms are how they stay connected with close friends, support their use of these platforms. But be mindful that social media promotes social comparison over connection, and depression sets them up to feel less than others even without assistance. Parents should support real time with their friends in small groups, for short periods during the time of day when they have the most energy.

Safety

Suicide is the second leading cause of death for adolescents in the United States, and the rate of attempted and completed suicide in adolescents has been steadily climbing over the past decade according to the CDC. The rate is higher in older adolescents, though thankfully relatively uncommon (about 1 in 10,000 a year), and, although we know risk factors, no one has been able to predict reliably the risk for an individual teenager at a point in time. In a clinically referred sample, 85% of depressed adolescents will have suicidal ideation and 32% will make a suicide attempt. The risk is higher in those adolescents with more than one psychiatric diagnosis and with a history of impulsive behaviors, substance abuse, prior suicide attempts, and a family history of suicide. It is important that parents hear that asking about suicidal thoughts will not cause them. On the contrary, preserving open communication and a warm relationship is very protective. Adolescent suicide attempts are likely to be impulsive, so helping the family to consider ways to “put up obstacles” that would slow down any possible attempt is an effective way to improve safety. Ask your patients about suicidal thoughts, plans, and what keeps them safe. Find out if they worry about sharing these thoughts with their parents and why. Ask if there are ways their parents can check on them that “aren’t too annoying.” Determine if there are guns in the home, and if so, are they safely stored (locked, separate from ammunition)? More than 50% of completed adolescent suicides involve firearms, so this question is critical. What about access to medications that could be dangerous in overdose in your home or a relative’s home they may visit? Discussing these facts with your patients and their parents together will make it easier for them to continue the conversation outside of your office and can make an enormous difference in their recovery.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Reference

Kovacs M et al. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1993 Jan;32(1):8-20.

Publications
Topics
Sections

In October of 2021, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the Children’s Hospital Association jointly declared a National State of Emergency in Children’s Mental Health and called on policy makers to address a host of challenges that have impeded access to effective mental health care for youth.

In November, we wrote about how pediatricians may increase their use of screening for adolescent depression and initiate treatment when appropriate.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Now we complement that piece with guidance you may offer the parents of your depressed adolescent patients. Adolescent depression is a common pediatric disorder, especially in the COVID-19 era when so many relationships and activities have been limited or cut off. With treatment, most adolescents recover. Accepting that it may be taking longer to find a therapist, you can make treatment recommendations, support the teenager and parents, address safety concerns and, if the depression is of moderate or more serious severity, start medications. Parents are your natural partners as they are concerned about their children’s health and safety and eager for guidance on how to best support their recovery.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Adolescence is a time in which parents transition to more of a consulting than a controlling posture with their children, but illness calls for a shift toward setting rules and routines that will support health and healing. Prepare both the teenager (in a 1:1 discussion) and parents for this temporary shift, and for some teenagers, expect resistance. Depression will make the teenager more unhappy and irritable. It also causes withdrawal, by sapping energy and making one feel unwelcome at activities, believing his or her presence will be a burden to others. Treatment includes something called “behavioral activation,” or continuous nudging, to keep the patient involved in social, intellectual, and physical activities. Parents (and siblings) are the keys to this behavioral activation, whether nudging to participate in a board game or a walk. Reassure parents they should not take it personally when their teen resists, and not be discouraged if they fail sometimes. Their focus is on calmly, warmly, and repeatedly prompting their children with nudges toward these routines and activities. They should be ready to remind them why they are “nagging,” framing these efforts explicitly as supporting recovery from depression. If possible, applying these rules to everyone at home will help. They need to avoid being drawn into conflict, focusing instead on staying connected to their teens. Their task is to keep planning and cajoling, giving their children multiple opportunities to participate, pushing back against depression’s gravitational pull for total withdrawal.
 

Sleep

One of the most important thing parents can do for their depressed adolescents is to support their healthy restful sleep. During adolescence, the timing of sleep naturally shifts later, and the need for restful sleep increases. Working against the demands of homework, extracurricular activities, and social connections, sleep often suffers during adolescence. Further sleep disruptions, including difficulty falling asleep and frequent awakening during sleep or in the early morning, are typical of depression. Restful sleep is instrumental to recovery, and parents need to help their depressed teens set good sleep habits. This includes setting a time for bed that is realistic and consistent and turning off screens 30 minutes before lights out. A soothing, consistent bedtime routine, including a hot shower and reading in bed, is a powerful cue for sleep. Getting daily exercise and avoiding a heavy meal and caffeine in the hours before bed supports both falling and staying asleep. Having light reading near bed (magazines or comics) instead of screens can provide a way to pass 30 minutes if they wake up during the night (ideally reading out of bed), one that will not make it harder for them to go back to sleep. Finally, teens should not be allowed to spend all day in bed or nap in the afternoon. This may be the hardest task for parents, as adolescents naturally treat their beds like their center of operations and depression lowers their energy and initiative. If parents set these rules and routines for all members of the family, it can improve the chances that their depressed adolescents may begin to return to healthy sleep.

 

 

Exercise

Vigorous exercise (for 20 minutes three times weekly) is as effective as SSRIs in treating mild to moderate depression. Even in severe depression, exercise may accelerate recovery and certainly contributes to returning to restful sleep and a feeling of improved energy. Inviting their depressed teens to join them on a trip to the gym may seem like a fool’s errand to parents, but they should prioritize getting their children moving. Don’t offer choices or ask what activity they would like to do. Most invitations will be met with “no, thanks” (or probably something less polite). Instead, initiate simple activities and then cajole the children with “let’s go!” They should use loving persistence to get them out the door. Parents are the experts on their children and will know if there is an activity that they are more likely to enjoy. Make any activities group ones, easy to start and not too long. They could initiate family walks or bike rides in their neighborhood. If it helps, they can blame you, “these are doctor’s orders!” This approach of warm persistence should be applied across the board, helping their depressed teens participate in mealtimes and other activities. Prepare parents that this can feel unnatural, if they have been letting their healthy teenagers have more space and independence and less time in family activities.

Social connections

Behavioral activation includes keeping a depressed teen engaged in social activities. Friendships are a potent motivator in the lives of healthy adolescents. If depressed teens can stay connected to close friends, it is a powerful force for recovery. Find out if their friends know about their depression, whom do they trust to tell about it? Help them find comfortable language to speak about their depression with trusted friends. Parents can use their behavioral activation strategies to prompt their teenagers to participate in social activities. If texting, video chatting, or social media platforms are how they stay connected with close friends, support their use of these platforms. But be mindful that social media promotes social comparison over connection, and depression sets them up to feel less than others even without assistance. Parents should support real time with their friends in small groups, for short periods during the time of day when they have the most energy.

Safety

Suicide is the second leading cause of death for adolescents in the United States, and the rate of attempted and completed suicide in adolescents has been steadily climbing over the past decade according to the CDC. The rate is higher in older adolescents, though thankfully relatively uncommon (about 1 in 10,000 a year), and, although we know risk factors, no one has been able to predict reliably the risk for an individual teenager at a point in time. In a clinically referred sample, 85% of depressed adolescents will have suicidal ideation and 32% will make a suicide attempt. The risk is higher in those adolescents with more than one psychiatric diagnosis and with a history of impulsive behaviors, substance abuse, prior suicide attempts, and a family history of suicide. It is important that parents hear that asking about suicidal thoughts will not cause them. On the contrary, preserving open communication and a warm relationship is very protective. Adolescent suicide attempts are likely to be impulsive, so helping the family to consider ways to “put up obstacles” that would slow down any possible attempt is an effective way to improve safety. Ask your patients about suicidal thoughts, plans, and what keeps them safe. Find out if they worry about sharing these thoughts with their parents and why. Ask if there are ways their parents can check on them that “aren’t too annoying.” Determine if there are guns in the home, and if so, are they safely stored (locked, separate from ammunition)? More than 50% of completed adolescent suicides involve firearms, so this question is critical. What about access to medications that could be dangerous in overdose in your home or a relative’s home they may visit? Discussing these facts with your patients and their parents together will make it easier for them to continue the conversation outside of your office and can make an enormous difference in their recovery.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Reference

Kovacs M et al. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1993 Jan;32(1):8-20.

In October of 2021, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the Children’s Hospital Association jointly declared a National State of Emergency in Children’s Mental Health and called on policy makers to address a host of challenges that have impeded access to effective mental health care for youth.

In November, we wrote about how pediatricians may increase their use of screening for adolescent depression and initiate treatment when appropriate.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Now we complement that piece with guidance you may offer the parents of your depressed adolescent patients. Adolescent depression is a common pediatric disorder, especially in the COVID-19 era when so many relationships and activities have been limited or cut off. With treatment, most adolescents recover. Accepting that it may be taking longer to find a therapist, you can make treatment recommendations, support the teenager and parents, address safety concerns and, if the depression is of moderate or more serious severity, start medications. Parents are your natural partners as they are concerned about their children’s health and safety and eager for guidance on how to best support their recovery.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Adolescence is a time in which parents transition to more of a consulting than a controlling posture with their children, but illness calls for a shift toward setting rules and routines that will support health and healing. Prepare both the teenager (in a 1:1 discussion) and parents for this temporary shift, and for some teenagers, expect resistance. Depression will make the teenager more unhappy and irritable. It also causes withdrawal, by sapping energy and making one feel unwelcome at activities, believing his or her presence will be a burden to others. Treatment includes something called “behavioral activation,” or continuous nudging, to keep the patient involved in social, intellectual, and physical activities. Parents (and siblings) are the keys to this behavioral activation, whether nudging to participate in a board game or a walk. Reassure parents they should not take it personally when their teen resists, and not be discouraged if they fail sometimes. Their focus is on calmly, warmly, and repeatedly prompting their children with nudges toward these routines and activities. They should be ready to remind them why they are “nagging,” framing these efforts explicitly as supporting recovery from depression. If possible, applying these rules to everyone at home will help. They need to avoid being drawn into conflict, focusing instead on staying connected to their teens. Their task is to keep planning and cajoling, giving their children multiple opportunities to participate, pushing back against depression’s gravitational pull for total withdrawal.
 

Sleep

One of the most important thing parents can do for their depressed adolescents is to support their healthy restful sleep. During adolescence, the timing of sleep naturally shifts later, and the need for restful sleep increases. Working against the demands of homework, extracurricular activities, and social connections, sleep often suffers during adolescence. Further sleep disruptions, including difficulty falling asleep and frequent awakening during sleep or in the early morning, are typical of depression. Restful sleep is instrumental to recovery, and parents need to help their depressed teens set good sleep habits. This includes setting a time for bed that is realistic and consistent and turning off screens 30 minutes before lights out. A soothing, consistent bedtime routine, including a hot shower and reading in bed, is a powerful cue for sleep. Getting daily exercise and avoiding a heavy meal and caffeine in the hours before bed supports both falling and staying asleep. Having light reading near bed (magazines or comics) instead of screens can provide a way to pass 30 minutes if they wake up during the night (ideally reading out of bed), one that will not make it harder for them to go back to sleep. Finally, teens should not be allowed to spend all day in bed or nap in the afternoon. This may be the hardest task for parents, as adolescents naturally treat their beds like their center of operations and depression lowers their energy and initiative. If parents set these rules and routines for all members of the family, it can improve the chances that their depressed adolescents may begin to return to healthy sleep.

 

 

Exercise

Vigorous exercise (for 20 minutes three times weekly) is as effective as SSRIs in treating mild to moderate depression. Even in severe depression, exercise may accelerate recovery and certainly contributes to returning to restful sleep and a feeling of improved energy. Inviting their depressed teens to join them on a trip to the gym may seem like a fool’s errand to parents, but they should prioritize getting their children moving. Don’t offer choices or ask what activity they would like to do. Most invitations will be met with “no, thanks” (or probably something less polite). Instead, initiate simple activities and then cajole the children with “let’s go!” They should use loving persistence to get them out the door. Parents are the experts on their children and will know if there is an activity that they are more likely to enjoy. Make any activities group ones, easy to start and not too long. They could initiate family walks or bike rides in their neighborhood. If it helps, they can blame you, “these are doctor’s orders!” This approach of warm persistence should be applied across the board, helping their depressed teens participate in mealtimes and other activities. Prepare parents that this can feel unnatural, if they have been letting their healthy teenagers have more space and independence and less time in family activities.

Social connections

Behavioral activation includes keeping a depressed teen engaged in social activities. Friendships are a potent motivator in the lives of healthy adolescents. If depressed teens can stay connected to close friends, it is a powerful force for recovery. Find out if their friends know about their depression, whom do they trust to tell about it? Help them find comfortable language to speak about their depression with trusted friends. Parents can use their behavioral activation strategies to prompt their teenagers to participate in social activities. If texting, video chatting, or social media platforms are how they stay connected with close friends, support their use of these platforms. But be mindful that social media promotes social comparison over connection, and depression sets them up to feel less than others even without assistance. Parents should support real time with their friends in small groups, for short periods during the time of day when they have the most energy.

Safety

Suicide is the second leading cause of death for adolescents in the United States, and the rate of attempted and completed suicide in adolescents has been steadily climbing over the past decade according to the CDC. The rate is higher in older adolescents, though thankfully relatively uncommon (about 1 in 10,000 a year), and, although we know risk factors, no one has been able to predict reliably the risk for an individual teenager at a point in time. In a clinically referred sample, 85% of depressed adolescents will have suicidal ideation and 32% will make a suicide attempt. The risk is higher in those adolescents with more than one psychiatric diagnosis and with a history of impulsive behaviors, substance abuse, prior suicide attempts, and a family history of suicide. It is important that parents hear that asking about suicidal thoughts will not cause them. On the contrary, preserving open communication and a warm relationship is very protective. Adolescent suicide attempts are likely to be impulsive, so helping the family to consider ways to “put up obstacles” that would slow down any possible attempt is an effective way to improve safety. Ask your patients about suicidal thoughts, plans, and what keeps them safe. Find out if they worry about sharing these thoughts with their parents and why. Ask if there are ways their parents can check on them that “aren’t too annoying.” Determine if there are guns in the home, and if so, are they safely stored (locked, separate from ammunition)? More than 50% of completed adolescent suicides involve firearms, so this question is critical. What about access to medications that could be dangerous in overdose in your home or a relative’s home they may visit? Discussing these facts with your patients and their parents together will make it easier for them to continue the conversation outside of your office and can make an enormous difference in their recovery.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Reference

Kovacs M et al. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1993 Jan;32(1):8-20.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

A pediatrician’s guide to screening for and treating depression

Article Type
Changed
Wed, 11/10/2021 - 13:35

 

On Oct. 19, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, and the Children’s Hospital Association jointly declared a “national emergency in children’s mental health,” calling upon policy makers to take actions that could help address “soaring rates” of anxiety and depression.

Knowing that increasing the work force or creating new programs will come slowly if at all, they called for the integration of mental health care into primary care pediatrics and efforts to reduce the risk of suicide in children and adolescents.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Our clinical experience suggests that adolescent depression, which can lead to profoundly impaired function, impaired development, and even suicide, is a major concern in your practice. We hope to do our part by reviewing the screening, diagnosis, and management of depression that can reasonably happen in the pediatrician’s office.

Depression

Depression affects as many as 20% of adolescents, with girls experiencing major depressive disorder (MDD) twice as often as boys. The incidence of depression increases fourfold after puberty, and there is substantial evidence, but no clear cause, that it has increased by nearly 50% over the past decade, rising from a rate of 8% of U.S. adolescents in 2007 to 13% in 2017.1 In that same time period, the rate of completed suicides among U.S. youth aged 10-24 increased 57.4%, after being stable for the prior decade.2 Adolescent depression is also linked to increased substance use and high-risk behaviors such as drunk driving. In 2020, mental health–related emergency department visits by adolescents aged 12-17 increased by 31%. Visits for suicide attempts among adolescent girls in 2021 jumped by 51% from 2019.3 Clearly, MDD in adolescence is a common, potentially life-threatening problem

.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Screening and assessment

At annual checkups with patients 12 and older or at sick visits of patients with emotional, sleep, or vague somatic concerns, it should be standard practice to screen for depression. The Patient Health Questionnaire 9 modified for Adolescents (PHQ9-A) is a reliable, validated, and free screening instrument that your patients can fill out in the waiting room. (The PHQ9 can be used for your patients who are 18 and older.) It takes only 5 minutes to complete and is very easy to score. It establishes whether your patient meets DSM-5 criteria for MDD, and the degree of severity (5-9 is mild, 10-14 is moderate, 15-19 is moderately severe, and 20-27 is severe). It also screens for thoughts about suicide and past suicide attempts. You might add the more comprehensive parent-completed Pediatric Symptom Checklist, which includes a depression screen.4

These screening instruments can be completed electronically prior to or at the visit and should have a preamble explaining why depression screening is relevant. If screening is positive, interview your adolescent patients alone. This will give you the time to gather more detail about how impaired their function is at school, with friends, and in family relationships. Have they been missing school? Have their grades changed? Are they failing to hand in homework? Have they withdrawn from sports or activities? Are they less likely to hang out with friends? Do they participate in family activities? Have others noticed any changes? You should also check for associated anxiety symptoms (ruminative worries, panic attacks) and drug and alcohol use. Of course, you should ask about any suicidal thoughts (from vague morbid thoughts to specific plans, with intent and factors that have prevented them) and actual attempts. Remember, asking about suicidal thoughts and attempts will not cause or worsen them. On the contrary, your patients may feel shame, but will be relieved to not be alone with these thoughts. And this knowledge will be essential as you decide what to do next. When you meet with the parents, ask them about a family history of depression or suicide attempts, and then offer supportive interventions.
 

 

 

Supportive interventions

For all adolescents with depression, supportive interventions are helpful, and for those with mild symptoms, they are often adequate treatment. This begins with education for your patient and their parents about depression. It is an illness, not a problem of character or discipline. Advise your patients that adequate, restful sleep every night is critical to recovery. Regular exercise (daily is best, but at least three times weekly for 30 minutes) is often effective in mild to moderate depression. Patience and compassion for feelings of sadness, irritability, or disinterest are important at home, and maintaining connections with those people who offer support (friends, coaches, parents, etc.) is essential. They should also be told that “depression lies.” Feelings of guilt and self-reproach are a normal part of the illness, not facts. Organizations such as the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (AACAP) offer written materials through their websites that are very helpful educational resources. Connect them with sources of counseling support (through school, for example). For those with mild, brief, and uncomplicated depression, supportive interventions alone should offer relief within 4-6 weeks. It is hard to predict the trajectory of depression, so follow-up visits are relevant to determine if they are improving or worsening.

Psychotherapy

For your patients with moderate depression, or with hopelessness or suicidality, a referral for evidence-based psychotherapy is indicated. Both cognitive behavioral therapy and interpersonal therapy have demonstrated efficacy in treating depression in adolescents. If there is a history of trauma or high family conflict, supportive psychotherapy that will enhance communication skills within the family is very important to recovery. Identify various sources for high-quality psychotherapy services (individual, family, and group) in your community. While this may sound easier said than done, online services such as Psychology Today’s therapist locator can help. If your local university has a graduate program in social work or psychology, connect with them as they may have easier access to high-quality services through their training programs. If there is a group practice of therapists in your community, invite them to meet with your team to learn about whether they use evidence-based therapies and can support families as well as individual youth.

Pharmacologic options

For those adolescents with moderate to severe depression, psychotherapy alone is usually inadequate. Indeed, they may be so impaired that they simply cannot meaningfully engage in the work of psychotherapy. These patients require psychopharmacologic treatment first. First-line treatment is with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) (both fluoxetine and escitalopram are approved for use in adolescent depression). While many pediatricians remain reluctant about initiating SSRI treatment of depression since the Food and Drug Administration’s 2004 boxed warning was issued, the risks of untreated severe depression are more marked than are the risks of SSRI treatment. As prescription rates dipped in the following decade, rates of suicide attempts in adolescents with severe depression climbed. Subsequent research on the nature of the risk of “increased suicidality” indicated it is substantially lower than originally thought.

The AAP’s Guidelines for Adolescent Depression in Primary Care offer reassuring guidance: They recommend that pediatricians initiate treatment at a very low dose of SSRI (5 mg of fluoxetine, 12.5 mg of sertraline, or 5 mg of escitalopram) and aim to get to a therapeutic dose within 4 weeks.5 Educate the patient and parent about likely side effects (gastrointestinal upset, sleep disruption, akathisia or restlessness, and activation), which indicate the dose should be held steady until the side effects subside. Patients should be seen weekly until they get to a therapeutic dose, then biweekly to monitor for response. At these regular check-ins, the PHQ9A can follow symptom severity. You should monitor changes in function and for any change in suicidal thoughts. If your patient does not respond with at least energy improvement within 4 weeks, you should cross-taper to a different SSRI.
 

 

 

Managing risk

Suicidal thoughts are a common symptom of depression and an important marker of severity. Adolescents have more limited impulse control than do adults, elevating their risk for impulsively acting on these thoughts. Adolescents who are using alcohol or other substances, or who have a history of impulsivity, are at higher risk. Further compounding the degree of risk are a history of suicide attempts, impulsive aggression or psychotic symptoms, or a family history of completed suicide. In managing risk, it is critical that you assess and discuss these risk factors and discuss the need to have a safety plan.

This planning should include both patient and parent. Help the parent to identify lethal means at home (guns, rope, medications, and knives or box cutters) and make plans to secure or remove them. It includes helping your patient list those strategies that can be helpful if they are feeling more distressed (distracting with music or television, exercise, or connecting with select friends). A safety plan is not a promise or a contract to not do something, rather it is a practical set of strategies the patient and family can employ if they are feeling worse. It depends on the adolescent having a secure, trusting connection with the adults at home and with your office.

If your patient fails to improve, if the diagnosis appears complicated, or if you feel the patient is not safe, you should refer to child psychiatry or, if needed, a local emergency department. If you cannot find access to a psychiatrist, start with your state’s child psychiatric consultation hotline for access to telephone support: www.nncpap.org.

Although the suggestions outlined above are grounded in evidence and need, treating moderate to severe depression is likely a new challenge for many pediatricians. Managing the risk of suicide can be stressful, without a doubt. In our own work as child psychiatrists, we recognize that there is no single, reliable method to predict suicide and therefore no specific approach to ensuring prevention. We appreciate this burden of worry when treating a severely depressed adolescent, and follow the rule, “never worry alone” – share your concerns with parents and/or a mental health consultant (hopefully co-located in your office), or obtain a second opinion, even consult a child psychiatrist on a hotline. Offering supportive care for those with mild depression can prevent it from becoming severe, and beginning treatment for those with severe depression can make a profound difference in the course of a young person’s illness.
 

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Pew Research Center. National Survey on Drug Use and Health (2017).

2. Curtin SC. Natl Vital Stat Rep. 2020 Sep;69(11):1-10.

3. Yard E et al. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2021 Jun 18;70(24):888-94.

4. Jellinek M et al. J Pediatr. 2021 Jun;233:220-6.e1.

5. Zuckerbrot RA et al. Pediatrics. 2018 Mar;141(3):e20174081.

Publications
Topics
Sections

 

On Oct. 19, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, and the Children’s Hospital Association jointly declared a “national emergency in children’s mental health,” calling upon policy makers to take actions that could help address “soaring rates” of anxiety and depression.

Knowing that increasing the work force or creating new programs will come slowly if at all, they called for the integration of mental health care into primary care pediatrics and efforts to reduce the risk of suicide in children and adolescents.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Our clinical experience suggests that adolescent depression, which can lead to profoundly impaired function, impaired development, and even suicide, is a major concern in your practice. We hope to do our part by reviewing the screening, diagnosis, and management of depression that can reasonably happen in the pediatrician’s office.

Depression

Depression affects as many as 20% of adolescents, with girls experiencing major depressive disorder (MDD) twice as often as boys. The incidence of depression increases fourfold after puberty, and there is substantial evidence, but no clear cause, that it has increased by nearly 50% over the past decade, rising from a rate of 8% of U.S. adolescents in 2007 to 13% in 2017.1 In that same time period, the rate of completed suicides among U.S. youth aged 10-24 increased 57.4%, after being stable for the prior decade.2 Adolescent depression is also linked to increased substance use and high-risk behaviors such as drunk driving. In 2020, mental health–related emergency department visits by adolescents aged 12-17 increased by 31%. Visits for suicide attempts among adolescent girls in 2021 jumped by 51% from 2019.3 Clearly, MDD in adolescence is a common, potentially life-threatening problem

.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Screening and assessment

At annual checkups with patients 12 and older or at sick visits of patients with emotional, sleep, or vague somatic concerns, it should be standard practice to screen for depression. The Patient Health Questionnaire 9 modified for Adolescents (PHQ9-A) is a reliable, validated, and free screening instrument that your patients can fill out in the waiting room. (The PHQ9 can be used for your patients who are 18 and older.) It takes only 5 minutes to complete and is very easy to score. It establishes whether your patient meets DSM-5 criteria for MDD, and the degree of severity (5-9 is mild, 10-14 is moderate, 15-19 is moderately severe, and 20-27 is severe). It also screens for thoughts about suicide and past suicide attempts. You might add the more comprehensive parent-completed Pediatric Symptom Checklist, which includes a depression screen.4

These screening instruments can be completed electronically prior to or at the visit and should have a preamble explaining why depression screening is relevant. If screening is positive, interview your adolescent patients alone. This will give you the time to gather more detail about how impaired their function is at school, with friends, and in family relationships. Have they been missing school? Have their grades changed? Are they failing to hand in homework? Have they withdrawn from sports or activities? Are they less likely to hang out with friends? Do they participate in family activities? Have others noticed any changes? You should also check for associated anxiety symptoms (ruminative worries, panic attacks) and drug and alcohol use. Of course, you should ask about any suicidal thoughts (from vague morbid thoughts to specific plans, with intent and factors that have prevented them) and actual attempts. Remember, asking about suicidal thoughts and attempts will not cause or worsen them. On the contrary, your patients may feel shame, but will be relieved to not be alone with these thoughts. And this knowledge will be essential as you decide what to do next. When you meet with the parents, ask them about a family history of depression or suicide attempts, and then offer supportive interventions.
 

 

 

Supportive interventions

For all adolescents with depression, supportive interventions are helpful, and for those with mild symptoms, they are often adequate treatment. This begins with education for your patient and their parents about depression. It is an illness, not a problem of character or discipline. Advise your patients that adequate, restful sleep every night is critical to recovery. Regular exercise (daily is best, but at least three times weekly for 30 minutes) is often effective in mild to moderate depression. Patience and compassion for feelings of sadness, irritability, or disinterest are important at home, and maintaining connections with those people who offer support (friends, coaches, parents, etc.) is essential. They should also be told that “depression lies.” Feelings of guilt and self-reproach are a normal part of the illness, not facts. Organizations such as the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (AACAP) offer written materials through their websites that are very helpful educational resources. Connect them with sources of counseling support (through school, for example). For those with mild, brief, and uncomplicated depression, supportive interventions alone should offer relief within 4-6 weeks. It is hard to predict the trajectory of depression, so follow-up visits are relevant to determine if they are improving or worsening.

Psychotherapy

For your patients with moderate depression, or with hopelessness or suicidality, a referral for evidence-based psychotherapy is indicated. Both cognitive behavioral therapy and interpersonal therapy have demonstrated efficacy in treating depression in adolescents. If there is a history of trauma or high family conflict, supportive psychotherapy that will enhance communication skills within the family is very important to recovery. Identify various sources for high-quality psychotherapy services (individual, family, and group) in your community. While this may sound easier said than done, online services such as Psychology Today’s therapist locator can help. If your local university has a graduate program in social work or psychology, connect with them as they may have easier access to high-quality services through their training programs. If there is a group practice of therapists in your community, invite them to meet with your team to learn about whether they use evidence-based therapies and can support families as well as individual youth.

Pharmacologic options

For those adolescents with moderate to severe depression, psychotherapy alone is usually inadequate. Indeed, they may be so impaired that they simply cannot meaningfully engage in the work of psychotherapy. These patients require psychopharmacologic treatment first. First-line treatment is with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) (both fluoxetine and escitalopram are approved for use in adolescent depression). While many pediatricians remain reluctant about initiating SSRI treatment of depression since the Food and Drug Administration’s 2004 boxed warning was issued, the risks of untreated severe depression are more marked than are the risks of SSRI treatment. As prescription rates dipped in the following decade, rates of suicide attempts in adolescents with severe depression climbed. Subsequent research on the nature of the risk of “increased suicidality” indicated it is substantially lower than originally thought.

The AAP’s Guidelines for Adolescent Depression in Primary Care offer reassuring guidance: They recommend that pediatricians initiate treatment at a very low dose of SSRI (5 mg of fluoxetine, 12.5 mg of sertraline, or 5 mg of escitalopram) and aim to get to a therapeutic dose within 4 weeks.5 Educate the patient and parent about likely side effects (gastrointestinal upset, sleep disruption, akathisia or restlessness, and activation), which indicate the dose should be held steady until the side effects subside. Patients should be seen weekly until they get to a therapeutic dose, then biweekly to monitor for response. At these regular check-ins, the PHQ9A can follow symptom severity. You should monitor changes in function and for any change in suicidal thoughts. If your patient does not respond with at least energy improvement within 4 weeks, you should cross-taper to a different SSRI.
 

 

 

Managing risk

Suicidal thoughts are a common symptom of depression and an important marker of severity. Adolescents have more limited impulse control than do adults, elevating their risk for impulsively acting on these thoughts. Adolescents who are using alcohol or other substances, or who have a history of impulsivity, are at higher risk. Further compounding the degree of risk are a history of suicide attempts, impulsive aggression or psychotic symptoms, or a family history of completed suicide. In managing risk, it is critical that you assess and discuss these risk factors and discuss the need to have a safety plan.

This planning should include both patient and parent. Help the parent to identify lethal means at home (guns, rope, medications, and knives or box cutters) and make plans to secure or remove them. It includes helping your patient list those strategies that can be helpful if they are feeling more distressed (distracting with music or television, exercise, or connecting with select friends). A safety plan is not a promise or a contract to not do something, rather it is a practical set of strategies the patient and family can employ if they are feeling worse. It depends on the adolescent having a secure, trusting connection with the adults at home and with your office.

If your patient fails to improve, if the diagnosis appears complicated, or if you feel the patient is not safe, you should refer to child psychiatry or, if needed, a local emergency department. If you cannot find access to a psychiatrist, start with your state’s child psychiatric consultation hotline for access to telephone support: www.nncpap.org.

Although the suggestions outlined above are grounded in evidence and need, treating moderate to severe depression is likely a new challenge for many pediatricians. Managing the risk of suicide can be stressful, without a doubt. In our own work as child psychiatrists, we recognize that there is no single, reliable method to predict suicide and therefore no specific approach to ensuring prevention. We appreciate this burden of worry when treating a severely depressed adolescent, and follow the rule, “never worry alone” – share your concerns with parents and/or a mental health consultant (hopefully co-located in your office), or obtain a second opinion, even consult a child psychiatrist on a hotline. Offering supportive care for those with mild depression can prevent it from becoming severe, and beginning treatment for those with severe depression can make a profound difference in the course of a young person’s illness.
 

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Pew Research Center. National Survey on Drug Use and Health (2017).

2. Curtin SC. Natl Vital Stat Rep. 2020 Sep;69(11):1-10.

3. Yard E et al. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2021 Jun 18;70(24):888-94.

4. Jellinek M et al. J Pediatr. 2021 Jun;233:220-6.e1.

5. Zuckerbrot RA et al. Pediatrics. 2018 Mar;141(3):e20174081.

 

On Oct. 19, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, and the Children’s Hospital Association jointly declared a “national emergency in children’s mental health,” calling upon policy makers to take actions that could help address “soaring rates” of anxiety and depression.

Knowing that increasing the work force or creating new programs will come slowly if at all, they called for the integration of mental health care into primary care pediatrics and efforts to reduce the risk of suicide in children and adolescents.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Our clinical experience suggests that adolescent depression, which can lead to profoundly impaired function, impaired development, and even suicide, is a major concern in your practice. We hope to do our part by reviewing the screening, diagnosis, and management of depression that can reasonably happen in the pediatrician’s office.

Depression

Depression affects as many as 20% of adolescents, with girls experiencing major depressive disorder (MDD) twice as often as boys. The incidence of depression increases fourfold after puberty, and there is substantial evidence, but no clear cause, that it has increased by nearly 50% over the past decade, rising from a rate of 8% of U.S. adolescents in 2007 to 13% in 2017.1 In that same time period, the rate of completed suicides among U.S. youth aged 10-24 increased 57.4%, after being stable for the prior decade.2 Adolescent depression is also linked to increased substance use and high-risk behaviors such as drunk driving. In 2020, mental health–related emergency department visits by adolescents aged 12-17 increased by 31%. Visits for suicide attempts among adolescent girls in 2021 jumped by 51% from 2019.3 Clearly, MDD in adolescence is a common, potentially life-threatening problem

.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Screening and assessment

At annual checkups with patients 12 and older or at sick visits of patients with emotional, sleep, or vague somatic concerns, it should be standard practice to screen for depression. The Patient Health Questionnaire 9 modified for Adolescents (PHQ9-A) is a reliable, validated, and free screening instrument that your patients can fill out in the waiting room. (The PHQ9 can be used for your patients who are 18 and older.) It takes only 5 minutes to complete and is very easy to score. It establishes whether your patient meets DSM-5 criteria for MDD, and the degree of severity (5-9 is mild, 10-14 is moderate, 15-19 is moderately severe, and 20-27 is severe). It also screens for thoughts about suicide and past suicide attempts. You might add the more comprehensive parent-completed Pediatric Symptom Checklist, which includes a depression screen.4

These screening instruments can be completed electronically prior to or at the visit and should have a preamble explaining why depression screening is relevant. If screening is positive, interview your adolescent patients alone. This will give you the time to gather more detail about how impaired their function is at school, with friends, and in family relationships. Have they been missing school? Have their grades changed? Are they failing to hand in homework? Have they withdrawn from sports or activities? Are they less likely to hang out with friends? Do they participate in family activities? Have others noticed any changes? You should also check for associated anxiety symptoms (ruminative worries, panic attacks) and drug and alcohol use. Of course, you should ask about any suicidal thoughts (from vague morbid thoughts to specific plans, with intent and factors that have prevented them) and actual attempts. Remember, asking about suicidal thoughts and attempts will not cause or worsen them. On the contrary, your patients may feel shame, but will be relieved to not be alone with these thoughts. And this knowledge will be essential as you decide what to do next. When you meet with the parents, ask them about a family history of depression or suicide attempts, and then offer supportive interventions.
 

 

 

Supportive interventions

For all adolescents with depression, supportive interventions are helpful, and for those with mild symptoms, they are often adequate treatment. This begins with education for your patient and their parents about depression. It is an illness, not a problem of character or discipline. Advise your patients that adequate, restful sleep every night is critical to recovery. Regular exercise (daily is best, but at least three times weekly for 30 minutes) is often effective in mild to moderate depression. Patience and compassion for feelings of sadness, irritability, or disinterest are important at home, and maintaining connections with those people who offer support (friends, coaches, parents, etc.) is essential. They should also be told that “depression lies.” Feelings of guilt and self-reproach are a normal part of the illness, not facts. Organizations such as the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (AACAP) offer written materials through their websites that are very helpful educational resources. Connect them with sources of counseling support (through school, for example). For those with mild, brief, and uncomplicated depression, supportive interventions alone should offer relief within 4-6 weeks. It is hard to predict the trajectory of depression, so follow-up visits are relevant to determine if they are improving or worsening.

Psychotherapy

For your patients with moderate depression, or with hopelessness or suicidality, a referral for evidence-based psychotherapy is indicated. Both cognitive behavioral therapy and interpersonal therapy have demonstrated efficacy in treating depression in adolescents. If there is a history of trauma or high family conflict, supportive psychotherapy that will enhance communication skills within the family is very important to recovery. Identify various sources for high-quality psychotherapy services (individual, family, and group) in your community. While this may sound easier said than done, online services such as Psychology Today’s therapist locator can help. If your local university has a graduate program in social work or psychology, connect with them as they may have easier access to high-quality services through their training programs. If there is a group practice of therapists in your community, invite them to meet with your team to learn about whether they use evidence-based therapies and can support families as well as individual youth.

Pharmacologic options

For those adolescents with moderate to severe depression, psychotherapy alone is usually inadequate. Indeed, they may be so impaired that they simply cannot meaningfully engage in the work of psychotherapy. These patients require psychopharmacologic treatment first. First-line treatment is with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) (both fluoxetine and escitalopram are approved for use in adolescent depression). While many pediatricians remain reluctant about initiating SSRI treatment of depression since the Food and Drug Administration’s 2004 boxed warning was issued, the risks of untreated severe depression are more marked than are the risks of SSRI treatment. As prescription rates dipped in the following decade, rates of suicide attempts in adolescents with severe depression climbed. Subsequent research on the nature of the risk of “increased suicidality” indicated it is substantially lower than originally thought.

The AAP’s Guidelines for Adolescent Depression in Primary Care offer reassuring guidance: They recommend that pediatricians initiate treatment at a very low dose of SSRI (5 mg of fluoxetine, 12.5 mg of sertraline, or 5 mg of escitalopram) and aim to get to a therapeutic dose within 4 weeks.5 Educate the patient and parent about likely side effects (gastrointestinal upset, sleep disruption, akathisia or restlessness, and activation), which indicate the dose should be held steady until the side effects subside. Patients should be seen weekly until they get to a therapeutic dose, then biweekly to monitor for response. At these regular check-ins, the PHQ9A can follow symptom severity. You should monitor changes in function and for any change in suicidal thoughts. If your patient does not respond with at least energy improvement within 4 weeks, you should cross-taper to a different SSRI.
 

 

 

Managing risk

Suicidal thoughts are a common symptom of depression and an important marker of severity. Adolescents have more limited impulse control than do adults, elevating their risk for impulsively acting on these thoughts. Adolescents who are using alcohol or other substances, or who have a history of impulsivity, are at higher risk. Further compounding the degree of risk are a history of suicide attempts, impulsive aggression or psychotic symptoms, or a family history of completed suicide. In managing risk, it is critical that you assess and discuss these risk factors and discuss the need to have a safety plan.

This planning should include both patient and parent. Help the parent to identify lethal means at home (guns, rope, medications, and knives or box cutters) and make plans to secure or remove them. It includes helping your patient list those strategies that can be helpful if they are feeling more distressed (distracting with music or television, exercise, or connecting with select friends). A safety plan is not a promise or a contract to not do something, rather it is a practical set of strategies the patient and family can employ if they are feeling worse. It depends on the adolescent having a secure, trusting connection with the adults at home and with your office.

If your patient fails to improve, if the diagnosis appears complicated, or if you feel the patient is not safe, you should refer to child psychiatry or, if needed, a local emergency department. If you cannot find access to a psychiatrist, start with your state’s child psychiatric consultation hotline for access to telephone support: www.nncpap.org.

Although the suggestions outlined above are grounded in evidence and need, treating moderate to severe depression is likely a new challenge for many pediatricians. Managing the risk of suicide can be stressful, without a doubt. In our own work as child psychiatrists, we recognize that there is no single, reliable method to predict suicide and therefore no specific approach to ensuring prevention. We appreciate this burden of worry when treating a severely depressed adolescent, and follow the rule, “never worry alone” – share your concerns with parents and/or a mental health consultant (hopefully co-located in your office), or obtain a second opinion, even consult a child psychiatrist on a hotline. Offering supportive care for those with mild depression can prevent it from becoming severe, and beginning treatment for those with severe depression can make a profound difference in the course of a young person’s illness.
 

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Pew Research Center. National Survey on Drug Use and Health (2017).

2. Curtin SC. Natl Vital Stat Rep. 2020 Sep;69(11):1-10.

3. Yard E et al. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2021 Jun 18;70(24):888-94.

4. Jellinek M et al. J Pediatr. 2021 Jun;233:220-6.e1.

5. Zuckerbrot RA et al. Pediatrics. 2018 Mar;141(3):e20174081.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

Marijuana and LSD guidance for pediatricians

Article Type
Changed
Fri, 09/17/2021 - 10:24

Seeking novelty is central to adolescence; experimentation is how they explore their identity, exert independence, and establish deep and connected relationships outside of the family. Research over the past 2 decades has demonstrated the neurobiological changes that underpin this increase in sensation seeking. Most adolescents are very good at assessing risk but are willing to tolerate higher levels of risk than adults in the pursuit of novelty.1 If their knowledge base is limited or inaccurate, as is often the case with drugs and alcohol, accepting higher risk becomes more dangerous. Adolescents are more likely to trust their peers than their parents, but their pediatricians still have authority and credibility.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

While there is ample credible information online (from the National Institute on Drug Abuse and the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration’s excellent websites, which can be recommended to teens), marijuana and hallucinogens (LSD and psilocybin) bear special discussion here because of changing legality and their potential medical utility. There is an emerging impression of safety with both; however, policy changes and for-profit marketing may not reflect the actual scientific evidence. You have the opportunity and authority to complicate your patient’s thinking by discussing the evidence supporting their medical utility, and the emerging evidence that both types of drugs may pose special risks for their developing brains.

By June 2021, marijuana was legal for recreational use in 19 states; Washington, D.C.; and Guam, and for “medical use” in 36 states and four territories. Entrepreneurs and activists have made spectacular claims that marijuana is effective for the treatment of everything from insomnia to PTSD, but the reality is less impressive. Of course, marijuana remains a schedule I drug under the federal Controlled Substances Act (1970), which has made it difficult for researchers to perform randomized controlled studies concerning treatment or risks.

However, there are a growing number of randomized controlled trials with synthetic cannabinoids (dronabinol and nabilone) and a (legal) drug derived from cannabis (cannabidiol or CBD, as distinct from the other active ingredient, tetrahydrocannabinol). There is Food and Drug Administration approval for CBD for the treatment of epilepsy in Lennox-Gastaut or Dravet syndrome in patients aged 2 years or younger, and for the synthetic agents for the treatment of chemotherapy-related nausea and vomiting in cancer patients and for the treatment of weight loss and muscle wasting related to HIV/AIDS. That’s it. There is some evidence that these agents may be effective for the treatment of muscle spasticity in multiple sclerosis, chronic pain of many etiologies, Tourette syndrome, insomnia related to multiple sclerosis and chronic pain, and possibly PTSD. But there have been multiple studies that have failed to demonstrate efficacy (or have demonstrated exacerbation) for a host of other medical and psychiatric problems.

While the evidence for marijuana’s medicinal uses is modest, there is substantial evidence that its use in adolescence carries risks. It is an addictive substance and regular use is associated with sustained modest cognitive impairment (a loss of up to eight IQ points in the clinically dependent) and higher rates of anxiety and depressive disorders. As with other substances, use before the age of 18 substantially raises the risk (as much as sevenfold) of developing addiction than the same rate of use in adulthood. The rate of schizophrenia in adolescents with heavy marijuana use is between six and seven times greater than in the general population, whereas similar adult use does not have this association.2,3 Studies in rats have demonstrated that use during adolescence delays and permanently changes the maturation of the prefrontal cortex, an area of the brain that is essential for complex decision-making, sustaining attention, abstract reasoning, and impulse control.4 While we do not fully understand the exact nature of these changes, there is good reason to believe that regular marijuana use in adolescence leads to disruption of critical brain development and cognitive or even psychotic consequences. It is worth noting that the potency of many commercially available marijuana products is much higher than those that were studied, raising the risk and uncertainty further.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Hallucinogens, or “psychedelics” (from Greek for “mind manifesting”) are a class that includes LSD and psilocybin (a chemical found in over 200 species of mushrooms). They precipitate visual and auditory “hallucinations,” a loss of sense of self, and a sense of awe that may be transcendent or frightening. While psilocybin was used by many indigenous cultures in religious ceremonies, LSD was synthesized by a chemist at Sandoz in 1938 and made widely available for study until it was classified as a schedule I drug by the 1970 Controlled Substances Act. They are not addictive. Early research demonstrated promise in the treatment of alcohol dependence and several psychiatric conditions (including other addictions and treatment-resistant depression). Research resumed in 2018, demonstrating promise in the treatment of depression related to terminal illness. Research has also concerned the nature of consciousness and spiritual experiences. Hallucinogens have become popular in certain fields (high tech) as a means of optimizing creativity and performance (“microdosing”). There is modest evidence that use in people with a family history of psychotic illness may precipitate sustained psychotic symptoms. Regular use may further increase the risk of persistent psychosis and adolescent users of multiple substances are at high risk for regular hallucinogen use. Adolescents may think that ketamine, phencyclidine , and 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine are also in this category, although they are different and considerably more risky drugs. Overall, these agents show therapeutic promise, but unless your young patients are facing depression related to a terminal illness and until we learn more from studies, the potential risk to their developing brains outweighs any potential benefits.

Aware of this information, you are ready to ask your adolescent patients about their drug and alcohol use and knowledge. Using phrases like “when did you first try ...” can increase the likelihood that your patients will be forthright with you. Or start by asking about what their friends are trying and talking about. Be curious about any drug and alcohol use at home. Find out what they are curious about, whom they trust, and where they get their information. Then you can offer your information about the dramatic changes happening in their brains (just like the rest of their bodies) and the special risks of drug use during this window of brain development. Acknowledge that the risks of marijuana use in adults may very well be lower than the risks of regular alcohol use but remind them about how their brains are different than those of adults. Delaying use until they are 18 (or ideally in their mid-20s when most brain development is complete), can dramatically lower these risks. For adolescents with a family history of addiction, psychosis, or mood and anxiety disorders, discuss the additional risks that drugs may present to them. And for those adolescents who acknowledge very early (before 13) or heavy use, be curious with them about whether they might be trying to “feel better” and not just “feel good.” Screen them for depression, suicidality, and anxiety disorders. Those underlying problems are treatable, but their course will only worsen with drug and alcohol use. You are in a unique position to help your adolescent patients make wise and well-informed choices and to get them assistance if they need it.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Romer D. Dev Psychobiol. 2010 Apr;52(3):263-76.

2. Szczepanski SM and Knight TR. Neuron. 2014;83:1002-18.

3. Renard J et al. Front Psychiatry. 2018;9:281.

4. Shen H. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2020 Jan 7;117(1):7-11.

Publications
Topics
Sections

Seeking novelty is central to adolescence; experimentation is how they explore their identity, exert independence, and establish deep and connected relationships outside of the family. Research over the past 2 decades has demonstrated the neurobiological changes that underpin this increase in sensation seeking. Most adolescents are very good at assessing risk but are willing to tolerate higher levels of risk than adults in the pursuit of novelty.1 If their knowledge base is limited or inaccurate, as is often the case with drugs and alcohol, accepting higher risk becomes more dangerous. Adolescents are more likely to trust their peers than their parents, but their pediatricians still have authority and credibility.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

While there is ample credible information online (from the National Institute on Drug Abuse and the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration’s excellent websites, which can be recommended to teens), marijuana and hallucinogens (LSD and psilocybin) bear special discussion here because of changing legality and their potential medical utility. There is an emerging impression of safety with both; however, policy changes and for-profit marketing may not reflect the actual scientific evidence. You have the opportunity and authority to complicate your patient’s thinking by discussing the evidence supporting their medical utility, and the emerging evidence that both types of drugs may pose special risks for their developing brains.

By June 2021, marijuana was legal for recreational use in 19 states; Washington, D.C.; and Guam, and for “medical use” in 36 states and four territories. Entrepreneurs and activists have made spectacular claims that marijuana is effective for the treatment of everything from insomnia to PTSD, but the reality is less impressive. Of course, marijuana remains a schedule I drug under the federal Controlled Substances Act (1970), which has made it difficult for researchers to perform randomized controlled studies concerning treatment or risks.

However, there are a growing number of randomized controlled trials with synthetic cannabinoids (dronabinol and nabilone) and a (legal) drug derived from cannabis (cannabidiol or CBD, as distinct from the other active ingredient, tetrahydrocannabinol). There is Food and Drug Administration approval for CBD for the treatment of epilepsy in Lennox-Gastaut or Dravet syndrome in patients aged 2 years or younger, and for the synthetic agents for the treatment of chemotherapy-related nausea and vomiting in cancer patients and for the treatment of weight loss and muscle wasting related to HIV/AIDS. That’s it. There is some evidence that these agents may be effective for the treatment of muscle spasticity in multiple sclerosis, chronic pain of many etiologies, Tourette syndrome, insomnia related to multiple sclerosis and chronic pain, and possibly PTSD. But there have been multiple studies that have failed to demonstrate efficacy (or have demonstrated exacerbation) for a host of other medical and psychiatric problems.

While the evidence for marijuana’s medicinal uses is modest, there is substantial evidence that its use in adolescence carries risks. It is an addictive substance and regular use is associated with sustained modest cognitive impairment (a loss of up to eight IQ points in the clinically dependent) and higher rates of anxiety and depressive disorders. As with other substances, use before the age of 18 substantially raises the risk (as much as sevenfold) of developing addiction than the same rate of use in adulthood. The rate of schizophrenia in adolescents with heavy marijuana use is between six and seven times greater than in the general population, whereas similar adult use does not have this association.2,3 Studies in rats have demonstrated that use during adolescence delays and permanently changes the maturation of the prefrontal cortex, an area of the brain that is essential for complex decision-making, sustaining attention, abstract reasoning, and impulse control.4 While we do not fully understand the exact nature of these changes, there is good reason to believe that regular marijuana use in adolescence leads to disruption of critical brain development and cognitive or even psychotic consequences. It is worth noting that the potency of many commercially available marijuana products is much higher than those that were studied, raising the risk and uncertainty further.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Hallucinogens, or “psychedelics” (from Greek for “mind manifesting”) are a class that includes LSD and psilocybin (a chemical found in over 200 species of mushrooms). They precipitate visual and auditory “hallucinations,” a loss of sense of self, and a sense of awe that may be transcendent or frightening. While psilocybin was used by many indigenous cultures in religious ceremonies, LSD was synthesized by a chemist at Sandoz in 1938 and made widely available for study until it was classified as a schedule I drug by the 1970 Controlled Substances Act. They are not addictive. Early research demonstrated promise in the treatment of alcohol dependence and several psychiatric conditions (including other addictions and treatment-resistant depression). Research resumed in 2018, demonstrating promise in the treatment of depression related to terminal illness. Research has also concerned the nature of consciousness and spiritual experiences. Hallucinogens have become popular in certain fields (high tech) as a means of optimizing creativity and performance (“microdosing”). There is modest evidence that use in people with a family history of psychotic illness may precipitate sustained psychotic symptoms. Regular use may further increase the risk of persistent psychosis and adolescent users of multiple substances are at high risk for regular hallucinogen use. Adolescents may think that ketamine, phencyclidine , and 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine are also in this category, although they are different and considerably more risky drugs. Overall, these agents show therapeutic promise, but unless your young patients are facing depression related to a terminal illness and until we learn more from studies, the potential risk to their developing brains outweighs any potential benefits.

Aware of this information, you are ready to ask your adolescent patients about their drug and alcohol use and knowledge. Using phrases like “when did you first try ...” can increase the likelihood that your patients will be forthright with you. Or start by asking about what their friends are trying and talking about. Be curious about any drug and alcohol use at home. Find out what they are curious about, whom they trust, and where they get their information. Then you can offer your information about the dramatic changes happening in their brains (just like the rest of their bodies) and the special risks of drug use during this window of brain development. Acknowledge that the risks of marijuana use in adults may very well be lower than the risks of regular alcohol use but remind them about how their brains are different than those of adults. Delaying use until they are 18 (or ideally in their mid-20s when most brain development is complete), can dramatically lower these risks. For adolescents with a family history of addiction, psychosis, or mood and anxiety disorders, discuss the additional risks that drugs may present to them. And for those adolescents who acknowledge very early (before 13) or heavy use, be curious with them about whether they might be trying to “feel better” and not just “feel good.” Screen them for depression, suicidality, and anxiety disorders. Those underlying problems are treatable, but their course will only worsen with drug and alcohol use. You are in a unique position to help your adolescent patients make wise and well-informed choices and to get them assistance if they need it.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Romer D. Dev Psychobiol. 2010 Apr;52(3):263-76.

2. Szczepanski SM and Knight TR. Neuron. 2014;83:1002-18.

3. Renard J et al. Front Psychiatry. 2018;9:281.

4. Shen H. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2020 Jan 7;117(1):7-11.

Seeking novelty is central to adolescence; experimentation is how they explore their identity, exert independence, and establish deep and connected relationships outside of the family. Research over the past 2 decades has demonstrated the neurobiological changes that underpin this increase in sensation seeking. Most adolescents are very good at assessing risk but are willing to tolerate higher levels of risk than adults in the pursuit of novelty.1 If their knowledge base is limited or inaccurate, as is often the case with drugs and alcohol, accepting higher risk becomes more dangerous. Adolescents are more likely to trust their peers than their parents, but their pediatricians still have authority and credibility.

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

While there is ample credible information online (from the National Institute on Drug Abuse and the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration’s excellent websites, which can be recommended to teens), marijuana and hallucinogens (LSD and psilocybin) bear special discussion here because of changing legality and their potential medical utility. There is an emerging impression of safety with both; however, policy changes and for-profit marketing may not reflect the actual scientific evidence. You have the opportunity and authority to complicate your patient’s thinking by discussing the evidence supporting their medical utility, and the emerging evidence that both types of drugs may pose special risks for their developing brains.

By June 2021, marijuana was legal for recreational use in 19 states; Washington, D.C.; and Guam, and for “medical use” in 36 states and four territories. Entrepreneurs and activists have made spectacular claims that marijuana is effective for the treatment of everything from insomnia to PTSD, but the reality is less impressive. Of course, marijuana remains a schedule I drug under the federal Controlled Substances Act (1970), which has made it difficult for researchers to perform randomized controlled studies concerning treatment or risks.

However, there are a growing number of randomized controlled trials with synthetic cannabinoids (dronabinol and nabilone) and a (legal) drug derived from cannabis (cannabidiol or CBD, as distinct from the other active ingredient, tetrahydrocannabinol). There is Food and Drug Administration approval for CBD for the treatment of epilepsy in Lennox-Gastaut or Dravet syndrome in patients aged 2 years or younger, and for the synthetic agents for the treatment of chemotherapy-related nausea and vomiting in cancer patients and for the treatment of weight loss and muscle wasting related to HIV/AIDS. That’s it. There is some evidence that these agents may be effective for the treatment of muscle spasticity in multiple sclerosis, chronic pain of many etiologies, Tourette syndrome, insomnia related to multiple sclerosis and chronic pain, and possibly PTSD. But there have been multiple studies that have failed to demonstrate efficacy (or have demonstrated exacerbation) for a host of other medical and psychiatric problems.

While the evidence for marijuana’s medicinal uses is modest, there is substantial evidence that its use in adolescence carries risks. It is an addictive substance and regular use is associated with sustained modest cognitive impairment (a loss of up to eight IQ points in the clinically dependent) and higher rates of anxiety and depressive disorders. As with other substances, use before the age of 18 substantially raises the risk (as much as sevenfold) of developing addiction than the same rate of use in adulthood. The rate of schizophrenia in adolescents with heavy marijuana use is between six and seven times greater than in the general population, whereas similar adult use does not have this association.2,3 Studies in rats have demonstrated that use during adolescence delays and permanently changes the maturation of the prefrontal cortex, an area of the brain that is essential for complex decision-making, sustaining attention, abstract reasoning, and impulse control.4 While we do not fully understand the exact nature of these changes, there is good reason to believe that regular marijuana use in adolescence leads to disruption of critical brain development and cognitive or even psychotic consequences. It is worth noting that the potency of many commercially available marijuana products is much higher than those that were studied, raising the risk and uncertainty further.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Hallucinogens, or “psychedelics” (from Greek for “mind manifesting”) are a class that includes LSD and psilocybin (a chemical found in over 200 species of mushrooms). They precipitate visual and auditory “hallucinations,” a loss of sense of self, and a sense of awe that may be transcendent or frightening. While psilocybin was used by many indigenous cultures in religious ceremonies, LSD was synthesized by a chemist at Sandoz in 1938 and made widely available for study until it was classified as a schedule I drug by the 1970 Controlled Substances Act. They are not addictive. Early research demonstrated promise in the treatment of alcohol dependence and several psychiatric conditions (including other addictions and treatment-resistant depression). Research resumed in 2018, demonstrating promise in the treatment of depression related to terminal illness. Research has also concerned the nature of consciousness and spiritual experiences. Hallucinogens have become popular in certain fields (high tech) as a means of optimizing creativity and performance (“microdosing”). There is modest evidence that use in people with a family history of psychotic illness may precipitate sustained psychotic symptoms. Regular use may further increase the risk of persistent psychosis and adolescent users of multiple substances are at high risk for regular hallucinogen use. Adolescents may think that ketamine, phencyclidine , and 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine are also in this category, although they are different and considerably more risky drugs. Overall, these agents show therapeutic promise, but unless your young patients are facing depression related to a terminal illness and until we learn more from studies, the potential risk to their developing brains outweighs any potential benefits.

Aware of this information, you are ready to ask your adolescent patients about their drug and alcohol use and knowledge. Using phrases like “when did you first try ...” can increase the likelihood that your patients will be forthright with you. Or start by asking about what their friends are trying and talking about. Be curious about any drug and alcohol use at home. Find out what they are curious about, whom they trust, and where they get their information. Then you can offer your information about the dramatic changes happening in their brains (just like the rest of their bodies) and the special risks of drug use during this window of brain development. Acknowledge that the risks of marijuana use in adults may very well be lower than the risks of regular alcohol use but remind them about how their brains are different than those of adults. Delaying use until they are 18 (or ideally in their mid-20s when most brain development is complete), can dramatically lower these risks. For adolescents with a family history of addiction, psychosis, or mood and anxiety disorders, discuss the additional risks that drugs may present to them. And for those adolescents who acknowledge very early (before 13) or heavy use, be curious with them about whether they might be trying to “feel better” and not just “feel good.” Screen them for depression, suicidality, and anxiety disorders. Those underlying problems are treatable, but their course will only worsen with drug and alcohol use. You are in a unique position to help your adolescent patients make wise and well-informed choices and to get them assistance if they need it.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

References

1. Romer D. Dev Psychobiol. 2010 Apr;52(3):263-76.

2. Szczepanski SM and Knight TR. Neuron. 2014;83:1002-18.

3. Renard J et al. Front Psychiatry. 2018;9:281.

4. Shen H. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2020 Jan 7;117(1):7-11.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

Are there some things we might want to keep from the COVID experience?

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 08/26/2021 - 15:44

As your patients return to your offices for annual exams and sports physicals before the school year starts, everyone will still be processing the challenges, losses, and grief that have marked end of the COVID experience. There will be questions about the safety of vaccines for younger children, whether foreign travel is now a reasonable option, and about how best to help children – school age and teenagers, vulnerable and secure – get their footing socially and academically in the new school year. But dig a little, and you may hear about the silver linings of this past year: children who enjoyed having more time with their parents, parents who were with their families rather than in a car commuting for hours a day or traveling many days a month, grocery deliveries that eased the parent’s workload, adolescents who were able to pull back from overscheduled days, and opportunities for calm conversations that occurred quite naturally during nightly family dinners. Office visits present a dual opportunity to review – what were the psychological costs of COVID and what were positive personal and family adaptations to COVID they may want to continue as the pandemic ends?

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Family dinner: Whether because sports practice was suspended, schooling was virtual, or working was at home, many families returned to eating dinner together during the pandemic year. Nightly dinners are a simple but powerful routine allowing all members of a family to reconnect and recharge together, and they are often the first things to disappear in the face of school, sports, and work demands. Research over the past several decades has demonstrated that regular family dinners are associated with better academic performance and higher self-esteem in children. They are also associated with lower rates of depression, substance abuse, eating disorders, and pregnancy in adolescents. Finally, they are associated with better cardiovascular health and lower rates of obesity in both youth and parents. The response is dose dependent, with more regular dinners leading to better outcomes. The food can be simple, what matters most is that the tone is warm, sharing, and curious, not rigid and controlling. Families can be an essential source of support as they help put events and feelings into context, giving them meaning or a framework based on the parents’ past, values, or perspective and on the family’s cultural history. Everyone benefits as family members cope with small and large setbacks, share values, and celebrate one another’s small and large successes. The return of the family dinner table, as often as is reasonable, is one “consequence” of COVID that families should try to preserve.

Consistent virtual family visits: Many families managed the cancellation of holiday visits or supported elderly relatives by connecting with family virtually. For some families, a weekly Zoom call came to function like a weekly family dinner with cousins and grandparents. Not only do these regular video calls protect elderly relatives from loneliness and isolation, but they also made it very easy for extended families to stay connected. Children cannot have too many caring adults around them, and regular calls mean that aunts, uncles, and grandparents can be an enthusiastic audience for their achievements and can offer perspective and guidance when needed. Staying connected without having to manage hours of travel makes it easy to build and maintain these family connections, creating bonds that will be deeper and stronger. Like family dinner, regular virtual gatherings with extended family are unequivocally beneficial for younger and older children and a valuable legacy of COVID.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Lowering the pressure: Many children struggled to stay engaged with virtual school and deeply missed time with friends or in activities like woodshop, soccer, or theater. But many other children had a chance to slow down from a relentless schedule of school, homework, sports, clubs, music lessons, tutoring, and on and on. For these children, many of whom are intensely ambitious and were not willing to voluntarily give up any activities, the forced slowdown of COVID has offered a new perspective on how they might manage their time. The COVID slowdown shone a light on the value of spending enough time in an activity to really learn it, and then choosing which activities to continue to explore and master, while opening time to explore new activities. There was also more time for “senseless fun,” activities that do not lead to achievement or recognition, but are simply fun, e.g., playing video games, splashing in a pool, or surfing the web. This process is critical to healthy development in early and later adolescence, and for many driven teenagers, it has been replaced by a tightly packed schedule of activities they felt they “should” be doing. If these young people hear from you that not only does the COVID pace feel better, but it can also contribute to better health and more meaningful learning and engagement, they may adopt a more thoughtful and intentional approach to managing their most precious asset – their time. Your discussion about prioritizing healthy exercise, virtual visits with friends, hobbies, or even senseless fun might reset the pressure gauge from high to moderate.

Homework help: Many children (and teenagers) found that their parents became an important source of academic support during the year of virtual school. While few parents welcomed the chance to master calculus, it is powerful for parents to know what their children are facing at school and for children to know that their parents are available to help them when they face a challenge. When parents can bear uncertainty, frustration, and even failure alongside their children, they help their children to cultivate tenacity and resilience, whether or not they can help them with a chemistry problem. Some parents will have special skills like knowing a language, being a good writer, or an academic expertise related to their work. But what matters more is working out how to help, not pressure or argue – how to share knowledge in a pleasurable manner. While it is important for children to have access to teachers and tutors with the knowledge and skills to help them learn specific subjects, the positive presence and involvement of their parents can make a valuable contribution to their psychological and educational development.

New ritual: Over the past 16 months, families found many creative ways to pass time together, from evening walks to reading aloud, listening to music, and even mastering new card games. The family evenings of a century earlier, when family members listened together to radio programs, practiced music, or played board games, seemed to have returned. While everyone could still escape to their own space to be on a screen activity alone, solitary computer time was leavened by collective time. Families may have rediscovered joy in shared recreation, exploration, or diversion. This kind of family time is a reward in itself, but it also deepens a child’s connections to everyone in their family. Such time provides lessons in how to turn boredom into something meaningful and even fun. COVID forced families inward and gave them more time. There were many costs including illness, deaths of friends and relatives, loss of time with peers, missed activities and milestones, and an impaired education. However, many of the coerced adaptations had a silver lining or unanticipated benefit. Keeping some of those benefits post COVID could enhance the lives of every member of the family.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Topics
Sections

As your patients return to your offices for annual exams and sports physicals before the school year starts, everyone will still be processing the challenges, losses, and grief that have marked end of the COVID experience. There will be questions about the safety of vaccines for younger children, whether foreign travel is now a reasonable option, and about how best to help children – school age and teenagers, vulnerable and secure – get their footing socially and academically in the new school year. But dig a little, and you may hear about the silver linings of this past year: children who enjoyed having more time with their parents, parents who were with their families rather than in a car commuting for hours a day or traveling many days a month, grocery deliveries that eased the parent’s workload, adolescents who were able to pull back from overscheduled days, and opportunities for calm conversations that occurred quite naturally during nightly family dinners. Office visits present a dual opportunity to review – what were the psychological costs of COVID and what were positive personal and family adaptations to COVID they may want to continue as the pandemic ends?

Swick_Susan_D_CALIF_web.jpg
Dr. Susan D. Swick

Family dinner: Whether because sports practice was suspended, schooling was virtual, or working was at home, many families returned to eating dinner together during the pandemic year. Nightly dinners are a simple but powerful routine allowing all members of a family to reconnect and recharge together, and they are often the first things to disappear in the face of school, sports, and work demands. Research over the past several decades has demonstrated that regular family dinners are associated with better academic performance and higher self-esteem in children. They are also associated with lower rates of depression, substance abuse, eating disorders, and pregnancy in adolescents. Finally, they are associated with better cardiovascular health and lower rates of obesity in both youth and parents. The response is dose dependent, with more regular dinners leading to better outcomes. The food can be simple, what matters most is that the tone is warm, sharing, and curious, not rigid and controlling. Families can be an essential source of support as they help put events and feelings into context, giving them meaning or a framework based on the parents’ past, values, or perspective and on the family’s cultural history. Everyone benefits as family members cope with small and large setbacks, share values, and celebrate one another’s small and large successes. The return of the family dinner table, as often as is reasonable, is one “consequence” of COVID that families should try to preserve.

Consistent virtual family visits: Many families managed the cancellation of holiday visits or supported elderly relatives by connecting with family virtually. For some families, a weekly Zoom call came to function like a weekly family dinner with cousins and grandparents. Not only do these regular video calls protect elderly relatives from loneliness and isolation, but they also made it very easy for extended families to stay connected. Children cannot have too many caring adults around them, and regular calls mean that aunts, uncles, and grandparents can be an enthusiastic audience for their achievements and can offer perspective and guidance when needed. Staying connected without having to manage hours of travel makes it easy to build and maintain these family connections, creating bonds that will be deeper and stronger. Like family dinner, regular virtual gatherings with extended family are unequivocally beneficial for younger and older children and a valuable legacy of COVID.

Jellinek_Michael_S 2019_web.jpg
Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Lowering the pressure: Many children struggled to stay engaged with virtual school and deeply missed time with friends or in activities like woodshop, soccer, or theater. But many other children had a chance to slow down from a relentless schedule of school, homework, sports, clubs, music lessons, tutoring, and on and on. For these children, many of whom are intensely ambitious and were not willing to voluntarily give up any activities, the forced slowdown of COVID has offered a new perspective on how they might manage their time. The COVID slowdown shone a light on the value of spending enough time in an activity to really learn it, and then choosing which activities to continue to explore and master, while opening time to explore new activities. There was also more time for “senseless fun,” activities that do not lead to achievement or recognition, but are simply fun, e.g., playing video games, splashing in a pool, or surfing the web. This process is critical to healthy development in early and later adolescence, and for many driven teenagers, it has been replaced by a tightly packed schedule of activities they felt they “should” be doing. If these young people hear from you that not only does the COVID pace feel better, but it can also contribute to better health and more meaningful learning and engagement, they may adopt a more thoughtful and intentional approach to managing their most precious asset – their time. Your discussion about prioritizing healthy exercise, virtual visits with friends, hobbies, or even senseless fun might reset the pressure gauge from high to moderate.

Homework help: Many children (and teenagers) found that their parents became an important source of academic support during the year of virtual school. While few parents welcomed the chance to master calculus, it is powerful for parents to know what their children are facing at school and for children to know that their parents are available to help them when they face a challenge. When parents can bear uncertainty, frustration, and even failure alongside their children, they help their children to cultivate tenacity and resilience, whether or not they can help them with a chemistry problem. Some parents will have special skills like knowing a language, being a good writer, or an academic expertise related to their work. But what matters more is working out how to help, not pressure or argue – how to share knowledge in a pleasurable manner. While it is important for children to have access to teachers and tutors with the knowledge and skills to help them learn specific subjects, the positive presence and involvement of their parents can make a valuable contribution to their psychological and educational development.

New ritual: Over the past 16 months, families found many creative ways to pass time together, from evening walks to reading aloud, listening to music, and even mastering new card games. The family evenings of a century earlier, when family members listened together to radio programs, practiced music, or played board games, seemed to have returned. While everyone could still escape to their own space to be on a screen activity alone, solitary computer time was leavened by collective time. Families may have rediscovered joy in shared recreation, exploration, or diversion. This kind of family time is a reward in itself, but it also deepens a child’s connections to everyone in their family. Such time provides lessons in how to turn boredom into something meaningful and even fun. COVID forced families inward and gave them more time. There were many costs including illness, deaths of friends and relatives, loss of time with peers, missed activities and milestones, and an impaired education. However, many of the coerced adaptations had a silver lining or unanticipated benefit. Keeping some of those benefits post COVID could enhance the lives of every member of the family.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

As your patients return to your offices for annual exams and sports physicals before the school year starts, everyone will still be processing the challenges, losses, and grief that have marked end of the COVID experience. There will be questions about the safety of vaccines for younger children, whether foreign travel is now a reasonable option, and about how best to help children – school age and teenagers, vulnerable and secure – get their footing socially and academically in the new school year. But dig a little, and you may hear about the silver linings of this past year: children who enjoyed having more time with their parents, parents who were with their families rather than in a car commuting for hours a day or traveling many days a month, grocery deliveries that eased the parent’s workload, adolescents who were able to pull back from overscheduled days, and opportunities for calm conversations that occurred quite naturally during nightly family dinners. Office visits present a dual opportunity to review – what were the psychological costs of COVID and what were positive personal and family adaptations to COVID they may want to continue as the pandemic ends?

Dr. Susan D. Swick

Family dinner: Whether because sports practice was suspended, schooling was virtual, or working was at home, many families returned to eating dinner together during the pandemic year. Nightly dinners are a simple but powerful routine allowing all members of a family to reconnect and recharge together, and they are often the first things to disappear in the face of school, sports, and work demands. Research over the past several decades has demonstrated that regular family dinners are associated with better academic performance and higher self-esteem in children. They are also associated with lower rates of depression, substance abuse, eating disorders, and pregnancy in adolescents. Finally, they are associated with better cardiovascular health and lower rates of obesity in both youth and parents. The response is dose dependent, with more regular dinners leading to better outcomes. The food can be simple, what matters most is that the tone is warm, sharing, and curious, not rigid and controlling. Families can be an essential source of support as they help put events and feelings into context, giving them meaning or a framework based on the parents’ past, values, or perspective and on the family’s cultural history. Everyone benefits as family members cope with small and large setbacks, share values, and celebrate one another’s small and large successes. The return of the family dinner table, as often as is reasonable, is one “consequence” of COVID that families should try to preserve.

Consistent virtual family visits: Many families managed the cancellation of holiday visits or supported elderly relatives by connecting with family virtually. For some families, a weekly Zoom call came to function like a weekly family dinner with cousins and grandparents. Not only do these regular video calls protect elderly relatives from loneliness and isolation, but they also made it very easy for extended families to stay connected. Children cannot have too many caring adults around them, and regular calls mean that aunts, uncles, and grandparents can be an enthusiastic audience for their achievements and can offer perspective and guidance when needed. Staying connected without having to manage hours of travel makes it easy to build and maintain these family connections, creating bonds that will be deeper and stronger. Like family dinner, regular virtual gatherings with extended family are unequivocally beneficial for younger and older children and a valuable legacy of COVID.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Lowering the pressure: Many children struggled to stay engaged with virtual school and deeply missed time with friends or in activities like woodshop, soccer, or theater. But many other children had a chance to slow down from a relentless schedule of school, homework, sports, clubs, music lessons, tutoring, and on and on. For these children, many of whom are intensely ambitious and were not willing to voluntarily give up any activities, the forced slowdown of COVID has offered a new perspective on how they might manage their time. The COVID slowdown shone a light on the value of spending enough time in an activity to really learn it, and then choosing which activities to continue to explore and master, while opening time to explore new activities. There was also more time for “senseless fun,” activities that do not lead to achievement or recognition, but are simply fun, e.g., playing video games, splashing in a pool, or surfing the web. This process is critical to healthy development in early and later adolescence, and for many driven teenagers, it has been replaced by a tightly packed schedule of activities they felt they “should” be doing. If these young people hear from you that not only does the COVID pace feel better, but it can also contribute to better health and more meaningful learning and engagement, they may adopt a more thoughtful and intentional approach to managing their most precious asset – their time. Your discussion about prioritizing healthy exercise, virtual visits with friends, hobbies, or even senseless fun might reset the pressure gauge from high to moderate.

Homework help: Many children (and teenagers) found that their parents became an important source of academic support during the year of virtual school. While few parents welcomed the chance to master calculus, it is powerful for parents to know what their children are facing at school and for children to know that their parents are available to help them when they face a challenge. When parents can bear uncertainty, frustration, and even failure alongside their children, they help their children to cultivate tenacity and resilience, whether or not they can help them with a chemistry problem. Some parents will have special skills like knowing a language, being a good writer, or an academic expertise related to their work. But what matters more is working out how to help, not pressure or argue – how to share knowledge in a pleasurable manner. While it is important for children to have access to teachers and tutors with the knowledge and skills to help them learn specific subjects, the positive presence and involvement of their parents can make a valuable contribution to their psychological and educational development.

New ritual: Over the past 16 months, families found many creative ways to pass time together, from evening walks to reading aloud, listening to music, and even mastering new card games. The family evenings of a century earlier, when family members listened together to radio programs, practiced music, or played board games, seemed to have returned. While everyone could still escape to their own space to be on a screen activity alone, solitary computer time was leavened by collective time. Families may have rediscovered joy in shared recreation, exploration, or diversion. This kind of family time is a reward in itself, but it also deepens a child’s connections to everyone in their family. Such time provides lessons in how to turn boredom into something meaningful and even fun. COVID forced families inward and gave them more time. There were many costs including illness, deaths of friends and relatives, loss of time with peers, missed activities and milestones, and an impaired education. However, many of the coerced adaptations had a silver lining or unanticipated benefit. Keeping some of those benefits post COVID could enhance the lives of every member of the family.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

Perinatal depression and the pediatrician’s role

Article Type
Changed
Fri, 05/14/2021 - 09:09

Postpartum depression (PPD) is a common and treatable problem affecting over 10% of all pregnant women. Without routine use of a screening questionnaire, many women go undiagnosed and without treatment. The risks of untreated PPD in a new mother are the risks of depression tripled: to her health and to the health of her new infant and their whole family. Although pediatricians treat children, they take care of the whole family. They appreciate their role in offering support and guidance to new parents, and in the case of PPD, they are in a unique position. The American Academy of Pediatrics recognized this when they issued their policy statement, “Incorporating Recognition and Management of Perinatal Depression into Pediatric Practice,” in January 2019. By screening, tracking, and connecting affected mothers to care and services, you can truly provide “two-generational care” for your youngest patients.

Dr. Susan D. Swick

PPD affects an estimated one in seven women (13%) globally. In one large retrospective study that looked at the 39 weeks before and after delivery, 15.4% of mothers received a diagnosis of PPD and a second study indicated that 22% of new mothers had depressive symptoms that were persistent for 6 months.1 The pathways to PPD include prior personal or family history of depression, stressors in the family (connected to social determinants of health), previous miscarriage or serious complications in a previous pregnancy, and sensitivity to hormonal changes. Indeed, PPD is the most common complication of childbirth.2 Although as many as half of all women eventually diagnosed with PPD had symptoms during their pregnancy, the misperception that PPD is only post partum leads to it being mistaken for the normal process of adjustment to parenthood. PPD is particularly insidious as new mothers are likely to be silent if they feel shame for not enjoying what they have been told will be a special and happy time, and those around them may mistake symptoms for the normal “baby blues” that will resolve quickly and with routine supports.

Untreated PPD, creates risks for mother, infant, and family as she manages needless suffering during a critical period for her new baby. While depression may remit over months without treatment, suicide is a real risk, and accounts for 20% of postpartum deaths.3 Infants face serious developmental consequences when their mothers are withdrawn and disconnected from them during the first months of life, including impaired social development, physical growth, and cognitive development. This impairment persists. Exposure to maternal depression during infancy is associated with lower IQ, attentional problems, and special educational needs by elementary school,4 and is a risk factor for psychiatric illnesses in childhood and adolescence.5,6 PPD has a broad range of severity, including psychosis that may include paranoia with the rare risk of infanticide. And maternal depression can add to the strains in a vulnerable caregiver relationship that can raise the risk for neglect or abuse of the mother, children, or both.

It is important to note that anxiety is often the presenting problem in perinatal mood disorders, with mothers experiencing intense morbid worries about their infant’s safety and health, and fear of inadequacy, criticism, and even infant removal. These fears may reinforce silence and isolation. But pediatricians are one group that these mothers are most likely to share their anxieties with as they look for reassurance. It can be challenging to distinguish PPD from obsessive-compulsive disorder or PTSD. The critical work of the pediatrician is not specific diagnosis and treatment. Instead, your task is to provide screening and support, to create a safe place to overcome silence and shame.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

There are many reliable and valid screening instruments available for depression, but the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EDPS) has been specially developed for and tested in this population. It is a 10-item scale that is easy to complete and to score. Scores range from 0 to 30 and a score of 10 is considered a cutoff for depression. It can be used to track symptoms and is free and widely available online and in multiple languages. Ideally, this scale can be administered as part of a previsit, automatically entered into an electronic medical record and given at regular intervals during the infant’s first year of primary care. Some new mothers, especially if they are suffering from depression, may feel anxious about filling this out. It is important that your staff tell them that you screen all new mothers in your practice, and that PPD is common and treatable and the pediatrician’s office is committed to the health of the whole family.

If a new mother screens positive, you might consider yourself to have three tasks: Reassure her that she is a wonderful mother and this is a treatable illness, not a cause for guilt, shame, or alarm; expand her support and decrease her isolation by helping her to communicate with her family; and identify treatment resources for her. Start by being curious about some of her specific worries or feelings, her energy level, feelings of isolation or trouble with sleep. Offer compassion and validation around the pain of these experiences in the midst of so much transition. Only after hearing a little detail about her experience, then you may offer that such feelings are common, but when they are persistent or severe, they often indicate PPD, and that her screening test suggests they do for her. Offer that this form of depression is very treatable, with both pharmacologic and psychotherapy interventions. And if she is resistant, gently offer that treatment will be very protective of her new infant’s physical, social, and cognitive growth and development. Hearing this from a pediatrician is powerful for a new mother, even if depressed. Finally, ask if you might help her bring other important adults in her family into an understanding of this. Could she tell her spouse? Her sister? Her best friend? Perhaps she could bring one of them to the next weekly visit, so you can all speak together. This intervention greatly improves the likelihood of her engaging in treatment, and strong interpersonal connections are therapeutic in and of themselves.

For treatment, the easier your office can make it, the more likely she is to follow up. Identify local resources, perhaps through connected community organizations such as Jewish Family and Children’s Services or through a public program like California’s First Five. Connect with the local obstetric practice, which may already have a referral process in place. If you can connect with her primary care provider, they may take on the referral process or may even have integrated capacity for treatment. Identify strategies that may support her restful sleep, including realistic daily exercise, sharing infant care, and being cautious with caffeine and screen time. Identify ways for her to meet other new mothers or reconnect with friends. Reassure her that easy attachment activities, such as reading a book or singing to her baby can be good for both of them without requiring much energy. This may sound like a daunting task, but the conversation will only take a few minutes. Helping an isolated new parent recognize that their feelings of fear, inadequacy, and guilt are not facts, offering some simple immediate strategies and facilitating a referral can be lifesaving.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com

References

1. Dietz PM et al. Am J Psychiatry. 2007;164(10):1515-20.

2. Hanusa BH et al. J Women’s Health (Larchmt) 2008;17(4):585-96.

3. Lindahl V et al. Arch Womens Ment Health. 2005;8(2):77-87.

4. Hay DF et al. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2001;42(7):871-89.

5. Tully EC et al. Am J Psychiatry. 2008:165(9):1148-54.

6. Maternal depression and child development. Paediatr. Child Health 2004;9(8):575-98.

Publications
Topics
Sections

Postpartum depression (PPD) is a common and treatable problem affecting over 10% of all pregnant women. Without routine use of a screening questionnaire, many women go undiagnosed and without treatment. The risks of untreated PPD in a new mother are the risks of depression tripled: to her health and to the health of her new infant and their whole family. Although pediatricians treat children, they take care of the whole family. They appreciate their role in offering support and guidance to new parents, and in the case of PPD, they are in a unique position. The American Academy of Pediatrics recognized this when they issued their policy statement, “Incorporating Recognition and Management of Perinatal Depression into Pediatric Practice,” in January 2019. By screening, tracking, and connecting affected mothers to care and services, you can truly provide “two-generational care” for your youngest patients.

Dr. Susan D. Swick

PPD affects an estimated one in seven women (13%) globally. In one large retrospective study that looked at the 39 weeks before and after delivery, 15.4% of mothers received a diagnosis of PPD and a second study indicated that 22% of new mothers had depressive symptoms that were persistent for 6 months.1 The pathways to PPD include prior personal or family history of depression, stressors in the family (connected to social determinants of health), previous miscarriage or serious complications in a previous pregnancy, and sensitivity to hormonal changes. Indeed, PPD is the most common complication of childbirth.2 Although as many as half of all women eventually diagnosed with PPD had symptoms during their pregnancy, the misperception that PPD is only post partum leads to it being mistaken for the normal process of adjustment to parenthood. PPD is particularly insidious as new mothers are likely to be silent if they feel shame for not enjoying what they have been told will be a special and happy time, and those around them may mistake symptoms for the normal “baby blues” that will resolve quickly and with routine supports.

Untreated PPD, creates risks for mother, infant, and family as she manages needless suffering during a critical period for her new baby. While depression may remit over months without treatment, suicide is a real risk, and accounts for 20% of postpartum deaths.3 Infants face serious developmental consequences when their mothers are withdrawn and disconnected from them during the first months of life, including impaired social development, physical growth, and cognitive development. This impairment persists. Exposure to maternal depression during infancy is associated with lower IQ, attentional problems, and special educational needs by elementary school,4 and is a risk factor for psychiatric illnesses in childhood and adolescence.5,6 PPD has a broad range of severity, including psychosis that may include paranoia with the rare risk of infanticide. And maternal depression can add to the strains in a vulnerable caregiver relationship that can raise the risk for neglect or abuse of the mother, children, or both.

It is important to note that anxiety is often the presenting problem in perinatal mood disorders, with mothers experiencing intense morbid worries about their infant’s safety and health, and fear of inadequacy, criticism, and even infant removal. These fears may reinforce silence and isolation. But pediatricians are one group that these mothers are most likely to share their anxieties with as they look for reassurance. It can be challenging to distinguish PPD from obsessive-compulsive disorder or PTSD. The critical work of the pediatrician is not specific diagnosis and treatment. Instead, your task is to provide screening and support, to create a safe place to overcome silence and shame.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

There are many reliable and valid screening instruments available for depression, but the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EDPS) has been specially developed for and tested in this population. It is a 10-item scale that is easy to complete and to score. Scores range from 0 to 30 and a score of 10 is considered a cutoff for depression. It can be used to track symptoms and is free and widely available online and in multiple languages. Ideally, this scale can be administered as part of a previsit, automatically entered into an electronic medical record and given at regular intervals during the infant’s first year of primary care. Some new mothers, especially if they are suffering from depression, may feel anxious about filling this out. It is important that your staff tell them that you screen all new mothers in your practice, and that PPD is common and treatable and the pediatrician’s office is committed to the health of the whole family.

If a new mother screens positive, you might consider yourself to have three tasks: Reassure her that she is a wonderful mother and this is a treatable illness, not a cause for guilt, shame, or alarm; expand her support and decrease her isolation by helping her to communicate with her family; and identify treatment resources for her. Start by being curious about some of her specific worries or feelings, her energy level, feelings of isolation or trouble with sleep. Offer compassion and validation around the pain of these experiences in the midst of so much transition. Only after hearing a little detail about her experience, then you may offer that such feelings are common, but when they are persistent or severe, they often indicate PPD, and that her screening test suggests they do for her. Offer that this form of depression is very treatable, with both pharmacologic and psychotherapy interventions. And if she is resistant, gently offer that treatment will be very protective of her new infant’s physical, social, and cognitive growth and development. Hearing this from a pediatrician is powerful for a new mother, even if depressed. Finally, ask if you might help her bring other important adults in her family into an understanding of this. Could she tell her spouse? Her sister? Her best friend? Perhaps she could bring one of them to the next weekly visit, so you can all speak together. This intervention greatly improves the likelihood of her engaging in treatment, and strong interpersonal connections are therapeutic in and of themselves.

For treatment, the easier your office can make it, the more likely she is to follow up. Identify local resources, perhaps through connected community organizations such as Jewish Family and Children’s Services or through a public program like California’s First Five. Connect with the local obstetric practice, which may already have a referral process in place. If you can connect with her primary care provider, they may take on the referral process or may even have integrated capacity for treatment. Identify strategies that may support her restful sleep, including realistic daily exercise, sharing infant care, and being cautious with caffeine and screen time. Identify ways for her to meet other new mothers or reconnect with friends. Reassure her that easy attachment activities, such as reading a book or singing to her baby can be good for both of them without requiring much energy. This may sound like a daunting task, but the conversation will only take a few minutes. Helping an isolated new parent recognize that their feelings of fear, inadequacy, and guilt are not facts, offering some simple immediate strategies and facilitating a referral can be lifesaving.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com

References

1. Dietz PM et al. Am J Psychiatry. 2007;164(10):1515-20.

2. Hanusa BH et al. J Women’s Health (Larchmt) 2008;17(4):585-96.

3. Lindahl V et al. Arch Womens Ment Health. 2005;8(2):77-87.

4. Hay DF et al. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2001;42(7):871-89.

5. Tully EC et al. Am J Psychiatry. 2008:165(9):1148-54.

6. Maternal depression and child development. Paediatr. Child Health 2004;9(8):575-98.

Postpartum depression (PPD) is a common and treatable problem affecting over 10% of all pregnant women. Without routine use of a screening questionnaire, many women go undiagnosed and without treatment. The risks of untreated PPD in a new mother are the risks of depression tripled: to her health and to the health of her new infant and their whole family. Although pediatricians treat children, they take care of the whole family. They appreciate their role in offering support and guidance to new parents, and in the case of PPD, they are in a unique position. The American Academy of Pediatrics recognized this when they issued their policy statement, “Incorporating Recognition and Management of Perinatal Depression into Pediatric Practice,” in January 2019. By screening, tracking, and connecting affected mothers to care and services, you can truly provide “two-generational care” for your youngest patients.

Dr. Susan D. Swick

PPD affects an estimated one in seven women (13%) globally. In one large retrospective study that looked at the 39 weeks before and after delivery, 15.4% of mothers received a diagnosis of PPD and a second study indicated that 22% of new mothers had depressive symptoms that were persistent for 6 months.1 The pathways to PPD include prior personal or family history of depression, stressors in the family (connected to social determinants of health), previous miscarriage or serious complications in a previous pregnancy, and sensitivity to hormonal changes. Indeed, PPD is the most common complication of childbirth.2 Although as many as half of all women eventually diagnosed with PPD had symptoms during their pregnancy, the misperception that PPD is only post partum leads to it being mistaken for the normal process of adjustment to parenthood. PPD is particularly insidious as new mothers are likely to be silent if they feel shame for not enjoying what they have been told will be a special and happy time, and those around them may mistake symptoms for the normal “baby blues” that will resolve quickly and with routine supports.

Untreated PPD, creates risks for mother, infant, and family as she manages needless suffering during a critical period for her new baby. While depression may remit over months without treatment, suicide is a real risk, and accounts for 20% of postpartum deaths.3 Infants face serious developmental consequences when their mothers are withdrawn and disconnected from them during the first months of life, including impaired social development, physical growth, and cognitive development. This impairment persists. Exposure to maternal depression during infancy is associated with lower IQ, attentional problems, and special educational needs by elementary school,4 and is a risk factor for psychiatric illnesses in childhood and adolescence.5,6 PPD has a broad range of severity, including psychosis that may include paranoia with the rare risk of infanticide. And maternal depression can add to the strains in a vulnerable caregiver relationship that can raise the risk for neglect or abuse of the mother, children, or both.

It is important to note that anxiety is often the presenting problem in perinatal mood disorders, with mothers experiencing intense morbid worries about their infant’s safety and health, and fear of inadequacy, criticism, and even infant removal. These fears may reinforce silence and isolation. But pediatricians are one group that these mothers are most likely to share their anxieties with as they look for reassurance. It can be challenging to distinguish PPD from obsessive-compulsive disorder or PTSD. The critical work of the pediatrician is not specific diagnosis and treatment. Instead, your task is to provide screening and support, to create a safe place to overcome silence and shame.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

There are many reliable and valid screening instruments available for depression, but the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EDPS) has been specially developed for and tested in this population. It is a 10-item scale that is easy to complete and to score. Scores range from 0 to 30 and a score of 10 is considered a cutoff for depression. It can be used to track symptoms and is free and widely available online and in multiple languages. Ideally, this scale can be administered as part of a previsit, automatically entered into an electronic medical record and given at regular intervals during the infant’s first year of primary care. Some new mothers, especially if they are suffering from depression, may feel anxious about filling this out. It is important that your staff tell them that you screen all new mothers in your practice, and that PPD is common and treatable and the pediatrician’s office is committed to the health of the whole family.

If a new mother screens positive, you might consider yourself to have three tasks: Reassure her that she is a wonderful mother and this is a treatable illness, not a cause for guilt, shame, or alarm; expand her support and decrease her isolation by helping her to communicate with her family; and identify treatment resources for her. Start by being curious about some of her specific worries or feelings, her energy level, feelings of isolation or trouble with sleep. Offer compassion and validation around the pain of these experiences in the midst of so much transition. Only after hearing a little detail about her experience, then you may offer that such feelings are common, but when they are persistent or severe, they often indicate PPD, and that her screening test suggests they do for her. Offer that this form of depression is very treatable, with both pharmacologic and psychotherapy interventions. And if she is resistant, gently offer that treatment will be very protective of her new infant’s physical, social, and cognitive growth and development. Hearing this from a pediatrician is powerful for a new mother, even if depressed. Finally, ask if you might help her bring other important adults in her family into an understanding of this. Could she tell her spouse? Her sister? Her best friend? Perhaps she could bring one of them to the next weekly visit, so you can all speak together. This intervention greatly improves the likelihood of her engaging in treatment, and strong interpersonal connections are therapeutic in and of themselves.

For treatment, the easier your office can make it, the more likely she is to follow up. Identify local resources, perhaps through connected community organizations such as Jewish Family and Children’s Services or through a public program like California’s First Five. Connect with the local obstetric practice, which may already have a referral process in place. If you can connect with her primary care provider, they may take on the referral process or may even have integrated capacity for treatment. Identify strategies that may support her restful sleep, including realistic daily exercise, sharing infant care, and being cautious with caffeine and screen time. Identify ways for her to meet other new mothers or reconnect with friends. Reassure her that easy attachment activities, such as reading a book or singing to her baby can be good for both of them without requiring much energy. This may sound like a daunting task, but the conversation will only take a few minutes. Helping an isolated new parent recognize that their feelings of fear, inadequacy, and guilt are not facts, offering some simple immediate strategies and facilitating a referral can be lifesaving.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com

References

1. Dietz PM et al. Am J Psychiatry. 2007;164(10):1515-20.

2. Hanusa BH et al. J Women’s Health (Larchmt) 2008;17(4):585-96.

3. Lindahl V et al. Arch Womens Ment Health. 2005;8(2):77-87.

4. Hay DF et al. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2001;42(7):871-89.

5. Tully EC et al. Am J Psychiatry. 2008:165(9):1148-54.

6. Maternal depression and child development. Paediatr. Child Health 2004;9(8):575-98.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article

Helping parents deal with children’s transition to in-person school

Article Type
Changed
Fri, 03/12/2021 - 14:18

This spring may bring an unusual transition for families: a return to in-person school after nearly a year in a virtual classroom. This will undoubtedly come as a welcome relief to many parents worried about their children’s education and development and struggling with running school from home. But it is important for parents to remember that transitions, even happy ones, are difficult. You can help parents to anticipate what may be challenging about this transition for their children so that they are all prepared and can diminish struggles and support their children’s mastery.

Be curious about their children’s thoughts and feelings

Dr. Susan D. Swick

Parents should adopt a truly curious and open-minded approach with their children. Remind parents that, while they are experts on their own children, they should not assume they know what their children are thinking or feeling about the return to school. Some children, especially ones struggling with learning problems or difficulty with peers, will have grown very comfortable being at home with parents or siblings. Some children, especially pre- and early teens, may have changed substantially in the year and might feel uncertain about returning to a prior team or group of friends. Some children may feel concerned about leaving a pet at home alone. Some children may be going to a new school and be anxious about facing such a big transition without the usual planning and supports. Those on a college track may be worried they are “behind” academically or in college preparation.

Parents can show up when and where their children are most likely to talk, perhaps bath time or bedtime for younger children or in the car together with their adolescents. They can ask: “Have you been thinking about what it might be like to go back to school? Have your friends been chatting about it?” They might be curious together about what might have changed in a year. What might be really great about being back in a classroom? What might they miss about home school? And what might be new? Are you worried about the work, any of your friends, or not being home? If children can begin to anticipate both the good and the difficult, they will be better equipped to face and manage the challenges and appreciate the delights.

Children in elementary school are built to master new situations but are also prone to anxiety about new expectations and demands. Parents can be calmly curious about what their thoughts, feelings, and questions are and look for answers together. Often all they need is to see parents being calm in the face of uncertainty, bearing the strong feelings that may come, and preserving curiosity and compassion. Adolescents may be grieving the things they have missed, or they may have concerns about relationships and practical matters such as the implications for applying to college. Parents can offer compassion and validation and help them to devise their own strategies to face the practical challenges they are concerned about.
 

 

 

Be mindful of their children’s vulnerabilities

While most children will find the transition back to school easier than they may anticipate, there will be some for whom the transition will be very challenging. Children who have been bullied at school may have found themselves able to concentrate and learn free of the fear and stress of a classmate’s taunts or stares. Children with learning disabilities or ADHD have probably struggled with online school, but they have also likely established strategies and supports during the year that have enabled them to get enough individualized help to get their work done. These children are vulnerable to falling behind and getting discouraged when these supports are lost, and possibly not replaced with new ones in the chaos of transition. Parents should reassure their children that they will work with the school to make sure that they can succeed in the classroom as they did at home.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Children with an inhibited or shy temperament might have found that it was easier to focus and listen in the comfortable setting of home than in a busy, stimulating classroom. Children who suffer from anxiety disorders that may make separating from parents or managing the performance and social demands of school extra difficult will find the return to school especially challenging. Some younger children may have experienced the emergence of an anxiety disorder during the past year, and the return to school may mark the challenge that brings heretofore quiet symptoms into full relief.

These children have all enjoyed being able to avoid the discomfort of certain anxiety-provoking situations, and they may be particularly stressed by anticipating a return to school. Younger children may begin to have stomach aches and other physical complaints as the return to school gets close, older children may seem more withdrawn or irritable or begin discussing ways to continue school from home. Parents should help their children try to identify and describe their worries. For anxious children, having a chance to practice may be very helpful. Visiting their school, especially if it is a new school, or having a planned hangout with a friend (with appropriate precautions) is the kind of exposure that can lessen anticipatory anxiety. If this is not enough, parents should not hesitate to bring in other caring, supportive adults, such as school counselors or therapists that may be essential to helping their children face and manage what may be intense anxiety.
 

Consider routines to support their transition

Just as parents begin to return their children to an earlier bedtime toward the end of summer, it will be helpful to consider how changing certain routines will support their children now. If children will need to get up earlier to be ready for a bus or a team practice, they should start moving bedtime and wake-up time earlier gradually. Uniforms or backpacks that have not been seen for a year should be dug out. Children who are planning a return to a sport may benefit from gradually increasing their exercise or starting training now. This will have the added benefit of improving sleep and energy and fortifying children for the challenges of change. Parents might consider reaching out to other parents in the same class as their children and having a virtual conversation to share their thoughts.

If their family has developed some new “COVID routines” that they have come to enjoy, they should find a way to preserve them. Perhaps they are having dinner together more often or have established a family game night or Netflix night. Help parents consider how to avoid falling back into overscheduling their children and themselves. If they created a time to Zoom with distant or vulnerable loved ones, they might decide to continue this. School may determine some of their routines, but they should also prioritize their family connections and well-being in deciding how to schedule their days.
 

Find opportunity for mastery and meaning

As parents are listening, validating, and planning with their children, they might use this time to reflect on valuable lessons. They might point out the value of patience: Adjusting to change takes time and happens in fits and starts. It has been 12 months since many of the pandemic changes started and it will take more than a few days to adjust as schools reopen. They might point out how proud they are of what their children have been able to learn, build, or do during this year, what they admire about them. It may be a time to consider what their family may have lost and gained during the past year, what they are eager to leave behind, and what they might like to keep. And it is also a chance for parents to observe that change is an inevitable part of life (especially when growing up). It is always challenging, and often brings loss and sadness. But if we pay attention, there are also the green shoots of what is new and possible.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Topics
Sections

This spring may bring an unusual transition for families: a return to in-person school after nearly a year in a virtual classroom. This will undoubtedly come as a welcome relief to many parents worried about their children’s education and development and struggling with running school from home. But it is important for parents to remember that transitions, even happy ones, are difficult. You can help parents to anticipate what may be challenging about this transition for their children so that they are all prepared and can diminish struggles and support their children’s mastery.

Be curious about their children’s thoughts and feelings

Dr. Susan D. Swick

Parents should adopt a truly curious and open-minded approach with their children. Remind parents that, while they are experts on their own children, they should not assume they know what their children are thinking or feeling about the return to school. Some children, especially ones struggling with learning problems or difficulty with peers, will have grown very comfortable being at home with parents or siblings. Some children, especially pre- and early teens, may have changed substantially in the year and might feel uncertain about returning to a prior team or group of friends. Some children may feel concerned about leaving a pet at home alone. Some children may be going to a new school and be anxious about facing such a big transition without the usual planning and supports. Those on a college track may be worried they are “behind” academically or in college preparation.

Parents can show up when and where their children are most likely to talk, perhaps bath time or bedtime for younger children or in the car together with their adolescents. They can ask: “Have you been thinking about what it might be like to go back to school? Have your friends been chatting about it?” They might be curious together about what might have changed in a year. What might be really great about being back in a classroom? What might they miss about home school? And what might be new? Are you worried about the work, any of your friends, or not being home? If children can begin to anticipate both the good and the difficult, they will be better equipped to face and manage the challenges and appreciate the delights.

Children in elementary school are built to master new situations but are also prone to anxiety about new expectations and demands. Parents can be calmly curious about what their thoughts, feelings, and questions are and look for answers together. Often all they need is to see parents being calm in the face of uncertainty, bearing the strong feelings that may come, and preserving curiosity and compassion. Adolescents may be grieving the things they have missed, or they may have concerns about relationships and practical matters such as the implications for applying to college. Parents can offer compassion and validation and help them to devise their own strategies to face the practical challenges they are concerned about.
 

 

 

Be mindful of their children’s vulnerabilities

While most children will find the transition back to school easier than they may anticipate, there will be some for whom the transition will be very challenging. Children who have been bullied at school may have found themselves able to concentrate and learn free of the fear and stress of a classmate’s taunts or stares. Children with learning disabilities or ADHD have probably struggled with online school, but they have also likely established strategies and supports during the year that have enabled them to get enough individualized help to get their work done. These children are vulnerable to falling behind and getting discouraged when these supports are lost, and possibly not replaced with new ones in the chaos of transition. Parents should reassure their children that they will work with the school to make sure that they can succeed in the classroom as they did at home.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Children with an inhibited or shy temperament might have found that it was easier to focus and listen in the comfortable setting of home than in a busy, stimulating classroom. Children who suffer from anxiety disorders that may make separating from parents or managing the performance and social demands of school extra difficult will find the return to school especially challenging. Some younger children may have experienced the emergence of an anxiety disorder during the past year, and the return to school may mark the challenge that brings heretofore quiet symptoms into full relief.

These children have all enjoyed being able to avoid the discomfort of certain anxiety-provoking situations, and they may be particularly stressed by anticipating a return to school. Younger children may begin to have stomach aches and other physical complaints as the return to school gets close, older children may seem more withdrawn or irritable or begin discussing ways to continue school from home. Parents should help their children try to identify and describe their worries. For anxious children, having a chance to practice may be very helpful. Visiting their school, especially if it is a new school, or having a planned hangout with a friend (with appropriate precautions) is the kind of exposure that can lessen anticipatory anxiety. If this is not enough, parents should not hesitate to bring in other caring, supportive adults, such as school counselors or therapists that may be essential to helping their children face and manage what may be intense anxiety.
 

Consider routines to support their transition

Just as parents begin to return their children to an earlier bedtime toward the end of summer, it will be helpful to consider how changing certain routines will support their children now. If children will need to get up earlier to be ready for a bus or a team practice, they should start moving bedtime and wake-up time earlier gradually. Uniforms or backpacks that have not been seen for a year should be dug out. Children who are planning a return to a sport may benefit from gradually increasing their exercise or starting training now. This will have the added benefit of improving sleep and energy and fortifying children for the challenges of change. Parents might consider reaching out to other parents in the same class as their children and having a virtual conversation to share their thoughts.

If their family has developed some new “COVID routines” that they have come to enjoy, they should find a way to preserve them. Perhaps they are having dinner together more often or have established a family game night or Netflix night. Help parents consider how to avoid falling back into overscheduling their children and themselves. If they created a time to Zoom with distant or vulnerable loved ones, they might decide to continue this. School may determine some of their routines, but they should also prioritize their family connections and well-being in deciding how to schedule their days.
 

Find opportunity for mastery and meaning

As parents are listening, validating, and planning with their children, they might use this time to reflect on valuable lessons. They might point out the value of patience: Adjusting to change takes time and happens in fits and starts. It has been 12 months since many of the pandemic changes started and it will take more than a few days to adjust as schools reopen. They might point out how proud they are of what their children have been able to learn, build, or do during this year, what they admire about them. It may be a time to consider what their family may have lost and gained during the past year, what they are eager to leave behind, and what they might like to keep. And it is also a chance for parents to observe that change is an inevitable part of life (especially when growing up). It is always challenging, and often brings loss and sadness. But if we pay attention, there are also the green shoots of what is new and possible.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

This spring may bring an unusual transition for families: a return to in-person school after nearly a year in a virtual classroom. This will undoubtedly come as a welcome relief to many parents worried about their children’s education and development and struggling with running school from home. But it is important for parents to remember that transitions, even happy ones, are difficult. You can help parents to anticipate what may be challenging about this transition for their children so that they are all prepared and can diminish struggles and support their children’s mastery.

Be curious about their children’s thoughts and feelings

Dr. Susan D. Swick

Parents should adopt a truly curious and open-minded approach with their children. Remind parents that, while they are experts on their own children, they should not assume they know what their children are thinking or feeling about the return to school. Some children, especially ones struggling with learning problems or difficulty with peers, will have grown very comfortable being at home with parents or siblings. Some children, especially pre- and early teens, may have changed substantially in the year and might feel uncertain about returning to a prior team or group of friends. Some children may feel concerned about leaving a pet at home alone. Some children may be going to a new school and be anxious about facing such a big transition without the usual planning and supports. Those on a college track may be worried they are “behind” academically or in college preparation.

Parents can show up when and where their children are most likely to talk, perhaps bath time or bedtime for younger children or in the car together with their adolescents. They can ask: “Have you been thinking about what it might be like to go back to school? Have your friends been chatting about it?” They might be curious together about what might have changed in a year. What might be really great about being back in a classroom? What might they miss about home school? And what might be new? Are you worried about the work, any of your friends, or not being home? If children can begin to anticipate both the good and the difficult, they will be better equipped to face and manage the challenges and appreciate the delights.

Children in elementary school are built to master new situations but are also prone to anxiety about new expectations and demands. Parents can be calmly curious about what their thoughts, feelings, and questions are and look for answers together. Often all they need is to see parents being calm in the face of uncertainty, bearing the strong feelings that may come, and preserving curiosity and compassion. Adolescents may be grieving the things they have missed, or they may have concerns about relationships and practical matters such as the implications for applying to college. Parents can offer compassion and validation and help them to devise their own strategies to face the practical challenges they are concerned about.
 

 

 

Be mindful of their children’s vulnerabilities

While most children will find the transition back to school easier than they may anticipate, there will be some for whom the transition will be very challenging. Children who have been bullied at school may have found themselves able to concentrate and learn free of the fear and stress of a classmate’s taunts or stares. Children with learning disabilities or ADHD have probably struggled with online school, but they have also likely established strategies and supports during the year that have enabled them to get enough individualized help to get their work done. These children are vulnerable to falling behind and getting discouraged when these supports are lost, and possibly not replaced with new ones in the chaos of transition. Parents should reassure their children that they will work with the school to make sure that they can succeed in the classroom as they did at home.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

Children with an inhibited or shy temperament might have found that it was easier to focus and listen in the comfortable setting of home than in a busy, stimulating classroom. Children who suffer from anxiety disorders that may make separating from parents or managing the performance and social demands of school extra difficult will find the return to school especially challenging. Some younger children may have experienced the emergence of an anxiety disorder during the past year, and the return to school may mark the challenge that brings heretofore quiet symptoms into full relief.

These children have all enjoyed being able to avoid the discomfort of certain anxiety-provoking situations, and they may be particularly stressed by anticipating a return to school. Younger children may begin to have stomach aches and other physical complaints as the return to school gets close, older children may seem more withdrawn or irritable or begin discussing ways to continue school from home. Parents should help their children try to identify and describe their worries. For anxious children, having a chance to practice may be very helpful. Visiting their school, especially if it is a new school, or having a planned hangout with a friend (with appropriate precautions) is the kind of exposure that can lessen anticipatory anxiety. If this is not enough, parents should not hesitate to bring in other caring, supportive adults, such as school counselors or therapists that may be essential to helping their children face and manage what may be intense anxiety.
 

Consider routines to support their transition

Just as parents begin to return their children to an earlier bedtime toward the end of summer, it will be helpful to consider how changing certain routines will support their children now. If children will need to get up earlier to be ready for a bus or a team practice, they should start moving bedtime and wake-up time earlier gradually. Uniforms or backpacks that have not been seen for a year should be dug out. Children who are planning a return to a sport may benefit from gradually increasing their exercise or starting training now. This will have the added benefit of improving sleep and energy and fortifying children for the challenges of change. Parents might consider reaching out to other parents in the same class as their children and having a virtual conversation to share their thoughts.

If their family has developed some new “COVID routines” that they have come to enjoy, they should find a way to preserve them. Perhaps they are having dinner together more often or have established a family game night or Netflix night. Help parents consider how to avoid falling back into overscheduling their children and themselves. If they created a time to Zoom with distant or vulnerable loved ones, they might decide to continue this. School may determine some of their routines, but they should also prioritize their family connections and well-being in deciding how to schedule their days.
 

Find opportunity for mastery and meaning

As parents are listening, validating, and planning with their children, they might use this time to reflect on valuable lessons. They might point out the value of patience: Adjusting to change takes time and happens in fits and starts. It has been 12 months since many of the pandemic changes started and it will take more than a few days to adjust as schools reopen. They might point out how proud they are of what their children have been able to learn, build, or do during this year, what they admire about them. It may be a time to consider what their family may have lost and gained during the past year, what they are eager to leave behind, and what they might like to keep. And it is also a chance for parents to observe that change is an inevitable part of life (especially when growing up). It is always challenging, and often brings loss and sadness. But if we pay attention, there are also the green shoots of what is new and possible.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content

Schools, COVID-19, and Jan. 6, 2021

Article Type
Changed
Tue, 01/19/2021 - 14:39

The first weeks of 2021 have us considering how best to face compound challenges and we expect parents will be looking to their pediatricians for guidance. There are daily stories of the COVID-19 death toll, an abstraction made real by tragic stories of shattered families. Most families are approaching the first anniversary of their children being in virtual school, with growing concerns about the quality of virtual education, loss of socialization and group activities, and additional risks facing poor and vulnerable children. There are real concerns about the future impact of children spending so much time every day on their screens for school, extracurricular activities, social time, and relaxation. While the COVID-19 vaccines promise a return to “normal” sometime in 2021, in-person school may not return until late in the spring or next fall.

Dr. Susan D. Swick

After the events of Jan. 6, families face an additional challenge: Discussing the violent invasion of the U.S. Capitol by the president’s supporters. This event was shocking, frightening, and confusing for most, and continues to be heavily covered in the news and online. There is a light in all this darkness. We have the opportunity to talk with our children – and to share explanations, perspectives, values, and even the discomfort of the unknowns – about COVID-19, use of the Internet, and the violence of Jan 6. We will consider how parents can approach this challenge for three age groups. With each group, parents will need to be calm and curious and will need time to give their children their full attention. We are all living through history. When parents can be fully present with their children, even for short periods at meals or at bedtime, it will help all to get their balance back and start to make sense of the extraordinary events we have been facing.

The youngest children (aged 3-6 years), those who were in preschool or kindergarten before the pandemic, need the most from their parents during this time. If they are attending school virtually, their online school days are likely short and challenging. Children at this age are mastering behavior rather than cognitive tasks. They are learning how to manage their bodies in space (stay in their seats!), how to be patient and kind (take turns!), and how to manage frustration (math is hard, try again!). Without the physical presence of their teacher and classmates, these lessons are tougher to internalize. Given their age-appropriate short attention spans, they often walk away from a screen, even if it’s class time. They are more likely to be paying attention to their parents, responding to the emotional climate at home. Even if they are not watching news websites themselves, they are likely to have overheard or noticed the news about recent events. Parents of young children should take care to turn off the television or their own computer, as repeated frightening videos of the insurrection can cause their children to worry that these events continue to unfold. These children need their parents’ undivided attention, even just for a little while. Play a board game with them (good chance to stay in their seats, take turns, and manage losing). Or get them outside for some physical play. While playing, parents can ask what they have seen, heard, or understand about what happened in the Capitol. Then they can correct misperceptions that might be frightening and offer reasonable reassurances in language these young children can understand. They might tell their children that sometimes people get angry when they have lost, and even adults can behave badly and make mistakes. They can focus on who the helpers are, and what they could do to help also. They could write letters of appreciation to their elected officials or to the Capitol police who were so brave in protecting others. If their children are curious, parents can find books or videos that are age appropriate about the Constitution and how elections work in a democracy. Parents don’t need to be able to answer every question, watching “Schoolhouse Rock” videos on YouTube together is a wonderful way to complement their online school and support their healthy development.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

School-aged children (7-12 years) are developmentally focused on mastery experiences, whether they are social, academic, or athletic. They may be better equipped to pay attention and do homework than their younger siblings, but they will miss building friendships and having a real audience for their efforts as they build emotional maturity. They are prone to worry and distress about the big events that they can understand, at least in concrete terms, but have never faced before. These children usually have been able to use social media and online games to stay connected to friends, but they are less likely than their older siblings to independently exercise or explore new interests without a parent or teacher to guide and support them. These children are likely to be spending a lot of their time online on websites their parents don’t know about, and most likely to be curious about the events of Jan. 6. Parents should close their own device and invite their school-age children to show them what they are working on in school. Be curious about all of it, even how they are doing gym or music class. Then ask about what they have seen or heard about the election and its aftermath at school, from friends, or on their own. Let them be the teachers about what happened and how they learned about it. Parents can correct misinformation or offer reliable sources of information they can investigate together. What they will need is validation of the difficult feelings that events like these can cause; that is, acknowledgment, acceptance, and understanding of big feelings, without trying to just make those feelings go away. Parents might help them to be curious about what can make people get angry, break laws, and even hurt others, and how we protest injustices in a democracy. These children may be ready to take a deeper dive into history, via a good film or documentary, with their parents’ company for discussion afterward. Be their audience and model curiosity and patience, all the while validating the feelings that might arise.

Teenagers are developmentally focused on building their own identities, cultivating independence, and deeper relationships beyond their family. While they may be well equipped to manage online learning and to stay connected to their friends and teachers through electronic means, they are also facing considerable challenge, as their ability to explore new interests, build new relationships, and be meaningfully independent has been profoundly restrained over the past year. And they are facing other losses, as milestones like proms, performances, and competitions have been altered or missed. Parents still know when their teenager is most likely to talk, and they should check in with them during those times. They can ask them about what classes are working online and which ones aren’t, and what extracurriculars are still possible. They should not be discouraged if their teenager only offers cursory responses, it matters that they are showing up and showing interest. The election and its aftermath provide a meaningful matter to discuss; parents can find out if it is being discussed by any teachers or friends. What do they think triggered the events of Jan. 6? Who should be held responsible? How to reasonably protest injustice? What does a society do when citizens can’t agree on facts? More than offering reassurance, parents should be curious about their adolescent’s developing identity and their values, how they are thinking about complex issues around free speech and justice. It is a wonderful opportunity for parents to learn about their adolescent’s emerging identity, to be tolerant of their autonomy, and an opportunity to offer their perspective and values.

At every age, parents need to be present by listening and drawing their children out without distraction. Now is a time to build relationships and to use the difficult events of the day to shed light on deeper issues and values. This is hard, but far better than having children deal with these issues in darkness or alone.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics at Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Topics
Sections

The first weeks of 2021 have us considering how best to face compound challenges and we expect parents will be looking to their pediatricians for guidance. There are daily stories of the COVID-19 death toll, an abstraction made real by tragic stories of shattered families. Most families are approaching the first anniversary of their children being in virtual school, with growing concerns about the quality of virtual education, loss of socialization and group activities, and additional risks facing poor and vulnerable children. There are real concerns about the future impact of children spending so much time every day on their screens for school, extracurricular activities, social time, and relaxation. While the COVID-19 vaccines promise a return to “normal” sometime in 2021, in-person school may not return until late in the spring or next fall.

Dr. Susan D. Swick

After the events of Jan. 6, families face an additional challenge: Discussing the violent invasion of the U.S. Capitol by the president’s supporters. This event was shocking, frightening, and confusing for most, and continues to be heavily covered in the news and online. There is a light in all this darkness. We have the opportunity to talk with our children – and to share explanations, perspectives, values, and even the discomfort of the unknowns – about COVID-19, use of the Internet, and the violence of Jan 6. We will consider how parents can approach this challenge for three age groups. With each group, parents will need to be calm and curious and will need time to give their children their full attention. We are all living through history. When parents can be fully present with their children, even for short periods at meals or at bedtime, it will help all to get their balance back and start to make sense of the extraordinary events we have been facing.

The youngest children (aged 3-6 years), those who were in preschool or kindergarten before the pandemic, need the most from their parents during this time. If they are attending school virtually, their online school days are likely short and challenging. Children at this age are mastering behavior rather than cognitive tasks. They are learning how to manage their bodies in space (stay in their seats!), how to be patient and kind (take turns!), and how to manage frustration (math is hard, try again!). Without the physical presence of their teacher and classmates, these lessons are tougher to internalize. Given their age-appropriate short attention spans, they often walk away from a screen, even if it’s class time. They are more likely to be paying attention to their parents, responding to the emotional climate at home. Even if they are not watching news websites themselves, they are likely to have overheard or noticed the news about recent events. Parents of young children should take care to turn off the television or their own computer, as repeated frightening videos of the insurrection can cause their children to worry that these events continue to unfold. These children need their parents’ undivided attention, even just for a little while. Play a board game with them (good chance to stay in their seats, take turns, and manage losing). Or get them outside for some physical play. While playing, parents can ask what they have seen, heard, or understand about what happened in the Capitol. Then they can correct misperceptions that might be frightening and offer reasonable reassurances in language these young children can understand. They might tell their children that sometimes people get angry when they have lost, and even adults can behave badly and make mistakes. They can focus on who the helpers are, and what they could do to help also. They could write letters of appreciation to their elected officials or to the Capitol police who were so brave in protecting others. If their children are curious, parents can find books or videos that are age appropriate about the Constitution and how elections work in a democracy. Parents don’t need to be able to answer every question, watching “Schoolhouse Rock” videos on YouTube together is a wonderful way to complement their online school and support their healthy development.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

School-aged children (7-12 years) are developmentally focused on mastery experiences, whether they are social, academic, or athletic. They may be better equipped to pay attention and do homework than their younger siblings, but they will miss building friendships and having a real audience for their efforts as they build emotional maturity. They are prone to worry and distress about the big events that they can understand, at least in concrete terms, but have never faced before. These children usually have been able to use social media and online games to stay connected to friends, but they are less likely than their older siblings to independently exercise or explore new interests without a parent or teacher to guide and support them. These children are likely to be spending a lot of their time online on websites their parents don’t know about, and most likely to be curious about the events of Jan. 6. Parents should close their own device and invite their school-age children to show them what they are working on in school. Be curious about all of it, even how they are doing gym or music class. Then ask about what they have seen or heard about the election and its aftermath at school, from friends, or on their own. Let them be the teachers about what happened and how they learned about it. Parents can correct misinformation or offer reliable sources of information they can investigate together. What they will need is validation of the difficult feelings that events like these can cause; that is, acknowledgment, acceptance, and understanding of big feelings, without trying to just make those feelings go away. Parents might help them to be curious about what can make people get angry, break laws, and even hurt others, and how we protest injustices in a democracy. These children may be ready to take a deeper dive into history, via a good film or documentary, with their parents’ company for discussion afterward. Be their audience and model curiosity and patience, all the while validating the feelings that might arise.

Teenagers are developmentally focused on building their own identities, cultivating independence, and deeper relationships beyond their family. While they may be well equipped to manage online learning and to stay connected to their friends and teachers through electronic means, they are also facing considerable challenge, as their ability to explore new interests, build new relationships, and be meaningfully independent has been profoundly restrained over the past year. And they are facing other losses, as milestones like proms, performances, and competitions have been altered or missed. Parents still know when their teenager is most likely to talk, and they should check in with them during those times. They can ask them about what classes are working online and which ones aren’t, and what extracurriculars are still possible. They should not be discouraged if their teenager only offers cursory responses, it matters that they are showing up and showing interest. The election and its aftermath provide a meaningful matter to discuss; parents can find out if it is being discussed by any teachers or friends. What do they think triggered the events of Jan. 6? Who should be held responsible? How to reasonably protest injustice? What does a society do when citizens can’t agree on facts? More than offering reassurance, parents should be curious about their adolescent’s developing identity and their values, how they are thinking about complex issues around free speech and justice. It is a wonderful opportunity for parents to learn about their adolescent’s emerging identity, to be tolerant of their autonomy, and an opportunity to offer their perspective and values.

At every age, parents need to be present by listening and drawing their children out without distraction. Now is a time to build relationships and to use the difficult events of the day to shed light on deeper issues and values. This is hard, but far better than having children deal with these issues in darkness or alone.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics at Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

The first weeks of 2021 have us considering how best to face compound challenges and we expect parents will be looking to their pediatricians for guidance. There are daily stories of the COVID-19 death toll, an abstraction made real by tragic stories of shattered families. Most families are approaching the first anniversary of their children being in virtual school, with growing concerns about the quality of virtual education, loss of socialization and group activities, and additional risks facing poor and vulnerable children. There are real concerns about the future impact of children spending so much time every day on their screens for school, extracurricular activities, social time, and relaxation. While the COVID-19 vaccines promise a return to “normal” sometime in 2021, in-person school may not return until late in the spring or next fall.

Dr. Susan D. Swick

After the events of Jan. 6, families face an additional challenge: Discussing the violent invasion of the U.S. Capitol by the president’s supporters. This event was shocking, frightening, and confusing for most, and continues to be heavily covered in the news and online. There is a light in all this darkness. We have the opportunity to talk with our children – and to share explanations, perspectives, values, and even the discomfort of the unknowns – about COVID-19, use of the Internet, and the violence of Jan 6. We will consider how parents can approach this challenge for three age groups. With each group, parents will need to be calm and curious and will need time to give their children their full attention. We are all living through history. When parents can be fully present with their children, even for short periods at meals or at bedtime, it will help all to get their balance back and start to make sense of the extraordinary events we have been facing.

The youngest children (aged 3-6 years), those who were in preschool or kindergarten before the pandemic, need the most from their parents during this time. If they are attending school virtually, their online school days are likely short and challenging. Children at this age are mastering behavior rather than cognitive tasks. They are learning how to manage their bodies in space (stay in their seats!), how to be patient and kind (take turns!), and how to manage frustration (math is hard, try again!). Without the physical presence of their teacher and classmates, these lessons are tougher to internalize. Given their age-appropriate short attention spans, they often walk away from a screen, even if it’s class time. They are more likely to be paying attention to their parents, responding to the emotional climate at home. Even if they are not watching news websites themselves, they are likely to have overheard or noticed the news about recent events. Parents of young children should take care to turn off the television or their own computer, as repeated frightening videos of the insurrection can cause their children to worry that these events continue to unfold. These children need their parents’ undivided attention, even just for a little while. Play a board game with them (good chance to stay in their seats, take turns, and manage losing). Or get them outside for some physical play. While playing, parents can ask what they have seen, heard, or understand about what happened in the Capitol. Then they can correct misperceptions that might be frightening and offer reasonable reassurances in language these young children can understand. They might tell their children that sometimes people get angry when they have lost, and even adults can behave badly and make mistakes. They can focus on who the helpers are, and what they could do to help also. They could write letters of appreciation to their elected officials or to the Capitol police who were so brave in protecting others. If their children are curious, parents can find books or videos that are age appropriate about the Constitution and how elections work in a democracy. Parents don’t need to be able to answer every question, watching “Schoolhouse Rock” videos on YouTube together is a wonderful way to complement their online school and support their healthy development.

Dr. Michael S. Jellinek

School-aged children (7-12 years) are developmentally focused on mastery experiences, whether they are social, academic, or athletic. They may be better equipped to pay attention and do homework than their younger siblings, but they will miss building friendships and having a real audience for their efforts as they build emotional maturity. They are prone to worry and distress about the big events that they can understand, at least in concrete terms, but have never faced before. These children usually have been able to use social media and online games to stay connected to friends, but they are less likely than their older siblings to independently exercise or explore new interests without a parent or teacher to guide and support them. These children are likely to be spending a lot of their time online on websites their parents don’t know about, and most likely to be curious about the events of Jan. 6. Parents should close their own device and invite their school-age children to show them what they are working on in school. Be curious about all of it, even how they are doing gym or music class. Then ask about what they have seen or heard about the election and its aftermath at school, from friends, or on their own. Let them be the teachers about what happened and how they learned about it. Parents can correct misinformation or offer reliable sources of information they can investigate together. What they will need is validation of the difficult feelings that events like these can cause; that is, acknowledgment, acceptance, and understanding of big feelings, without trying to just make those feelings go away. Parents might help them to be curious about what can make people get angry, break laws, and even hurt others, and how we protest injustices in a democracy. These children may be ready to take a deeper dive into history, via a good film or documentary, with their parents’ company for discussion afterward. Be their audience and model curiosity and patience, all the while validating the feelings that might arise.

Teenagers are developmentally focused on building their own identities, cultivating independence, and deeper relationships beyond their family. While they may be well equipped to manage online learning and to stay connected to their friends and teachers through electronic means, they are also facing considerable challenge, as their ability to explore new interests, build new relationships, and be meaningfully independent has been profoundly restrained over the past year. And they are facing other losses, as milestones like proms, performances, and competitions have been altered or missed. Parents still know when their teenager is most likely to talk, and they should check in with them during those times. They can ask them about what classes are working online and which ones aren’t, and what extracurriculars are still possible. They should not be discouraged if their teenager only offers cursory responses, it matters that they are showing up and showing interest. The election and its aftermath provide a meaningful matter to discuss; parents can find out if it is being discussed by any teachers or friends. What do they think triggered the events of Jan. 6? Who should be held responsible? How to reasonably protest injustice? What does a society do when citizens can’t agree on facts? More than offering reassurance, parents should be curious about their adolescent’s developing identity and their values, how they are thinking about complex issues around free speech and justice. It is a wonderful opportunity for parents to learn about their adolescent’s emerging identity, to be tolerant of their autonomy, and an opportunity to offer their perspective and values.

At every age, parents need to be present by listening and drawing their children out without distraction. Now is a time to build relationships and to use the difficult events of the day to shed light on deeper issues and values. This is hard, but far better than having children deal with these issues in darkness or alone.

Dr. Swick is physician in chief at Ohana, Center for Child and Adolescent Behavioral Health, Community Hospital of the Monterey (Calif.) Peninsula. Dr. Jellinek is professor emeritus of psychiatry and pediatrics at Harvard Medical School, Boston. Email them at pdnews@mdedge.com.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Use ProPublica
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article